Right - outdrawn. That’s what I get for using the OP’s chord diagram!
Anyways, notice that the first version I posted is similar to Snoopy’s - except (probably) using the thumb to drop on the second fret on the first string.
My second version is similar to Mr. Blue Sky’s - except muting the second string.
The first one definately sounds fuller, but it’s kinda tough to play. The second one is easy. Depends on how it fits into your song, which one you choose.
In other words, you can play an A Major 9th, a C# minor 7th, or a plain old E Major fifth over someone else’s F# bass and you’d still be in the neighborhood.
Now all the purists will (and probably should) chime in and flame me.
There you have every note of the chord except the 5th, which doesn’t matter anyway, and you could do melodic stuff with your pinky too (e.g. pull it off and you get the tonic. Fret it on the 1st string to get the 5th.)
Almost. You’re missing the defining minor 3rd in both these chords. Don’t get me wrong–it’ll work. It’s just that the major-minor tonality will just be harmonically ambiguous unless the melody line or context is filling in the blanks.
However, that voicing sounds muddy. To my ears, 2x2200 and 244200 sound the best. The 9th isn’t necessary for the 11th chord. As long as you have the 7th and 3rd in there, you’re okay. As long as you have somebody holding the F# in the bass, you can get away with an A-B-E (a nice quintal) for the F#11.