I had a BK Fish sandwich once and it nearly made me puke. I think it is worse than the Filet-o-fish.
Yeah, Lent is the big Filet o’ Fish sales time. I’ve seen some McDonald’s also discount it regularly on Fridays when located in heavily Catholic areas.
They used half-slices in the 1970s and 80s, too, at my local locations.
Fillet-O-Fish Fridays makes Lent awesome. I’ll usually give up fast food except for the FoF.
It most certainly is worse than the FOF.
I tried one once and it seemed to be soaked in some lemony liquid to hid the awful fishy taste.
Not good. Yuck.
FOF is the good stuff! (Well, for me anyway.) 
I like White Castle burgers. But I don’t like the way the onion-and-grease flavor hangs around for another half a day or so.
I don’t think I’ve ever had a filet-o-fish sandwich, and I don’t think I ever will.
What??? No! I love the Filet o’ Fish!! Love it! As far as fast food items go, its in my top 5
I loves me some FOF, loves (I scrape off the sauce)! So I figured how bad could the BK version be? Let me tell you - it’s bad.
Butter Burger. What is wrong with people?
I don’t know about Filet O Fish as I despise seafood in any form, even fast food approximations thereof… I’ve absolutely got to agree with this, though. Of all the other forms of fast food I’ve sampled, White Castle has got to be the most vile thing I can imagine. Or, down south, Krystal, which is roughly equivalent as far as I can tell.
And yet I have a friend who drove 200 miles solely to eat at White Castle (no, his name is not Harold, nor is it Kumar) because he loves it so much. He also buys those frozen White Castle sliders in the supermarket and claims to have perfected the art of reconstituting them into something close to the original. The whole thing boggles my mind.
We’ve got a local burger joint that serves a great double cheeseburger, awesome fries, and a drink of your choice, for 5 bucks. Surely other areas have such things. Don’t understand why someone would go for typical fast food fare unless they’re travelling and don’t know the local places that have much better, just as quick food, for cheaper. :dubious:
Count me as another vote in favor of the FoF. One of my favorite fast food sammitches. I think they did reduce the size of the patties a few years ago though; maybe Squarefish stocks are running low.
McD’s offered a double FoF for a short time in the Houston area last year; like you, I thought it was going to be Nirvana, but it was somehow…off. incorrect fish to tartar sauce ratio or something. I prefer the classic single.
Filet-o-Fish was created specifically for Lent. It was one of the first deviations McDonald’s made from its hamburger menu. The menu was set in stone up until then.
I’ve had one, recommended by a Cheesehead cow-orker. Overpriced and ordinary plus frozen custard that is more of the same. There’s a Culver’s where my Long John Silver’s used to be, in the same lot as my grocery store, and I’ve been there once. But, yearly, when they start advertising Walleye, my Minnesota head starts to turn, until I recall that Pike ARE ALL FREAKING BONES!
Love 'em. Only eat a couple a year though.
Still remember eating them when I was about 8 or 10. Early sixties.
I’m with Alice. FOF are what I eat when I go to work too sick to eat breakfast or pack a lunch but eventually need to eat something to get through the rest of the day.
Another “fan” of the FoF. Fan perhaps being too strong a word, but it is the only fast food fish sandwich I can tolerate and it is probably my favorite thing ( very low bar ) at McD. Old ones that have dried out in the bin are dire, however. I have occasionally gotten virtually inedible examples.
Back when I worked at said fine dining establishment in the mid-1980’s a half-slice of cheese was indeed standard. I tried a full slice a couple of times and it didn’t work - it upset that delicate balance between cheap cheese, cheap fried fish and cheap tartar sauce :D.
I love fish. McDonald’s Filet o’ Fish sandwich is horrible. Burger King’s version is even worse.
Good God! I got rid of my gall bladder 20 years ago and you can still eat that shit while the ghost of mine says, “You fried potatoes in schmaltz and butter?” without saying, “Get ready to run in the next half hour?”
I guess I’m all alone here, because I like BK fish. Though whenever I order one at the drive thru, I have to go park and wait until they cook it and bring it out to me. I bought some frozen White Castle burgers for my husband and heated them per instructions, and I have seldom seen him become so ill. He was sick for two days. I don’t know what all that was about, but I guess I’m taking frozen White Castle burgers out of rotation.
You’re not supposed to enjoy a filet-o-fish. You eat them to do penance.
I used to work there. If made fresh (with new grease) they are really good. That goes for everything at BK.
I’ll betray my BK brethren by telling you this but if you order something fresh they will make it from scratch, from Whopper to BK Fish it’ll take a little longer but it’ll be worth it.
Try a Whopper fresh and see what I mean.