I caught her. Guess what I did. What would you have done?

Coldfire:

pldennison:

TomH:

yosemitebabe:

TomH:

Coldfire:

Well, gawrsh ma’am, shore looks like being accused to me!
Not to mention that shortly after the accusations started, the view count popped up, sort of like buzzards smelling blood. Besides, like most who post here, I lurked for quite some time.

Think I haven’t read other accusations on the board? If I’m correct MarkXXX and someone else were accused of being him. Do you think I’ve not been reading the board for quite a while, along with the Straight Dope? Don’t break your arm patting yourself on the back just yet, honey. I’m quite sure that I don’t react or act within your desired parameters. Now that this post is getting thoroughly bollixed up, even if Serlin were to return, what gives people here the right to harass him so long as he obeys the rules? Vigilantes? Why have you people taken it upon yourselves to screw up my post with unfounded accusations? I might have a reason for posting this and might be seeking either absolution, agreement or criticism for the way I handled the situation. Then you guys start changing the subject and who the heck is going to post here now?

DNFTT. Do Not Feed The Troll. See that in one of my posts and there are those who might have had what I was seeking who will not reply, just because you people decide to go on the hunt. Such things, years ago, were called witch hunts, because whoever the mob found was it whether guilty or not.

Now, I ask you again, politely, to please leave me out of your witch hunt.

You poor victim, you. <sniff sniff>

Poor fella.

Looks like Florida has a lot of guys being victimized on this board. A lot of men of your approx. age, with a simular background to yours, and with a simular attitude towards women.

Golly gee. What a coincidence. It must be something about Florida. I don’t know.

No, it’s just something about assholes.

This hijack is more appropriate for the Pit, folks. Either respond to the OP, or let the thread die on it’s own. Any other type of respnse will result in locking this up, o.k.?
You may flame over in the Pit, not here!

Were you physically violent with these people? Your OP implies that. If so, were there charges brought against you?

Had I been in the same position, I think I would have been more subtle.

When a former boyfriend of mine started dating someone else without first telling me he was “former,” I waited and eventually befriended her (because we were all loosely in the same social group). I told her about what he did, and some other things I thought that might be of interest to her, and she eventually found these things to be true. We were friends longer than he and I were (eventually she moved away and I lost track of her).

Looking back, I think I should just have ignored him, and befriended her just because she was a nice person.

Define violent. :slight_smile:


Fretful Porpentine:

**What would I have done?

If I were dating a man who worked 80 hours a week and
thought material goods were an adequate substitute for
spending time together, I would have done the same thing
she did.**

Really? You would have accepted a ring, become engaged,
not dumped the guy, never told him that you wanted time
with him more than the money, and just slept around on
him?

Wow.

The first thing I thought when I read the OP was that you killed them in a fit of rage. I honestly thought that was coming.

Of course, my second thought was “hello again, Serlin”, but that’s beside the point.

No. Neither were killed and I did mention earlier that, after a time, she tried to get back with me, but I would not do it. I didn’t go to jail, no police were called and emergency services were not needed.

What would any of you have done in the same situation?

(Sigh.) No, I suppose I wouldn’t; I’m an honest person and in any case I don’t date workaholics. My first post was basically a knee-jerk reaction to an OP that really got on my nerves. I got the impression that he thought she “owed” him loyalty because he bought her jewelry and paid her bills – as if she were a glorified prostitute. The way I see it, men who treat all women as if they were gold-diggers will get gold-diggers, because few decent women will stay with somebody who thinks of them in such an insulting fashion.

One word for ya:

Sucker

To be fair, I only got half way into your story before reaching my opinion. You are in every way as responsible for your ‘predicament’ as you think that she is. You chose a lazy 'ho to lavish your attention on, then worked yourself into a frenzy paying all her bills all the while spending less and less time with her.

What would I have done in your shoes? Banged her like a screen door for a weekend and moved on.

I recommend you do the same.

The OP implies that you beat them violently with your “heavy oak club tipped with steel.”

Did you or did you or not strike them?

When he imagined it while writing the OP?

Or when he makes up an answer to respond to you?

What would you like him to say?

Well, I’ll lay it all out.

When I caught them in bed, right in the act, I went ice cold and my vision just narrowed down to something like a pinpoint. The urge to take the heavy, steel wrapped tip of the tire thumper and just beat the guy into a bloody pulp actually made me shake – but I have a strong dislike of jails and I figured that if I started pounding him, they might get me for attempted murder.

Her eyes got like about as big as dinner plates and her mouth went into an almost perfect O and the only thing she could say was ‘oh – f*in’ st!’ and started heaving him off of her, but he was already on the move.

