Very high production values, decent cast, and IMO the writing is exactly on par with the actual show! Huge props to everyone for pulling this off, but especially to Director Dan Lanigan!
Okay, after two viewings, I have to give this a solid B. I’d go 6/10 stars on IMDB. The look of the production is very good, faithful to the cartoon in a lot of ways. Some of the cast is good, some is mediocre. I thought Fry’s smirk was a bit too omnipresent, but I thought he was also on-target. I thought Leela’s voice was occasionally good but the actress didn’t have the right look. Professor was great; Hermes was great; Amy was so-so. Zoidberg looked okay but sounded terrible. Bender looked good but didn’t sound like Bender. Zap Branigan made a good effort but didn’t have the over-the-top-Kirk voice down at all; he did have the obliviousness to the fact that he was a man in a skirt down pretty well tho. Hypno-Toad sucked: the pupils in the eyes were to small and the loud industrial droning noise was absent.
The Zod beer commercial was awesome. The nuclear cargo and the giraffe were awesome. Rich Little as Nixon was great and that whole sequence looked great. The CGI overall was good considering the budget.
I guess that’s the biggest consideration: this as a very low budget fan film. Prolly high budget for a fan film, but very low budget by any other standard, and I have to give props for doing so well with so little.
Oh, and the actual “episode” is only about 15 minutes long. Hypno-Toad takes up like the last 7 minutes after the credits but without the droning noise is no fun at all.
So close but the look and timing of the characters were off. I did like a lot of the little stuff that they put into the scenes though, funny little things to pay attention to along the way.
Forget the voice and the look, the characterization was completely off! She was the one performer who made me think, “Uhhh, obviously this person didn’t watch a single episode of the show to prepare for the role!”
But, Nixon! Was that really Rich Little? The credits say it was Rich Little. How did a low budget fan film score Rich Little!?!?!? Way to go, fan film guys!
I admit, the Leela character completely missed the mark, personality-wise, but the makeup really made it clear how creepy and unsettling a giant-eyed cyclops would be, It would definitely take some getting used to.
The Hermes character seemed too young, and the voices were obviously off, but i could see this getting time as a series. Comedy Central has put far lamer stuff on the air.
I agree. The look and feel were great. The acting and writing were mixed. I was shocked to see that was really Rich Little when the credits rolled. I thought it looked like him but didn’t think it could really be him.
Was there really ten minutes of hypno toad at the end or did I miss something by stopping early?
I’m verrry sloowly downloading this, and I’m going to enjoy it, because I miss Futurama so much. No matter how imperfect it may be, I’m glad they made an effort.
I’m just posting to share my wish with the SDMB – that some group with really good voice mimicry would redub A Prisoner of Brenda – actually giving the characters the voices their bodies should have, while mimicking the attributes of the swapped mind. It should have been easy to do when first made, there’s some overlap in voice actors. But I guess Comedy Central was busy keeping the show as dumbed down as possible.
Visually it was excellent. I’d give it a solid A. The acting was not terrible. Some performers were better than others, but overall a respectable B-. The script, however, was awful. It missed on every level. Not remotely funny. I just couldn’t finish it.