I've lost weight! Yay! So why am I freaking out? (long, whiney, self-obsessed)

I’ve lost about 25 pounds in the last year. I’d lost 15 pounds before, then gained back 5, and my goal for the summer was to lose another 15 pounds, and I made it.

In many ways, this is a new experience for me. I’m thinner than I’ve been in my life. I’ve been a size 14 since I reached my full height. I’m now a size 12. I’ve also never acheived a weight-loss goal before. Either I had no goal other than “lose a few pounds” or I drifted away from the diet well before I reached any goal. Now that I’ve made the goal, I’m not really sure what to do.

I’d need to lose 10 more pounds to get my BMI down out of the “overweight” range. I realize that BMIs are pretty arbitrary, and I want to emphasize that I’m not setting my weight-loss goals based on BMI, but that gives you some idea where I’m at. Or, I’m 182 pounds soakin’ wet, 5 feet 9 inches, if that means more to you.

When losing moderate amounts of weight in the past, I’d end up a bit slimmer and my clothes would fit better, which made me feel better about myself. I’d always thought that more weight loss would be more of the same: maybe I’d get the chance to go out and buy some cute new clothes, and losing weight would make my body look better.

Well, now I’ve lost a lot of weight (for me) and I’m kinda freaking out about my body.

When trying to get dressed this morning, I realize that my favorite pants don’t fit. In fact, they look awful. Last week I had to go buy a new belt, because the old one was too big, and my jeans were falling down. I think I’m going to have to buy all new pants. That should make me happy. I thought it would make me feel happy! But instead, I’m thinking, “Nooooo! My pants! My beautiful, beautiful pants! I finally got nice pants that fit me, and now it’s all ruined!”

When I gently grasp my forearms, I can feel bone. I lie awake in bed feeling my ribs, because it just creepy being able to feel the rack of them in there. When I look down at my legs, I find myself thinking, “Who are you and what have you done with my thighs?” I guess they look nicer, and more muscular, and less cellulitey . . . but they don’t look like they belong on my body. Even worse, I have odd globs of fat that persist in a few places on my body, which (IMHO) look awful. When I was fat before, I was curvy. Now I’m thinner in some places, yet globby in others. I feel like this cancels out most of the conventional “attractiveness” I’ve acheived by losing weight.

And that’s totally irrational, which freaks me out even further. Nobody is looking at my body thinking, “Wow, her calfs and quads are really nicely defined. But what’s up with those globs of fat on her inner, upper thigh that I can’t even see because they’re only visible when she’s standing in front of the bathroom mirror in her underwear! God, that’s disgusting. She is completely unattractive!” Am I turning into one of those body-dismorphic chicks? Am I going to go crazy and lose forty more pounds and be mincing around with my collar bones jutting out going, “Oh my gawd, I’m so fat. My body is so disgustingly faaaat”?

And speaking of conventional attractiveness . . . I went through many years of coping with my fatness by thinking that people who diet are shallow, and their physical attractiveness is offset by that fact that they are boring and obsessed with appearances. And, really, I’m more shallow than I used to be, in that use a hell of a lot of brain cycles thinking about calories and fat grams and what I’m going to do at the gym. Am I turning into what I used to hate? Was I wrong for hating that in the past? Should I just accept that the lifestyle changes that are making me a healthier person are also making me less . . . deep?

Okay, really, I know people who are thin who are smart and deep and nice and fun to be with, so I know it’s bullshit, but I’m . . . just . . . Cripes, I don’t even know where my head is right now.

My mom was very hurt by her own mother telling her she was too heavy, and what with growing awareness of eating disorders, she seemed terrified of giving my sister and me an unhealthy body image when we were teenagers. She always encouraged us to eat healthy nurtritious food and excercise, but if we said we wanted to go on a diet she would flip out. She told us over and over that our weight was fine (and really, we were only slightly overweight in high school), that we were beautiful as we were, that losing weight is not the key to beauty and happiness. This is true enough in and over itself, but I halfway suspect that between Mom’s anorexiphobia and my own coping mechanisms, I’m wired so that being overweight means normal, happy, beautiful and losing weight means . . . none of those things.

