My dad is a very generous guy, and he really likes to be generous. But he has a habit of offering something very generous to me and then when I accept, changing the offer at the last moment.
Most recent example: After I found out I was pregnant I started looking out for a new car to replace Birdman’s broken car. Dad mentioned he was looking to upgrade his Prius and I mentioned that if he did so I’d like to buy the old one. Once I told him I was pregnant he got all excited and offered to just give us the old Prius once he got a new one. I was all for that, unfortunately a couple weeks later new Priuss got very difficult to come by, what with Japan getting all disastered. After that, my dad made a different offer–since he wouldn’t be getting a new car soon he would just give us some money to get a new car. Great! This is all awesome!
Now keep in mind that up to this point it’s all been his idea to straight up give us the car/money, all I did was mention I’d buy his old one off him.
Anyway, last week we got Birdman’s broken car towed to the shop to see if it was worth fixing enough to sell. It was really, really, not worth fixing, so I made a deal with one of the mechanics to take it off our hands for $200. I called Dad to let him know we weren’t going to be getting any trade money for the broken car and to ask how much he was offering to give us to get a replacement. He said $10,000. Awesome, I said! Very Generous!
This weekend I found a great little car on Craigs List that was being sold for $10,000 obo. Great! I told Dad about it and then Birdman and I went to visit it. It drove great and the owner offered to take it in to the service shop with us tomorrow to get it checked out. It all sounded like this was the car for us, so I called my dad to let him know.
Me: “Hey Dad, the car is great and I think we’ll offer him $9000 for it and see how it goes. Is that cool with you, or do you need some time to cover that?”
Him: “No, I don’t need any time, I can cover it now. So how much were you thinking about putting toward the car?”
Me: “Um, me? Well, we don’t have any money until we sell the house…? I guess when we have the equity we could give you some back?”
Him: “Ok, how about I cover the car and you can give me $2000 when you sell the house.”
Me: “Ok, yeah, that sounds good…K, I’ll let you know how the inspection goes…”
So yeah. We aren’t getting $10,000 we’re getting more like $7500, depending on how much the owner sells it for. Which is fine, and very generous of Dad…but it’s not what he offered in the first place. If he had said “Hey, how about I offer to help you buy a car, I’ll cover 80% up to $10,000” or something, then I could have planned it out. I would have waited until after we had the house sold to have the equity squared away, or I would have gotten a little loan from the bank, or something. I am grateful for his help, but I wish he would be a little less generous in his initial offer so I can know what to reasonably expect from him.
I also have no idea how to handle this next time he decides to be generous with us. It has happened over and over in my life, but I keep taking him at his word and then being disappointed when he doesn’t keep it, but then feeling like I have no legs to stand on to be disappointed.