You know how time freezes in snapshots sometimes, in your brain? That happened to me. There was a shot of him hitting the floor on his feet, prick erect as hell and looking at me in great surprise. I did not know him. Then her, on her back, legs still wide spread, pushing herself in a sitting position and looking real scared.

I next recall him asking her who the hell I was as she was rather hysterically pointing out to me that I was supposed to be working and what the hell was I doing there. Somewhere along the line, the guy acted like he was going to come at me and I threatened him with the club and he settled right down – all of the way. (Get what I mean?)

Through all of this, I could smell her perfume, the ‘romantic’ air freshener she liked to use, noticed that her crumpled underwear was a special, shiny, silky crimson set that I had bought her and that her engagement ring was gone. Even with her hair all rumpled and her looking panic stricken, I thought she looked beautiful.

She was sputtering something about ‘let me explain’ and he was still asking ‘who the f is this’ and ‘I didn’t know she was married man’ and she was saying ‘what gives you the right to spy on me’ and ‘call the cops’ and ‘get the f out’ and ‘it’s your fault because I get lonely and you aren’t around much’ and things like that.

I shut the guy up by telling him I was her fiancé. Ever notice how guys look so much less threatening when they’re standing there nude, prick drooping? I told her to shut the F up, called her a slut, among a few other things, emphasized my words by swinging the club and putting it through her bedroom wall. Then, when speech failed me, I turned and put my hand right through her bedroom door. (Mistake. Broke two knuckles.)

Then for some reason, I suddenly felt calm and collected, my vision widened and I recall turning to the guy, telling him to f her all he wants, 'cause she’s a slut, to leave $10 on her table when he goes home and to get checked by his doctor. Then, I recall just looking at her, taking in every detail and she put her head down and wouldn’t look at me. Then I heard myself telling her that was it, we’re through, that she could kiss my ass and what a s**t of a person she was.

Then I left. I heard her say something like ‘wait,’ but I was out of the door and gone. I started shaking when I got to the car, downed what was left of my booze and went to get more. Afraid that the cops would be after me, I threw the tire billy into a ditch, miles away, drove up to an old camping spot back in the woods and got thoroughly drunk.

I slunk home, a tad hung over but braced by the ever wise decision to buy a pint on the way back for a ‘hair of the dog,’ drove past my house several times to see if cops were lurking to pounce, (like they wouldn’t know my car)? and went in. I had several messages from her on the answering machine. The first couple were outraged and pissed, threatening legal action, blaming me for her actions, the ‘we need to talk,’ then ‘where the hell are you’ and finally degraded to ‘f off!’.

Two weeks of silence later, she showed up at my home, all sweet and loving, seductive as hell, suggesting that we get back together. I guess her rent or something was due. Be proud of me because I was nice and polite and cool and calm and said no and after listening to her many reasons why she had cheated on me – she slipped up and indicated that there had been at least two others - I escourted her to the door and said bye.

After she left, I shook, had self doubt, the urge to try again, wanted to hop in my car and chase after her yelling that all if forgiven, but I didn’t. I kept picturing that hairy male ass between her legs – the one that wasn’t mine. So, I poured myself a beer, dumped in a shot and proceeded to get on with getting over her.

Sometimes, I think about the good times and fun we had and sometimes, after listening to other guys talk about what they did when they discovered they were being cheated on, I wonder if I ‘wussied’ out and should have been more violent.

I mean, guys have told me how they beat the hell out of the guy, the girl, ruined her car, trashed her apartment, pulled guns, knives and baseball bats, and some got hauled to jail.

But, that was somewhat over 3 years ago. I’m not even sure where she is anymore. I don’t think I’ll ever work so hard for any lady again. It actually took me a few years of working only one job to recover my complete health.

There are times though, when I recall her voice or something she did to make me laugh, or drive by a place we went and had fun, or something she gave me that I did not throw out or pack away happens to turn up, when I think about her.

What would you have done?

Have you ever considered becoming a novelist, FarTreker? You can tell a pretty good story. Surely it would be more productive of your time to try to write novels than to annoy people on the SDMB.

This is what happens when you FTT.

Would you judges of truth and justice be so kind as to examine any of my posts and please point out any where I deliberately called any poster a liar? Funny, having read my way through the board, I’ve found a lot that I consider bunk, but without being able to justify my suspicions, I’ve not found it necessary to shoot my mouth off and tell the poster that he/she is full of crap. I just move on.

In this circumstance, from the implications of tomndebb, no matter what I posted would be a lie.

Come here. I’d like to show you my busted knuckles on my right hand close up. They’re kind of lumpy.

I had my doubts about the story, but I let it go.
I cannot let the implied threat of that last post stand, however. I’m locking this up now.