Give me car advice!

Hello. I need a lot of help. I’m 19 and don’t really have much of anyone who’s capable of providing guidance, so I hope I can tap the vast knowledge/experience bank here.

I need (well, I guess it’s not necessarily a need so much as an urgent want) a new car. Right now I am driving a BMW 318i that is the same age as me, which makes me nervous considering I commute about 45 minutes (non highway) to work five days a week. If something ends up breaking, it’s gonna be pricey and the car might be totalled (it’s worth $3000 or thereabouts).

I am looking for a car in the $10,000 and under (under is good!) price range that fits the following criteria:

  • manual transmission

  • non-domestic

  • reliable

  • well-constructed/engineered

  • relative luxury (prefer leather but it is not a sticking point)

  • good gas mileage

  • good handling/acceleration

One thing I am considering very strongly is a late '90s VW Jetta, preferably a GLX, but I don’t really know what I’m doing. Help!

A diesel VW might be a good choice, but really, for under 10k, you really just have to go with what seems like the best deal out there. Just be sure to bring anything you are considering to a garage to check it out, and research the VIN.