What we have:
6 confirmables
7 unknown
Case 1: scum all claim vanilla. 6 confirmed 7 unknown. we lynch unknown, vig kills unknown, scum kill confirmed (worst case Cop).
5 confirmed 5 unknown - we lynch unknown, doc protects Vig, vig kills unknown, scum kill doc
4 confirmed 3 unknown - we lynch unknown, vig dies
3 confirmed 2 unknown
2 confirmed 1 unknown - we lynch unknown and Town Wins.
Case 2: 1 scum claims power, one scum claims vanilla. I thought about this some more. The only power scum could claim is Doc. If they claim Vig, the real vig will kill scum with 100% accuracy (we lynch neither). and we’re back to case 1 only better. If they claim Doc, we happily let BOTH live and use either the Vig or Cop to gain ground on the scum because if they try to kill the real Doc, we know who to lynch the very next Day.
Case 3: scum claim 2 powers - 4 unknowns 9 confirmed - Town wins.
I think a mass claim wins it.
Special Ed should NOT claim though until all others have.
Also. Scum should resign. 