When my BMI was on the borderline between “overweight” and “obese,” I had some trouble with high blood pressure, and I continue to monitor my blood pressure closely. It is still on the high side of normal, meaning that I’m likely to get hypertension in the future, especially if I don’t maintain a healthy lifestyle. So, if I lose some more weight, it may be that I can bring down my blood pressure further, and decrease my chances of experiencing future health problems.

And, in fact, it seems to be willfully stupid to say, “My diet is working well for me, but, even though my weight is higher than it should be for optimum health, I’m going to stop losing weight because I’m afraid to be skinny and ugly and shallow.”

Right now I’m continuing my diet, more out of habit than anything else. I thought about taking a “break” briefly, not restricting my calorie intake, but continuing to track what I eat and my weight. Does that sound like a really bad idea? I was thinking that I might get used to the way I look, and maybe (please, please, please!!!) my globby fat will redistribute itself a bit, and I will stop feeling so stupid and irrational and weird about all of this. On the other hand I’m afraid that breaking discipline now will mean losing my diet “momentum,” and could even lead to my weight going back up.

Has anyone else experienced anything like this, or am I just special? I cannot even imagine what it would be like to lose 50 or 100 pounds and see your body completely change shape! If you’ve lost a significant amount of weight, were you feeling cool with it the whole time? Did you ever find yourself wishing you had your old body back?

I’ve never expierenced what you’re going through exactly. I’ve never lost a dramatic ammount of weight. But once I did read a funny short story by woody Allen about a thin man on his death bed and he was longing for the return of his ‘fat’ body of his youth.
The thing I think you should do is to be more concerned about yourself than your pants. So your nice pants are too big. Either have them taken in or get new ones. Your body is in transition right now. I think you’ll like where it ends up.

Stay on your healthy diet. Go shopping for some new clothes that will look swell on your slimmer body. What you are talking about almost sounds like something subconscious trying to sabatage all your hard work. Do you think you might benefit from a bit of counseling?

I’ve been overweight in the past. At one time I lost 85 lbs over the course of a year. I’ve been between 125 and 130 for a while now. I see it as something I must do because I don’t ever want to be as close to morbidly obese as I was again. I treat my dietary regimine as though I were a diabetic and “cannot” eat like I did before.

I can DO more now that I am slimmer. I FEEL better now that I am slimmer. I don’t think that makes me less dimensional than I was before.

Hang in there. I think you’ll get used to how you look now.

There was an article in the New Yorker a few months ago about the very topic.

The gist of the article was that a number of people found that when they lost large amounts of weight, their lifestyles changed. It allowed them to be more active. More athletic. They had more friends and a social life. They could dress sexier. One of the issues many of them faced was that their friends and family often had trouble adjusting to the “new” them. For example, if you and your friends always considered skinny, attractive people “shallow”, how might they react to you now that you have essentially become one of those people? Sometimes people even get divorced. When the plump, mousy girl he married looses some weight and is now thin and more confident, he might feel that this is no longer the person he fell in love with.

The point is that with any major lifestyle change, expect that there will be major adjustments. Probably one of the best things you can do is buy some new clothes and try out a few different styles.

Stay on your healthy new diet.

Try doing something like pilates - that will whip the globby fat into shape in no time - it won’t necessarily get rid of it, but it will make it a nicer shape.

Consign your old nice pants - if you’re in even a remotely big town (more than 30,000) they’ll have a consignment shop - you’ll get a bit of $$ and the old “fat” pants won’t be there taking up space.

Buy yourself a couple of really nice outfits that flatter your new shape and make you feel like a million bucks.

Thats it.

I’ve never actually lost a bunch of weight, but a girlfriend of a girlfriend lost about 85 lbs doing weightwatchers and went from a 24 to about a 12 or 14 I think - she was a bit…odd, after losing the weight - but she did get used to it, and kind of went back to being her old self - only a bit smaller.

Good for you and your improved health. :slight_smile:

Stay on your diet. In fact, you know what? It’s not a diet. It’s a life. If you simply make the decision that this is how you’re going to live from now on, then you’re going to be slim and healthy forever. Doesn’t that sound nice?

Apparently not, since you’re having problems with it. I’m not sure I can help you there, 'cause I don’t recognise your experiences at all. I’ve lost weight and built muscle and am freaking ecstatic about it. Maybe you just need time. But stick to the diet.

Podkayne ,

By any chance, have you been thirsty more lately?

