I was "the other man" and now I'm confused.

Where do I start? I’m a gay man, and have been single for about 6 months. I was feeling a bit randy one night and I’d always heard about a certain website which is good for setting up meetings with other guys. I’d never done anything like this before, but my libido was getting the best of me. So, I placed an ad, and got a few responses. One of the responses was from a guy who said he might be interested, but he was married and had absolutely no experience doing this kind of thing. i was like, “yeah, right”. but, we started chatting. he said that he wanted his first time to be a meaningful thing. he said he was in his early 40’s, had been married for 15 years and had young children and didn’t want to risk losing them, so he wanted to chat and get to know each other before making any decisions. we chatted for a few weeks and i became fascinated with this guy. eventually, i sent him a face picture, he said he trusted me and sent one back. he was definitely very attractive. we literally exchanged hundreds of emails over the next three weeks. he told me that he’d always been curious about it, but was very worried about rejection because of his inexperience. so, we agreed to meet in a public place for a few drinks, and then take it from there. he said that he’d like to meet me, but was pretty sure he couldn’t go thru with it, at least on our first meeting.

when i met him, i was immediately struck by how good looking he was. he was very shy and nervous. i did everything i could to make him feel comfortable. we had a few drinks and talked for about two hours, and then i finally got the courage to ask him back to my place. he nervously said yes, and we headed to my place. we ended up in bed. it was very awkward for both of us at first, but we got into it after a while. all in all, i’d say that the sex was just basic, nothing exciting. but at the same time, it WAS exciting and new and we were both nervous and our hearts were pounding. after it was over, he thanked me for being so patient with him. he also said he would like to possibly do it again, but it was very difficult for him to get away without raising some question. i assumed that our little affair was over, based on that. but, we’re still emailing each other a lot during the day. we talk about everything, he says he’s really glad to have met me and considers me a good friend. our conversations have never been sexually charged that much, mostly we talk about his family, my family, our likes and dislikes, etc. just getting to know each other. he confided in me that although he was glad he finally went thru with it, he felt guilty about cheating on his wife, but he was dealing with it.

i have become so smitten with this guy, but i know that it can’t go anywhere. in fact, i don’t think i would want it to go anywhere. but, i’m obsessed with him for now. i keep my phone by my bed at night, so in case he emails me (and he does), i’ll hear the beep and be able to email him back. i recognize that this is not normal behavior. and i recognize that the only place this will lead to is heartbreak, but right now he’s all i can think about. i think part of me was very flattered that he felt comfortable enough with me to allow his first time to happen.

but part of me feels guilty that i helped him cheat. i really like chatting with him, he’s a very interesting guy, and we still email each other at least 5 or 6 times a day, but other than a couple of times, nothing is ever mentioned about our tryst, and i’ve never pushed the issue of getting together again, in fact i’ve never mentioned it. i’m wondering if he just would like to maintain a male bond or something?

is it possible that a “straight” man can satisfy his curiosity and never want it again? he says that he still looks at my pictures and would like me to send him more. i’m just confused.

No.

This is going to end really badly. Break it off. If he’s willing to cheat on the woman he’s in a long-term, committed relationship with for your sake, what proof do you have that he’ll ever be honest with you?

It sounds like an infatuation that’s being fueled by the scarcity of the object. You want him so much because he’s not super-available so you can’t get tired of him or ever really settle into a routine where you can determine if he’s really a good match or just forbidden fruit.

I don’t see any way for it to end well.

Six months down the road he’s going to be lurking on coughslist again looking for a new person to scratch his semiannual itch. I don’t doubt that he’ll keep on with you as a friend (if only to forestall a possible bitter-scorned revelation to wifey), but you’re going to get nothing from him romantically. The fewer tracks he leaves in any particular direction, the more likely he is to keep his extracurriculars a secret…if he starts to wear a path to your door every month or so, his wife WILL find out eventually. If he disappears for a few hours every month to a location that even he doesn’t know for sure until he’s there, she has less to go on.

