If LotR Had Been Written By Someone Else!?

Another Simon and Garfunkel…

The Wizard (to the tune of The Boxer)

I am just a hobbit, though my story’s often told-
I have squandered my existence
On a quest to destroy this Ring of Power.
Oh, I must rest! Still I have to continue
And disregard the rest…mmm, mmm, mmm…

When I left my home in the Shire I was no more than a boy,
In the company of old friends,
In the quiet of the Buckland forests, running scared,
Laying low, seeking out the hiding places
Where no Nazgul would go,
Looking for the places they could never know.

[Chorus] Lai luh-lai,
Lai luh-lai lai lai luh-lai,
Lai luh-lai,
Lai luh-lai lai lai luh-lai luh-luh-luh-lai lai…

Asking only for some refuge I go searching high and low
But I find no safety,
Just a come-on from Elrond in elven Rivendell.
“I do declare,” he said, “someone must destroy this Ring.”
And so I volunteered…luh-luh-luh-luh-luh…

repeat chorus

So I’m running now through Moria and wishing I was home,
Going home,
Where the Misty Mountain winters aren’t bleeding me…
Bleeding me…going home…

Off the bridge hangs a wizard and a conjurer by trade
And he carries a reminder of the Balrog that made him fall
And caught him till he cried out, in his anger and his shame,
“I am falling, I am falling, but the wizard still remains!”
Mmm, mmm, mmm…

repeat chorus ad nauseum

Mr. Goodwraith!!!

Bahahahahahahahaahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaahahahahahahahgasps for breath ahahahahahahahahahahahahhaahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaahahahachokes on tonguea-glurg…glurg…coughs tongue back out Ahahahahahahahahaahahahahahahahahahaha.
My brain. You hurt it. Thank you for that.

okay, i had to do it. if anyone’s still reading this thread.

frodo has returned to hobbiton after the adventures recounted in lord of the rings. he is rather bitter and unhappy and has not yet made his way to the grey havens. he sings along to his favorite tori amos song, changing the words a bit…

so i run faster
but she caught me there
yes my luck had turned
at cirith ungol
in the third age
running after gollum
running after the ring

this precious ring
made me bleed
i want to go away
this precious ring
let it break its hold on me

he said you’re really a nasty hobbit
but i like the way it shines
on your finger
so i’ll bite it off
can you believe that? sick sick…
watching me wither
dressing up like a wraith
i wanna smash the faces
of those beautiful elves
immortal elves
so you can go to valinor
doesn’t make you elbereth

this precious ring
made me bleed
i want to go away
this precious ring
let it break its hold on me

i remember
yes in my grey elven cloak
no one dared
no one cared
to tell me where all the pretty elves go
those demigods
when there’s a morgul blade
tucked inside the cloak of every
naaaazguuuuuuuuuul

this precious ring
made me bleed
i want to wash away
this precious ring
why didn’t i get to be king?
i still bleed now,
i want to go away
this this precious ring
let it break
its hold on me

precious…
precious…

amaltheagray :

Brilliant!!! Just perfect. I had thought earlier that this song would work excellently, and so it has. I especially like the line:

ROTFL!!!

From the Annals of Oddur Iskarimil, Book-Keeper of Larúel and Historian of Lands West, an excerpt from Eddie Izzard’s legendary final routine, Alkarin:


“One thing that always amazes me is hobbits. Hobbits.”

[Exaggerates facial movements slightly as he says last word. Stands staring for a few seconds with piquant expression on face. Crowd titters nervously.]

"Hobbits, of course, are a great and wonderful thing, rah rah rah, responsible for bringing us much joy and laughter, dah dah diddly dum. [Walks around, rolls eyes slightly and shakes hand dismissively while talking. Smattering of laughter.] I can just see God up there on Design Day, deciding what to make hobbits like: [imitates God] “Right! Make me a creature with a [counts off dramatically, almost drunkenly, with fingers] taste for good food, an intense love for the homestead, a pleasant disposition, and, ooh, uumm… [stares at sky squinting for a few moments, then looks behind him as if someone just spoke to him] What’s that? Too much? Well all right, we’ll make them… pfft, tell you what. We’ll make them tiny as bloody hell, like this big [places hand at approx. four foot level]. Still too good? Well… oh, all right, just give them, uh… [acts annoyed and befuddled, as if he wants to just get this out of the way. Waves left arm slightly as he says] bloody… hairy feet or something, I don’t bloody know. Oh sod this, I’m off to lunch.” [Mimes sound of door slamming.]