Not wanting to raise any alarms, but unexpected weight loss is one of the indicators…

Dieting always makes me a bit loopy, too. Probably from a combination of lack of blood sugar and spending too much time looking at myself in the mirror. :slight_smile: What you’re going through is perfectly normal. Just be sure to spend more time looking at the new awesome/sexy bits than the “ugly” stuff.

Worst comes to worst and you find yourself getting too crazy, just go off the diet for a week or two to reset your brain. It’s a good idea to do this every few months anyway, just for morale.

As for the clothing weirdness, wait until you’ve managed to diet yourself into the children’s clothing section, like I managed to do over the summer. Nothing quite like having to shop for boy’s underwear because all the men’s clothing bottoms out at a 32" waist…

The next girl I date is going to burst out laughing when I strip down to reveal my oh-so-sexy Spiderman Underoos. :smiley:

Answer, part 2

Does remembering to brush your teeth or wash your hair make you feel shallow, too? Nothing bad about living healthy and trying to look your best.

The fat probably won’t distribute, unless you have an alien physiology. But taking a week or two to get your head screwed back on straight isn’t a bad idea, so long as you don’t go nuts with the eating. It’ll also give you a chance to enjoy the new you without having obsess with a bunch of numbers.

Never. Of course, I’ve only lost 20-30 lbs. Just give yourself time to adjust mentally.

I had the opposite experience. I was a very skinny person who was always being asked if I were anorexic. One day I looked in the mirror and scared the hell out of myself, so I started dieting to gain weight. As I began to succeed, I started having a lot of second thoughts. I actually felt I was losing some of my identity, as stupid as that may sound. I had to constantly remind myself that I was doing something good for my health.

I had a hard time letting go of my clothes too…it was so hard to find the right sizes when I was scrawny, I was afraid I’d lose weight and never find anything to wear again. Buying new clothes helped a lot.

I’m still not happy with how my body looks (surprise!) but I’ve decided to quit trying to adjust myself to the perfect weight and start working out at the gym instead. I read something not long ago that said something like, “Your body is not an ornament, but a functional object.” Very obvious, but it really got through to me, because I had always been so fixated on how I looked. From now on I’m trying to appreciate my body for what it can do.

I lost 50 pounds since December, and I feel great. After 5 years of being fat, I finally have my old body back. It’s so exciting to feel pretty and sexy again, and to not have to shop at the “fat” stores anymore (i.e. Lane Bryant).

I know what you’re talking about with the clothes though. The 3 pairs of cute shorts I bought 2 months ago are huge. I literally didn’t have a single pair of pants that fit me anymore. But when I went shopping recently and fit into a juniors size 9 pair of jeans, it was the greatest feeling! I remember a time when I couldn’t ever find a normal pair of jeans that fit because my thighs were so fat. Now I can fit into the juniors skinny jeans and it’s awesome. Every time I look in the mirror, I’m like “Wow!” And it just motivates me even more. I want to lose 10 more pounds then I’m done!

And no, you’re not being shallow! Savor the excitement! You deserve it.

Gah! Just thinking about how I’ve struggled over the last three months . . . unexpected weight loss?! No.

In fact, it’s gloriously predictable. I’ve been tracking what I eat and my activities at fitday.com. I’m eating an average of 1750 calories a day. I’m burning approximately 2350 calories a day. That’s a difference of 600 calories per day. A pound of fat is 3500 calories. That’s a predicted weight loss of 0.17 pounds a day, or approximately 5 pounds a month. I started the diet in June. In three months, I lost fifteen pounds.

As a physicist, I find it extremely satisfying that the numbers actually work out. :slight_smile: If only Physics 101 labs always worked out so well . . . :wink:

Thank you everyone for the perspective.

In particular, Dung Beetle and Tupug Anachi’s comments are resonanting with me. I shouldn’t just remember being overweight as having a different body shape, I should remember: high blood pressure, having to breathe hard walking up hill or climbing stairs, not having the energy to peel my butt off the couch in the evening . . . And, thinking of the future, every pound I lose is a pound I don’t have to drag along when I go for a run. :slight_smile:

So, okay, you’re all correct, I need to stop staring at the bathroom mirror, and buy new pants.

I can understand part of this. I’ve lost about 25 pounds over, oh, six months or so, and I looked at myself in the mirror last week and suddenly thought, “I’m not fat anymore!” I’m still overweight, but there’s been a big change.