It sounds like your more smitten with the “forbidden” aspect than the guy.

OK a man who will cheat on his wife, a person he made a public and legal commitment to, and will risk losing his children, certainly isn’t going to think twice about dumping you.

Fair enough you’re expecting it.

Morality aside, you know what it is. No point worrying about what is going to happen, so enjoy it while you can.

Hopefully you won’t get an irate wife with a knife coming at you :slight_smile:

Can’t speak to the gay attraction issue, but FWIW if he’s emailing and texting you on his phone he’s begging for a Tiger Woods style confrontation with his wife. People who are infatuated get sloppy, and if the wife gets her hands on his cell or his email account for even a few minutes he’s done, and you’re entangled in the drama. Don’t think that his wife will not come to your work and make a giant scene. She will.

OP, how do YOU see this ending up? (Realistically.) How do you WANT it to end up? (Hypothetically.) What do you want from him? To leave his wife & kids for you? To keep seeing you on the side?

And now, a quick PSA: please be sure you’re doinge everything in your power to not catch/transmit/swap any STDs.

Sounds like normal crush behavior to me. Maybe the two of us are freaks, though. :stuck_out_tongue:

Ever consider that this guy may just be playing? Is he even really married?

I say go for it! Keep doing what you’re doing and ride this thing, milking it for all it’s got.

Just kidding. This will only end with somebody in tears. Pull out now.

This guy doesn’t happen to be a politician or preacher of some sort does he? How wide is his stance? :slight_smile: Will he deny everything (and you) when this comes out? Enjoy the excitement now but know that the hurt will come eventually.

Snerk
He’s right though. You’re not doing any good for anyone in this scenario. You’re not investing in a relationship, he’s certainly not investing in either relationship, and the wife is just being screwed over. However, you don’t have to have a part in this deceit.

Pull out now.

They’re right. Eject while you can.

Generally speaking, I’m inclined to cut people a little slack with respect to extramarital attractions. When you add the gay angle I’m even more tolerant, because gays do not have the same opportunities to date, choose mates, and get married without stigma that straight people have.

HOWEVER, my tolerance assumes no kids are involved. This man has young children, and that changes everything. You are helping him do something that has the distinct possibility of leading to great trauma for them. If he really loves his kids, he should either come clean with his wife about his urges and get an honorable divorce, behaving as gently as possible to everyone involved, or he should put a lid on it and be the best husband he can. What’s he’s doing now is inviting disaster for his children - and you are enabling him. I have no respect for anyone who would deliberately expose innocent kids to that kind of risk.

Your next email to him - “You’re a great guy, and I like you a lot. Please get in touch with me if you ever leave your wife and are available for a real relationship. Otherwise, it’s been nice knowing you, and good-bye.”

That’s how you quit him. :slight_smile:

Excuse me ?
While I agree for marriage, for dating and choosing mates, gays (especially male) have it far, far better than us. If I were gay, I could go on a gay bar on a Friday night and be able to find myself some nice flirt to take back to my or his home.
Instead, if I go to a straight generic bar, I can do anything great, smile, be open and all, still women look at me as if I am a creep.

Dude, I’m not even gay and I can spot this one. This is not his first time. He’s probably had more ass than a barber’s chair. He just likes to be publicly married and still get it on the side.

No, he isn’t going to leave his wife. Say good bye and find someone honest. On second thought, don’t bother with the “saying good bye” part.

Regards,
Shodan

My concern is the guy probably also tries to bareback (not use condoms) if he presents himself as a “virgin” to gay sex, as well.

That’s an excellent point. Dishonesty and relationships are a bad mix no matter what side of the plate you bat from.

Regards,
Shodan

Definitely agreed here. I just figured that claims to “virginity” are easier - and less unattractive - in a guy who claims he’s just “curious,” and worry how often that works out for him. Plus being married, he’s probably not getting tested lest unexplained lab results show up at home or something.