[Stands still while crowd laughs for a few seconds.]

"Or he had this surplus of rough material, you know, a bunch of curly hair just lying around, cluttering up the place, and just didn’t know where to stick it, so to sort of cover things up he put it in the place where it’d be least visible, you know? Yeah, makes sense. But little did he know [speaking now with great emphasis and clear, dramatic enunciation] that that hair was [raises voice], in fact, supposed to go somewhere. This is why you’ll only find one place on a dwarf’s body that isn’t covered with hair. I mean, what did you think all that armor was supposed to cover? [Crowd erupts laughing, excepting group of dwarves that quietly detach themselves from audience and head towards armory down road.]

[Izzard goes off on slight tangent about hair and nether regions, segues into a long diatribe about Elvish, recites passages from “There and Back Again” loudly and theatrically in Elvish to uproarious effect, then deftly weaves his way back to the topic of hobbits.]

"And you know, visiting a hobbit, that’s [points index finger, moves hand rhytmically up and down in hacking fashion], that’s never easy. I was doing a show in the Shire last year, and the thing that struck me about the place is that there’s not a single person there that didn’t feel it was their mission in life to be victorious over their neighbors in the [stares straight forward, speaks in slightly sarcastic monotone] Race To Stuff Eddie Izzard So Full of Pastries They Shall Come Out His Orifices, Oh Yes They Will. [Ends sentence on down note, nods head downwards as he says last word. Crowd laughs, excepting group of hobbit housewives who surreptitiously sharpen kitchen knives.]


There ends the excerpt. Of course, though the show ended in tragedy, it can do naught but add to the legacy that was Izzard Mirth-Maker’s. Long may he live in our memories.

Let’s see somebody cross LotR with “The Usual Suspects.” (I’d do it myself but I don’t know LotR well enough. Best leave it to the experts.)

Gandolf walks out from behind the rather cool looking sails on which are projected shifting, soft pastel colors. He steps onto the disk which is illuminated from below with a white light.

“Hi. I’m Gandolf Edward, welcome to Crossing Under,” Gandolf said with casual ease.

He takes a quick deep breath and lets it out slowly. He rubs his hands together briefly as he stares down at the disk. Then, suddenly he looks up at the gallery toward the right side and straightens his tall pointy hat.

“I’m coming over here,” he said. He steps in that direction, approaching the edge of the bright disk. “I’m getting an older male. I think it’s for someone back there,” he adds, pointing to the back row. “He claims to be a father figure and I’m getting a…it’s like…a unique ess name…like Sar or Saur…it’s an ess arr sounding name. I may be off on the name, but I’m never wrong on the initial or the sound.”

Naturally, no one bothers to respond right away. Gandolf points once again to the back row of the gallery. “I’ve got an older male claiming to be a father figure with a unique ess arr name like, Sar-on.”

Someone finally raises a hand and one of the sound techs rushes over with a boom mic.

“I think that might be for me,” a robed man said when the mic arrived.

“Do you understand the ess arr name?” Gandolf asked.

“I’m an ess arr name,” the man said.

Gandolf stares at the disk for a moment as if thinking or communing with the other world. “If you are then there’s another ess arr name.” Glancing up at the man, Gandolf asked, “What’s your name?”

“Saruman,” the man replied.

“No. That’s not what I’m getting. Do you know a Sauron?” Gandolf Edward asked.

“Yes,” Saruman said. “He’s…”

“No!” Gandolf said quickly. “My job.” He glanced away to more easily concentrate on the subtle energies of the spirit world. “He’s still claiming to be a father figure,” Gandolf said. “Is your father crossed under?”

“Yes, but Sauron isn’t my father…exactly,” Saruman said.

“He’s claiming to be above you,” Gandolf said. “That to me is father, uncle, grandfather…”

“He was, sort of a mentor, you might say,” Saruman said.

“But he was older than you,” Gandolf said, nodding. “Much older he’s telling me.”

Saruman nodded back.

“He’s showing me…” Gandolf stops himself. “First, I have to tell you that I really don’t like doing jewelry and it’s for this reason. It’s something we all have. Everyone has some piece of jewelry whether it’s a necklace or a bracelet or whatever that gets handed down. And all the sceptics are at home now with their clipboards writing down ‘Ooo! He’s going to use the jewelry bit!’”

Gandolf and the gallery all chuckle and laugh. Then, Gandolf turns serious again. “But I do have a rule and that’s I give it as I get it. They give it to me and I pass it on.” After a moment to calm himself, he continues. “Alright. He’s still showing it to me. He’s showing me a ring. A gold ring.”