After a lifetime of putting yourself down for being fat, that “putdown” part of your thinking is still grasping at straws, trying to pick on flaws. I can’t say I’ve conquered that, myself, but my counselor says I should ask myself, “Does this make sense? Is this reasonable?”

My mom’s advice is that one of the most important things that helped her stay on her diet and lose the weight she needed to lose was to buy new clothes. If your old nice clothes are still there, and you’re wearing them and you look bad in them, it’s tempting to just fit back into them. If you’ve either donated, consigned, or stored them and are wearing your new clothes, you won’t want to grow out of them because you’ll look nice because your clothes fit.

I’ve been having the opposite identity crisis myself - I was one of those girls everybody always thought was anorexic in high school and college because of my high metabolism. I was always trying to gain weight. And everybody would tell me “Wait until your mid-20’s, your metabolism will slow down.” And you know, I didn’t believe them. So in the last two years I’ve gained a fourth of my previous personhood. Jesus. I’ve outgrown two rounds of pants and I have got to do something about this. Most people can’t even really tell (for one thing, my boyfriend didn’t know me before) but it bothers me to no end because I look at myself in the mirror in my underwear and somebody else’s body has replaced mine!

It makes me sad and anxious and depressed, but to be honest it’s really more upsetting that I don’t look like myself than that I gained 25 pounds (that people say they can’t even see). One does hope that this new “let’s learn to garden, and while we’re at it let’s buy a reel mower” thing will help, because I’ve been so slack about going to the gym I might as well cancel my membership.

Counter tip: Stop dieting - start living.

You sound like you get obsessed with figures. The calories, the pounds lost, your blood pressure. You are totally (and i mean no offense) self-obsessed here. It’s no wonder you are looking at the new you and feeling strange if you are so critical and interested in what’s going on. You need to rethink yourself. You are not a fat person trying to slim - you are a slim person. It’s time to let the fat person go.

Keep eating healthily, keep exercising. But stop counting. Let the calorie figures slide right out of your head and build a new relationship with food. One where you are concentrating on enjoying what you eat and then stopping when you have had enough. And build a new relationship with exercise - do it for fun rather than to number crunch. And maybe try some weights as well as aerobic exercise to get a little toned.

Other than that, get some new clothes, ditch the old ones (AND that unflattering mirror) and enjoy your new healthy body :slight_smile:

This sounds a lot like my experience! In January of 2003, my doctor gently suggested to me that I stop thinking about losing weight and actually do something about it. I started an exercise program and a sensible diet (much the same numbers as yours, as a matter of fact), and lost between 4 and 6 pounds a month until finally, about a year later, I’d lost 70 lbs. I went from 215 to 145 (I’m 5’10" or so), which was actually five or ten pounds less than my goal, but that’s the weight my body seems to have settled on.

I went through the same weirdness about how my “new” body looks, and it took me a while to get used to it. In the middle of the weight-loss year, I found myself thinking that I was lumpy-looking, which wasn’t any more attractive than the original fat, but I either got less lumpy or got used to how I looked. I still sometimes feel a disconnect between how I look and how I think I look, but that’s improving.

The shallowness factor is there, too. I always disdained people who spent a lot of time on their physical self, assuming they weren’t deep thinkers, but now that I’m healthy and fit, I think it’s worth the amount of time I have to spend on keeping myself that way. The obsession with numbers faded after I’d reached my goal and maintained it for a while, by the way.

I’ve been the same size and weight (within five pounds) for a year and a half now, and the feelings of my body being alien and just not “right” have dwindled. I’m accustomed to how I look now, just as I was when I was overweight, and the best part about it isn’t so much the cute pants as it is knowing how strong and healthy I really am. I wouldn’t trade this for all the cake and couch time in the world.

I went through something similar to you years ago. I have to confess that I didn’t lose nearly as much weight (I lost 25 lbs that I’d put on when I’d been injured, couldn’t exercise, and porked up). Also, I didn’t have exactly the same thoughts as you. However, I did have a lot of thoughts about how I didn’t like who I was becoming by dieting.

Honestly, I just thought about it too much. I needed to relax. Everything was okay. I suspect it is with you as well.

