I am not convinced that Sweet Willey is a liar. IMO, Monty is often a little quick to use the “L” word, but that reflects the fact that I am reluctant to use this insult without the strongest proof.
Now then.
By one narrow definition, the Masons most definitely recruit, to the extent that they “enlist new members for a party or organization” or (alternatively) “[rare] replenish”.
Notwithstanding my Websters New World Dictionary however, “recruit” implies some level of promotion and, based on the evidence given in this board, it appears to me that Masons engage in what might be termed as a “soft sell”.
I would characterize their policy as one that formally avoids active recruitment, although some winking and nudging is permitted.
So, while I believe that S.W. has made some mischaracterizations, I vote “not guilty” on the lying charge.
More generally, Sweet Willey noted that his father had apparently engaged in some what I would call corrupt practices while a Mason, and was wondering how far up such corruption occurred.
I would note that the question, “Do [fill-in-the-blank] engage in world-wide corrupt practices?” is essentially a slanderous (libelous?) one and therefore might call for a level of tact that I don’t think S.W. exercised.
Furthermore, it appears that S.W. was over-extrapolating on the basis of the rumors he had heard about a local Masonic organization.
At the same time, methinks that certain institutional practices can tend to have the unfortunate consequence of advancing corruption. Such practices include:
- Secrecy.
- Non-transparent and implicit membership benefits.
- A policy where group loyalty demands that requests for aid be granted, perhaps in response to a codephrase. *
- A policy that is silent about whether aid should be granted if the request is illegal, immoral or both.
Frankly, I don’t know whether or to what extent the Masons have such practices. And while it wouldn’t surprise me if there were a lot of pols who were Mason members (politicians like joining local social organizations), it would surprise me if that fact amounted to didley-squat.
- “Will nobody yada yada the widow’s son?”, as a hypothetical example.