But I was never a charter member. Does this mean I get to be a charter member now or something? 
Now that you made this deal public? No.
Sorry, no – we were trying to catch the attention of your fellow Guests who are lapsed Charter Members.
But you’re welcome to become a Member anytime. 
I just re-upped a few weeks ago and I got one too. If I get canceled sometime real soon we will have words!
Just so you know, the email did not go only to Guests.
I am currently a Member - my subscription lapses in July. I received the “Renew your Charter Membership” email.
You were a little less selective than you believed, obviously.