4 people haven’t claimed yet. There are 3 scums left who started the game as scums. If those three are in those 4, i’ll laugh.
Okay, Meeko’s #1177 is very convincing. I’ll trust the claim at this time.
unvote Meeko
So I’ve eliminated Skeezix, Meeko, and (for now) Idle. I’ll go to bed with my vote back to what tiny case I’ve previously made.
vote Cookies
Yeah. Apparently the “This part has been pre-typed” went right over your head.
Pick a reason. Oh, Third person to vote town is good.
I KNOW you are better than this Scuba, I mean c’mon.
**I guess you are saying you don’t trust me. **
Well, I don’t know what to say to that.
Meeko, did you protect idle night 1?
waits on Meeko to catch up
Looks like with Meeko’s claim, there’s darn little reason to hold back from everybody else claiming. Here’s my PM:
You are Snow White from the fairy tales.
You are a member of the Excellent Indivisible Unity of Good Characters(EIUGC).
You want to get rid of all the Naughty Dividing Characters of Evil(NDCE).
You win when all threats to EIUGC are dead.
You are Vanilla Town.
NETA: If I have the count right from the people who claiming this is a redress of HP, then all the power roles have claimed. Everybody else is going to say “I’m vanilla Town, really!”
Yes. I protected Idle.
01-21-2011, 02:02 PM is the time stamp my Sent PM box has for the action pm.
And yes, I protected you.
But frankly Red, you are pinging me right now.
I can confirm that I was protected last night.
[QUOTE=Mahaloth]
You slept quite well and felt safe during the Night.
[/QUOTE]
Well as long as someone has 5 votes on them and they are not meeko or I, then scum can’t force a power lynch today, so I’m okay with that.
**Funny that you offer this AFTER you posted your claim.
Funny that you offered your “” claim “” so freely.
Must keep up appearances of being Town, mustn’t we ? **
Also: I’d like everyone to post their PMs before the next post they make (if they haven’t done so.) I think I spotted a discrepancy that will implicate a couple of people.
I see no reason not to claim now:
[QUOTE=Mahaloth]
You are Jacob from Lost.
You are a member of the Excellent Indivisible Unity of Good Characters(EIUGC).
You want to get rid of all the Naughty Dividing Characters of Evil(NDCE).
You win when all threats to EIUGC are dead.
You are Vanilla Town.
[/QUOTE]
I’ve gotta go back and reread the past few hours’ of posts, because there seems to be a whole lot going on here, even aside from Meeko voting for darn near everyone at one point or another.
I got no such PM that night, so I think you are correct that it did not go through.
Seriously guys. Pretend it is tomorrow and take your best shot at who you’re going to vote for. Now vote for that guy and not me and chances are you’ll avoid a mislynch.
It is really that easy I think. I chose Town. I felt bad about hitting one of you before I was even your enemy and I chose the high road. It sucked that I was outed when I was. I would not have killed if I weren’t exposed. It sucks that I hit the one fracking thing with an instant double-kill bonus.
My idea that night, was that if it had gone through, you would be given the option to chose right then and there. I was thinking that someone had to influence you or visit you, etc. Also, my role pm does have the word persuade. :shrug:
Protect an obvious NK that night, and attempt, albeit indirectly, to add someone to town.
First - unvote Meeko
Second - my PM (I claimed earlier but did not post the whole PM)
I still think lynching Cookies is a bad idea and she has seemed like town since her conversion. Skeezix and Meeko are confirmed. Idle is mostly confirmed (I agree there’s no way he would have fought as strongly with Pleonast if both were scum). I get strong town feels from Chronos and Astral. And I just don’t feel comfortable enough lynching Scuba with what little info we have (but is building).
Which leaves:
vote Suburban Plankton
Consider this a placeholder vote until I feel more confident about someone else. I realize that somebody’s doing a good job hoodwinking me, I just don’t know who.
I will say this about Suburban, I don’t like his vote against Chronos simply because he posted his program. I don’t know enough about programming to begin to know what flaws it has, but Chronos values it, so for him to post the results is a valid action. The program may or may not be useful, but if Chronos believes it is a tool to help find scum, then he should be allowed to post without immediate suspicion.
As requested:
I haven’t had any time this week to tackle this game. I was really sure Storyteller was scum, which was wrong, but I was pretty right about pants. That leaves Scuba_Ben from my WoWs.
I don’t have a strong feeling on our other players right now. I worry Cookies is a mislynch, but I worried about Pleo, too, and that ended up the correct move. The reasons for doubting a Cookie lynch are much less substantial than Pleo, so I can’t fault anyone for picking her. This isn’t helpful in the least, but I have a gut feeling about her that leans town. I know 3 dead townies sounds bad, but (IIRC) the ratio at the time was only 5 townies to 1 scum. That seems pretty average for early game, and picking town at that point isn’t entirely unreasonable.
But, ultimately, I’m going with Scuba. What little was there struck me as scummy enough.
Vote Scuba_Ben
I’m thinking Scuba botched his claim. Snow White from the fairy tales? How about Snow White from Snow White or Snow White from Snow White and the Seven Dwarves? I mean, I’m Angel from Angel. Not Angel from Buffy, or Angel from the tv shows.
unvote Cookies
vote Scuba Ben
I’ll try to come back before the day is over, to switch my vote and prevent any shenanigans if you guys disagree with my assessment. (But I’ll be at work,so no guarantees)
Also, if Scuba comes up scum, then Suburban will too, I think.
@Red: It is what it is. I had to go back and check also. Snow White appears in “… and the Seven Dwarves,” and a different one in “… and Rose Red.” I believe I read the second one in Grimms’ Fairy Tales, and I was confused for years about why there weren’t any dwarves. Snow White is a stronger character in the second story, whereas the first one is corrupted by the Disney film into showing her as utterly useless.
AOP: Read the story at Snow-White and Rose-Red - Wikisource, the free online library
@Meeko: I offered my claim so freely because by my count, all power roles had claimed. There was no reason for anybody else to hold back. And all remaining claims would be VT, or a counter-claim of your role. I think it would be ballsy for someone to counter-claim Red Skeezix this long after his claim. So there’s no more info to conceal from Scum.
As for the other crack – I thought of the wording just after I posted. Yet another case of Hit Post Too Soon. If we lynched everybody who does that, we’d have a mass lynch Day 1.