Idea - Survivor: Second Chance

So we’ve seen 9 seasons (not counting All Stars) of Survivor. During which we see two early votings in tribal council which are usually unfair and a total turkey shoot. Not always, but often.

So I propose that they should do something like they did with All Stars and put together a game for those people who were the first ones out in the prior seasons.

What do you all think?

There was a reason the early-outs were eliminated first. It could be interesting…or it could be awful!

Survivor: Losers

The first person voted off by every tribe

Sonja Christopher
Debb Eaton
Diane Ogden
Peter Harkey
John Raymond
Ryan Aiken
Nicole Delma
Brook Geraghty

vs

B.B. Andersen
Kel Gleason
Jessie Camacho
Gabriel Cade
Jed Hildebrand
Janet Koth
Michelle Tesauro
Dolly Neely

Kel certainly deserves a second chance. I never thought it was fair to vote him out.

I love the idea. I cried buckets when I saw Dolly taking the walk of shame out of TC. I was sooo looking forward to watching her wriggle through the mud in a tank-top and bikini bottoms. My heart sank when she opened her mouth at TC and glibly announced that she was the swing vote. I just hung my head and muttered “she pulled a Christy…I can’t believe it, she just pulled a Christy…”

Even though he made it fairly far along, I think we should get a sponsor’s exemption and allow Michael Skulpin from Australia to play.

Just so long as there is no friggin’ Rupert.

I just realized… Survivor is The Gong Show.

Only with more skin.

You’re right. It is about time for a Jamie Farr cameo!

It’s not a bad idea, but the first obstacle to overcome is getting the erstwhile oustees to come back for it. Some of them had a miserable time on the show, especially Debb, and have only reluctantly come back for reunion shows. It’s pretty tough emotionally to be the first ousted from the game.

Plus, for this concept, you’d be bringing these people back with the certain knowledge that two of them will be the first booted for the second time.