I used to be a really regular poster on the Foo Fighters postboard.
Over a 3 year period, I lost count of the number of threads which revolved around the same sort of theme… namely…
Some notable music magazine (insert any prominent name here) would compile a list of some sort…
**Top 50 singles of all time…
Top 100 albums of all time…
50 Worst bands of all time…
Top 20 most overrated albums of all time…**
etc etc etc You get the drift by now.
After a while, some things became really, REALLY obvious to me. Basically, music magazines, in the final analysis don’t really have much to offer these days. Their era has kinda passed 'em by - what with messageboards, and band websites, and file sharing etc etc.
So these magazines (all of 'em - mark my words) tend to fall into these stupid popularity contest polls with regular ad nauseum - and ultimately - the goal is simply to sell more units.
And the single most effective way to get your magazine publicity, any publicity, is to compile a totally subjective list which really can’t be argued with in any sort of empirical black and white terms - seeing as how it’s all opinion based.
Anyways, I ended up getting very, VERY bored with the Foo Fighters postboard. These same sort of threads came up with vomit inducing regularity and ultimately it betrayed a certain lack of originality - both in the music business today in general - and those hanger-on industrys like music magazines which live off it.
It’s basically occurred to me that almost every possible chord progression and melodic phrasing and tempo variation has already been invented. The challenge nowadays is who can rip off an old forgotten song the best, without getting busted for it?
An example - the chord progression in Foo Fighters song “Generator” is a total rip off of “The Rain Song” by Led Zeppelin but it’s set to a much faster tempo. That’s the sort of “hidden plagiarism” I’m talking about nowadays.
The magazines have got so little to write about that well, lists like this one are all they can fall back on as a staple diet to ship copies.