“A gold ring?” Saruman asked.

“A gold ring,” Gandolf repeated. “He’s saying, ‘one one one’. Now it’s…it’s more like…‘the one’, ‘the one’ and he’s showing me the ring again.” He looks at Saruman again. “Does, ‘the one’ mean anything to you?”

“The one ring?” a short person sitting next to Saruman asked.

Saruman glared at the short person sitting next to him.

“Are you related?” Gandolf asked the two.

“No!” they both replied.

“We’re…aquaintances,” Saruman said.

“You came together?” Gandolf asked.

“Uh, yes,” Saruman replied.

“Sort of,” the short person added reluctantly.

“To me you’re family then,” Gandolf said. “If you came together then your relatives on the other side joined up and came together too.”

“I doubt it,” Saruman muttered with another glare at the little person.

“I’m getting a fr…fro…fro…” Gandolf quieted and listened to the thoughts coming into his head. “I’m getting a froda or frodo?”

“I’m Frodo,” the small person sitting next to Saruman replied.

“You’re…Frodo? Really?” Gandolf asked as if he didn’t believe it himself. Frodo nodded. “He’s telling me that you have the one and he’s showing me the ring again. He just won’t get away from that ring!”

“Yes,” Frodo said. “It’s right here.” He pulled out a chain from beneath the tunic he wore and from it hung a golden ring. “Everybody always called this, ‘the one ring’.”

“Ohh! That’s why he keeps saying ‘the one’ and showing the ring,” Gandolf said. “It’s because that’s what it was called.”

“Ask him if I was supposed to get the ring,” Saruman said.

“No!” Frodo said.

“Easy, Frodo,” the short and heavier set man sitting on Frodo’s other side said.

“Sam, I’m supposed to…” Frodo began.

“No!” Gandolf said. “My job.” He smiled at the gallery and they chuckled. “He’s telling me that the one who bears the ring is the one to carry the ring. I’m getting a pull to my left, to me that’s to the west. Mor…mor…mordor. What’s that?”

“Mordor is a place,” Saruman said.

“Is that out of my state?” Gandolf asked.

“Uh, quite some distance, I would say,” Saruman replied.

“He’s telling me, ‘the one to Mordor, the one to Mordor’,” Gandolf said. “Does this mean anything to you?”

“Yeah,” Frodo said. He glanced at Saruman. “It means you don’t get the ring.”

“He’s pulling his energy back,” Gandolf said. “Just know that he saw this as his way of coming through…”

Saruman tried to grab the ring from Frodo but the little hobbit was quicker than he looked and he tucked the ring back into his tunic while he leapt out of his seat and stepped back. Sam jumped up and placed himself between his friend and the tall Saruman.

“Can we get security out here?” Gandolf said, stopping the show in it’s tracks.

Several dark clad men came from opposite directions and converged on Saruman. Saruman glared at Gandolf angrily. “If my staff wasn’t confiscated when I got here, you and these hirelings of yours would be dust and ash Gandolf!”

One of the dark clad men cuffed Saruman and they led him out of the studio.

“Frodo, we need to talk after the show,” Gandolf said seriously.

-=-

I hope you enjoyed my little contribution. I couldn’t resist doing a Crossing Over With John Edward parody, particularly, when after spending a few days reading the previous posts, I dreamt a part of the scene above.

dstrauss,

I think Galadrial and partners have missed at least two other countercharges in their filing.

Yes, I’m talking about:

  1. Racial discrimination–Hobbits belong to an obscure race against which many of the great powers of Middle-earth have shown a pattern of neglect, or even abuse (recall the history of Sauron’s proxy attack on the Shire through his orc minions).

  2. Discrimination against the disabled–Hobbits are stature-challenged or differently statured, whichever term happens to be more politically correct at the moment. I can’t recall the exact name of the statute involved–something like the CIDA (Children of Iluvatar with Disabilities Act). Of course, since this stature issue is a racial characteristic, your client’s opponents might challenge this charge on the basis that it is subsumed in the previous charge of racial discrimination.

DISCLAIMERS:

  1. Since I am not licensed to practice law–nor likely ever to be, I hope-- the counter-plaintiffs should seek the advise and assistance of qualified legal counsel before acting on the above information.

  2. Since what I’ve said is based entirely on a second-hand account of the events (which, as well, I read in a translation by yet another hand) I can offer no evidence worthy of the courtroom. (In other words, it would be a waste of time to subpoena me.)

