Wildest Bill wrote:
I see what your saying but in all fairness I have seen people poking fun at the Christian faith also around here. I don’t take it so personally. I have not had a lot of time to research on Odin but I can see it is a “real” type religion for people around the Norwegian area. If I wrong on that, I am almost positive someone will correct me. So I take back my comment I made about it at the time I really thought it was like “the force” or something ok?
Fair enough. But there are modern worshipper/followers of the Asatru here in the States, the Asatru Free Assembly being one (if they’re still around, not sure…)
Further WB said:
Who are your “gods”? And how come you don’t capitalize them when you refer to them? I am not being a smart alec I really want to know why and who they are? And what happens to the Wiccas when you die?
Fair enough. I follow Freyr and Lady Athene. Freyr picked me out during a Winter Solstice ritual in '84. I’ve been learning about him ever since. If you want to know joy, laughter, good times and sex, Freyr is great!
I choose Athene for two reasons, 1) in honor of my Greek heritage (my paternal g’father was a Greek immigrant to this country and 2) because of scholarship. Lady Athene is the matron of the scholary arts.
As for the afterlife, look up the thread on the afterlife in Great Debates. Sorry, I don’t have the link readily available. I’ll post it later.
As for capitalization, I dunno… never thought about it. I don’t see the necessity.
Then WB wrote:
I don’t follow you. Either your right and I am wrong. Or vice versa. Either my God is real or yours. It doesn’t really matter who is right or wrong until we die. Then we know what God was real or not. Right?
Wrong. The problem here is you don’t grasp the concept of polytheism. There are two groups of people on this board, the theists, people who believe in the gods and atheists, those who don’t. I apologize to the agnostics who, for the moment, I’m lumping in with the atheists. Please don’t take offense.
Looking under the category of theists, it divides further into monotheists, such as yourself who believe in only one God (capitalized just for you!). Then there are those, such as myself who believe in many gods.
I don’t recall where in history the one god of the tribes of Isreal started being the One True God as many Xians view him now. Poly, Tris, CMK, Lib, any help here? But if you look thru the OT, you’ll find that the existence and efficacy of the other gods is not doubted, just that they are not the gods of the Isreal. Check out Stanley Tambiah’s Magic, Science, Religion and the Scope of Rationality for a discussion of this.
To summarize, you believe in the one God who denys the existence of all others (supposedly). I believe in many gods of which your one God is one of many. Does that explain it?
Even further WB wrote (regarding interpretations of Revelations):
I am a Christian. What other qualification is needed? And btw I wasn’t trying to prove anything I just asked a question if you would take the mark of the anti-christ. I don’t think I need to be scholar to ask that do I? It is a simple question yes or no.
The point I’m trying to make about Revelations is this. It was written almost 2000 years ago by one man of a very different time and place than we of the 20th century. How do you know what he means?
An example. If you were to take a trip to a Muslim country and see two men walking down the street, holding hands, you, being of a person of western J/C values, might take those two to be homosexual. However, in Muslim culture, two men holding hands is simply a sign of friendship and has none of the sexual/close-ness implications that a westerner, such as yourself, might see in it. Given that you would mis-interpret that simple cultural symbol of THIS time and place, why would you be able correctly interpret symbols of almost 2000 years ago? You’ve given no evidence that you can.
Now, as for your simple question; a point: many answers are rarely as easy and YES or NO. Don’t believe me, talk to Dr. Schroedinger! Since I don’t believe REVELATIONS will happen, I think the question is moot. But, IF it did happen (and that’s a BIG IF) I would realise there’s a truly evil, malevolent, personified force in the world and would probably NOT take the mark. But those are big ifs in my book.
Then WB wrote:
Hey I am not God and you’re not God so how can we judge what he did and why? Lets assume God is real and made everything. Don’t you think he has the right to make the rules. I might not like the rule he has and you might not like them but they are the His rules. Well the people did not follows his rules. And he punished them for it. I am not sure you have children but if they broke your rules would you not punish them? And God did not punish Job(I guess you were refering to him?) I believe the devil did. And why God did that I don’t know either and have wondered about it too. My guess would be to try to make Job stronger in his faith. A guess that is all it is.
Sorry, that doesn’t cut it in my book. I don’t follow ANYONE who says “Do what I say and don’t question me.” If your God is that type of being, then sorry, He’s not worthy of my worship. The points I brought up were the Flood, the cities and tribes killed when the Isrealites took Caanan and the story of Job. I think those are fair examples that your God is certainly NOT superior, not by any stretch of the imagination.