I got in on the Friends phenomenon a little late, but what the hell, I’ve been watching for over a year now, I think I can comment.
As far as I can tell, Monica has ALWAYS been a shrill Type A control freak. Acquired taste, I guess. That doesn’t really annoy me unless it develops into some ridiculous misunderstanding (like the “handmade gifts” debacle). I do think that her past weight troubles have been brought up waaaay too much, especially since they’re past.
Joey needs something to do. Right now he’s basically The Minor Goofy Situation Waiting to Happen, and I can see that getting old (like “We were on a break!!”). Everyone else has gone through at least one serious crisis or emotional situation…too many, in the case of Ross and Rachel…and I don’t see why Joey couldn’t have one as well.
Phoebe has always been a dependable buddy/catalyst/opposing view, and this season has been no different. (The way she won the maid of honor contest was classic.) If it ain’t broke…
I nearly gave up on Rachel after the interminable “We were on a break” sludge-fest. She’s a little better now, but too…flighty for my tastes (wasn’t there a better way to get Tag on board?).
As for Ross, there’s always been something about this somewhat gawky intellectual type who’s been dragged through the mud too many times to count that’s appealed to me. I sympathized totally with him through all three marraiges, and I think the show would be much better served by allowing him to rise above all his past failures.
Chandler…well, he’s Chandler, what more do you need to know. Certainly hope the marraige situation is settled quickly, though. As a man with his own life, he’s the life of the party; as Monica’s ball and chain, he’s a drag.
The stories haven’t been too far out of the ordinary, except for the marriage subplot (and I really hope this gets closed out ASAP). Good to see workplace humor, always one of the sticking points of the show, still playing a significant part.
In short, overall it could be better, but I think it’s a little premature to say that the franchise “sucks”. Wait until the end of the season and then we’ll see.