(But if you recover any damages or otherwise find my information useful, I wouldn’t mind an invitation to lunch at, say, the Caras Galadhon Cafe.)

I can’t believe this hasn’t been done!

At the Prancing Pony Inn:

Pippin (Eric Idle): Evening.

Butterbur (Terry Jones): Evening.

Pippin: Well, what you got?

Butterbur: Well, there’s egg and bacon; egg, sausage and bacon; egg and spam; egg, bacon and spam; egg, bacon, sausage and spam; spam, bacon, sausage and spam; spam, egg, spam, spam, bacon and spam; spam, sausage, spam, spam, spam, bacon, spam, tomato and spam; spam, spam, spam, egg and spam; (Big Folk start singing in background) spam, spam, spam, spam, spam, spam, baked beans, spam, spam, spam and spam.

Big Folk: Spam, spam, spam, spam, lovely spam, lovely spam.

Butterbur: (cont) …or Lobster Thermidor a Crevette with a mornay
sauce served in a Southfarthing manner with shallots and aubergines
garnished with mushroom pate, brandy [ed.-probably an Old Winyards brandy] and with a fried egg on top and spam.

Merry: Have you got anything without spam?

Butterbur: Well, there’s spam, egg, sausage and spam. That’s not got much spam in it.

Merry: I don’t want any spam!

Pippin: Why can’t he have egg, bacon, spam and sausage?

Merry: That’s got spam in it.

Pippin: It hasn’t got as much spam in it as spam, egg, sausage and spam has it?

Merry: (over Big Folk starting again) Could you do me egg, bacon, spam and sausage without the spam then?

Butterbur: Ech!

Merry: What do you mean ech! I don’t like spam!

Big Folk: Lovely spam, wonderful spam…etc

Butterbur: Shut up! Shut up! Shut up! Bloody Big Folk. You can’t have egg, bacon, spam and sausage without the spam.

Merry: I don’t like spam!

Pippin: Shh, Merry, don’t cause a fuss. I’ll have your spam. I love it. I’m having spam, spam, spam, spam, spam, spam, spam, baked beans, spam, spam, spam and spam. (starts Big Folk off again)

Big Folk: Lovely spam, wonderful spam…etc

Butterbur: Shut up! Baked beans are off.

Pippin: Well, can I have his spam instead of the baked beans?

Butterbur: You mean spam, spam, spam, spam, spam, spam, spam, spam, spam, spam, spam, and spam?

Big Folk: Lovely spam, wonderful spam…etc…spam, spam, spam! (in harmony)

Someone please touch this up to make it sound more like Butterbur and the hobbits>

Excellent job!! Much better than my attempt. I could practically hear Rush’s voice. My hat is tipped to you… :slight_smile:

I haven’t gone through the entire thread, but I what I’ve read so far is brilliant! This is really a total rip-off of Paul Auster’s “The Music of Chance”, I only changed a few words, but I think it’s ok none-the-less.

For one whole year he did nothing but run, travelling back and forth across Middle Earth as he waited for his luck to run out. He hadn’t expected it to go on that long, but one thing kept leading to another, and by the time Frodo understood what was happening to him, he was past the point of wanting it to end.
Three days into the thirteenth month he met up with the man who called himself Strider. It was one of those random, accidental encounters that seem to materialize out of thin air – a twig that breaks off in the wind and suddenly lands at your feet. Had it occurred at any other moment, it is doubtful that Frodo would have opened his mouth.
But because he had already given up, because he figured there was nothing to lose anymore, he saw the stranger as a reprieve, as a last chance to do something for himself before it was too late. And just like that, he went ahead and did it. Without the slightest tremor of fear, Frodo closed his eyes and jumped.
It all came down to a question of sequence, the order of events. If it had not taken the wizard six months to find him, he never would have been on the road the day he met Aragorn, son of Arathorn, and therefore none of the things that followed from that meeting ever would have happened…

Here’s your “Usual Suspects” parody, NDP. Yeah, I know Legolas wasn’t at Minas Tirith or anything, but I needed a sniper. :slight_smile:

THE USUAL FELLOWSHIP - directed by Brian Singer
EXT. MINAS TIRITH - DAY

LEGOLAS stands on the walls of the citadel, arrow nocked and drawn, looking down at the NAZGUL on their BLACK WINGED STEEDS, circling FARAMIR and his men below. Legolas stares down the shaft of the arrow at the Nazgul.

