Homeland 2017

I guess nobody is watching this excellent SHO series any longer. Honestly, it’s the fastest hour in television viewing. Crisp editing and great writing, not to mention Mandy Patinkin, F. Murray Abraham, and Rupert Friend (who is doing Emmy-worthy work this season). This year’s action takes place in NYC, rather than overseas. My only quarrel with this show has been that Carrie has to be the most inept CIA agent ever. She invariably makes the wrong decisions on any given matter. But highly entertaining stuff.

I’ve been enjoying this season, up until the last episode where

they took her daughter away.

That’s such a tired storyline.

What I liked about the most recent episode is

In the custody hearing, Carrie Matheson was asked, “So were you really in your daughter’s bedroom with a loaded gun?”, suggesting that she was being paranoid due to her manic-depression. But she and we know that she had completely valid reasons for fearing for her safety and that of her daughter, but she couldn’t explain her reasoning without sounding like a paranoid nutcase and revealing to the conspirators that she was onto them.

I peeked at the spoilers and well geez it’s about time, Carrie is the most neglectful mother ever.

All I know is that Rupert Friend as “Quinn” needs an Emmy. Good lord he’s awesome this season.

I’m liking this season very much.

It’s about time she had her kid taken away.

Yeah, but then she wouldn’t be able to do the absolute worst thing she could possibly do in response and not get to do the quivery chin thingy. She is really one of the least sympathetic ‘heroines’ in television.

This season is very “meh” for me. Quinn continues to be the show’s punching bag, and Dar Adal has become a mustache-twirling villain. Just not finding it suspenseful at all.

This show has always done a methodical setup for the season’s plot line, rather than doing some half-assed, badly written episode that confuses more than enlightens. The payoff has always been worth it.

In the custody hearing, Carrie Matheson was asked, “So were you really in your daughter’s bedroom with a loaded gun?”

Carrie - “Well, yes, but the safety was on!”. Nitpick, but if I’m not mistaken, the pistol she was holding doesn’t have a safety that can be set to off or on.

Does she really have to cry (or make that face that indicates she’s on the verge) every episode?

Well, she is bi-polar, and her emotions are never far from the surface.

So, Dar is gay? That was new to me.

Looks that way. I’m wondering if Peter is too, or was he molested by Dar, or maybe a secret agent in training version of “gay for pay.”
Loving this season so far. Last season was their best since season 1, and this one is shaping up just as well. Every time I see an episode on my DVR my first reaction is “tired old show that used to be good,” but then it’s always one of the first Sunday night shows I watch and it keeps me riveted.

One minor quibble is that I found Carrie’s term “war fighter” very clunky when she was explaining why it would be a bad idea to send in a SWAT team to take Quinn down.

Remember that Peter was recruited as a kid (I think we were told he was sixteen?) from a homeless shelter. So I think we’re meant to understand that Dar was molesting him.

I thought Dar explicitly said something like “and I never touched you”. I don’ think there was any molestation involved.

Here’s their dialogue according to the recap in The New York Times:

"‘What the hell is this? Feeling sorry for yourself?’

Expletive by way of a greeting.

‘Because if you are, that would be a first. You grew up in a hard school. No time for self-pity. It’s the first thing about you that impressed.’

‘Not the first thing.’

‘Yeah, well. We’re all beautiful when we’re young, aren’t we?’

‘[Expletive] dirty old man.’

‘Fair enough. For the record, though, I never forced myself on anyone.’"

I’m liking it, they seem to always be abit ahead of the days news, except for assuming

a woman would be POTUS like the rest of “us” did.

That business with Quinn and Dar Adal.?.. Probably some payback coming no doubt.

Something I find distracting is Carrie’s expression — she often looks very puzzled. Do others notice this? Is it over-acting or just the actress’ natural expression? (Disclaimer: I’m not a Homeland fan.)

Another excellent episode. Intrigue and counter intrigue: who’s right and who’s wrong and who’s masking; and what is the end-game? All elements that this show does really well.

In Smiley’s People, Episode 1, at the 39:40 mark, respected top spy George Smiley meets young Mostyn who says “I heard you lecture at Sarrat, sir – the new entrants’ training course. It was the best thing of the whole two years.” Shortly afterwards, Smiley arranges a few moments alone with Mostyn to learn what the superiors are concealing.

Watching Episode 6 of Homeland Season 6 just now, respected top spy Saul Berenson meets a young agent, Nate Joseph, at the 8:35 mark. Joseph says “I heard your lecture, sir, during my training course… It was the highlight of my whole two years.” Shortly afterwards, Saul arranges to be alone with the young man to learn what the superiors are concealing.

The similarity is huge; the speeches by Mostyn and Joseph are almost identical. (I’ve not finished Episode 6 — Is Joseph, like Mostyn, going to be punished for cooperating with Saul? BTW, Saul showing incriminating photos to a foreign agent in Episode 3 also mimics Smiley’s People.)

I don’t know if anyone else will find this interesting, and I certainly do not intend to press plagiarism charges! :stuck_out_tongue: The connection mainly served to remind me that Smiley’s People is a spy film of the very top drawer, while Homeland is at least a rung or two down.

I don’t think that was an accident. When Saul meets the guy, Saul says he was glad the guy was paying attention.