LEGOLAS
(muttering)
One…two…three, four, five…six seven…eight…nine. (beat) Heh. Eowyn was a fag.

Oh, and <b>Epigramcracker</b>, I’m glad you liked it. What’s scary is how little is changed. All that stuff about the evil eye is actually in there.

That liberal arts education has to be good for something

It is typical of Butterbur’s that not a single person, man or Hobbit, batted an eyelid when Gandalf materialized out of thin air and plopped semi-graciously onto a barstool. Sam Gamgee didn’t even drop a note in his rendition of “The Road Goes Ever On”.

“A pint of your best, Butterbur,” he said as a smoke ring shaped itself into the infinity symbol above his head.
Slurping the foam from his beer, he turned to the assembled crowd. The room grew silent; when Gandalf spoke even the dog stopped wagging.
“Well”, he said. “It seems that the One Ring has been loosed on the world again.”
He took another draught while he waited for the rooba rooba to die down.
“Yes, it’s true. Sauron casts his evil eye across the world to once again claim the power that once was his. Long ago, the One Ring was wrested from him, and over the years it has made its way through many hands until it has come to rest in the Shire. Now, it must be delivered to Mount Doom before the Dark Lord can find it and regain the iron hold on its one power that he once held.”

More rooba rooba.

“But Doc…I mean Gandalf!..” broke in Frodo. “If Sauron had such a tight hold on the One Ring, how was it ever wrested from him in the first place?”
“Don’t you know…,” said the wizard, as a slow, sly grin appeared through his whiskers. “There’s only one thing that can get the One Ring off the hand of Sauron.”

“You mean?..”

“That’s right…Lard of the Rings.”

from “The Barstools of the Rings” by Spider Robinson.

Someone, PLEASE try your hand at “Doc Savage.” I don’t have any of the books any longer for reference, or I’d try it myself.

I don’t know which might work best–

  1. Keep original Middle-earth characters and settings, adjusted to sound like Doc Savage & co. with a hint of 1930’s atmosphere.

  2. Re-set LotR in a more Doc-like world of 1930’s with the 102nd floor headquarters, the gadgets, the Monk & Ham-style banter (and “Holy Cow!”), the Mayan (Smaug-ian?) gold, Hidalgo Trading Co., the secret upstate “hospital”–or House of Healing–for criminal minds, and of course, the occasional mysterious trilling sound from the Doc-character. (Probably = Gandalf, since they’re both wizards of one sort or another.)

But I suspect the first alternative would be a bit easier.

In either case, the Ring would of course be the creation or archaeological? discovery of a power-mad genius bent on world conquest–perhaps a Hitler-like figure, and a Saruman-puppet henchman of his who probably winds up getting sent to the upstate compound in the end.

I can’t wait to hear this if someone will take it on.

Such brilliance… have a look at the wonderful http://lyingmofo.ohskylab.com btw.

Here’s my puny attempt:
Khazad-dûm
by J.R.R. Coleridge

In Khazad-dûm did evil fall
And stately Aragorn despair:
Where Gandalf, wizard grey, he fell
Through caverns measureless by ell
Down to the Endless Stair.

Up twice five miles through carven stone
With staff and sword he chased alone:
Until he reached the lonely Durin’s Tower,
Where awaited him an incensed bleeding Balrog;
And here both sides were matched by equal power,
Expiring to go to the Halls of Mandos.


(Nothing rhymes with Balrog. Except Azog, but that’s another story…)

Everyone’s so … AMAZING!!

I love all you ppl’s creativity. I am in awe.

**klai **and others:

I can only remember the beginning of the second part, after the lacuna-like break resulting, it is said, by the interruption of the infamous visitor–was he from Bree? I don’t remember exactly. (You’ll recall that the poet claimed to have composed or envisioned the first part during a miruvor-enduced trance–or was it a funky batch of pipeweed?)

It goes something like this:

A damsel with a mithril harp
in a vision once came to my sight:
It was a Lorien elven-maid
And on her mithril harp she played
Singing of Mount Everwhite.

Can anyone remember the rest?

A quick query at http://www.onelook.com for “words ending in *og” (http://www.onelook.com/?w=*og&ls=a) yielded over 100 results. What about warthog, analog, antismog, backlog, catalog, or hounddog (paving the way for Elvis Presley’s “You Ain’t Nothin’ But a Balrog”)<g>?

lastin

klai, I love your “Xanadu!” Absolutely brilliant! I’ll never be able to hear the original again.