I think what happened is that when I started trying to lose weight, I spent a lot of time planning meals, scheduling exercise, and counting calories. I got used to thinking about weight related things for a good portion of my day. After a while, I got really sick of weight loss being such a big part of my life. I did feel shallow because I thought about weight-related things so much and didn’t think about much else. What happened to the days when I didn’t think about those things for days at a time? And I started worrying that this was the way it would be for the rest my life.

You know what? It wasn’t. I was just at that awkward stage where I was moving from making it such a conscious thing to becoming a habit. It happened. Over time, I thought less about weight-related things. It became less of a conscious, constantly planning thing and more an unconscious pattern. I can’t eat whatever I want whenever I want to, but I don’t think about it so much. It happened slowly for me and will likely happen more slowly for you because you’ve lost more weight and so have been dieting longer.

In the meantime, do some fun things for yourself that don’t involve weight loss. Get a massage or manicure/pedicure (it doesn’t make you feel shallow; it makes you feel pampered). Join a bookclub or find some other intellectual pursuit. You haven’t become “shallow” or less of a thinker becaue you’ve lost weight. It wasn’t brain mass that you lost!

Also you may consider participating in a sports league or training for some physical event. You have the energy now. Plus, setting goals, seeing yourself improve, and learning to enjoy what your body can do is very fulfilling. Exercise stops being all about a chore you have to do in order to lose/maintain a weight goal and starts being a fun way to acheive something. I started horseback riding and it was one of the best things I ever did.

And do get at least one or two new outfits. I know it’s a lot of fun to buy new clothes when you want to but it’s no fun at all when you have to (no idea why that is). But no one feels good when they don’t have anything in their closet that looks good on them.

Finally, when you start worrying about your body or obsessing on the perceived negatives of your diet, tell yourself you’re overthinking it again. It’s probably easy for a physicist to get caught up in a loop of overanalysis! But that’s all it is. You’re fine. You’re just making a transition and it will take some time.

InternetLegend, whew, thanks. It’s good to know someone else has been there.

zelie, I see where you’re coming from, and maybe I’m being a little defensive, but I don’t think that being obsessed with numbers is a bad thing. I’m an astronomer. I look for mathematical relationships to explain what we see in nature. I’m not just obsessed with numbers as regards my health, I’m obsessed with numbers, period. Counting calories might not seem very appealing to you, but then you probably wouldn’t like my job, either! I crunch numbers and stare at graphs and charts for a living. Applying similar principles to dieting is only natural for me.

I should just build a new relationship with food, eh? :dubious: While I’m at it, I should also probably build a new relationship with my father and work out a successful peace plan for the Middle East. Right now, numbers are giving me a structure that lets me decide what and how much to eat. Listening to my body and my emotions doesn’t work. My body is so stupid it doesn’t know the difference between “tired” and “hungry” and “thirsty” and sends the same signals for all three. It doesn’t really speak up when it’s full, either; it prefers to wait until it’s stuffed. Emotionally, well, I’d be happiest if I was eating delicious food all the time. In order to eat right, I have to argue with my body and my emotions, and, just like at the Straight Dope :slight_smile: it’s easiest to do that when I have hard numbers on my side.

Am I using it as a crutch? Maybe. But I don’t mind it and it’s working, so what’s the harm? It’s helping me build good habits that are now almost second nature, like drinking a glass of water when I feel munchy, and shoving aside my first instincts and choosing a smaller portion. But I know I don’t have the willpower to abadon calorie counting completely. I allow myself one day a week when I don’t enter what I eat. Three weeks out of four I eat sensibly on that day, but sometimes bad habits rear their ugly heads on that day, and it’ll throw me off for a week afterward. I lose my zen and get weird cravings. This is how I’ve drifted away from diets in the past. A bad day leads to a bad week, and before you know it I’m eating the same way I always did. If I have the cold, hard numbers at hand, then I can face down a craving, something I can’t acheive through willpower alone.

Maybe I’m I going to have to keep doing this forever, and keep logging my calories to be sure I don’t consume more than I burn. If it helps me stay healthy, though, and I don’t mind it, I’m going to keep doing it. I’ve been doing this for almost four months now, which is longer than I’ve been able to sustain any other diet/lifestyle change.

As for exercise, happily it’s not an issue. I exercise because it feels freakin’ awesome, and because (this blows my mind) I am now a Person Who Exercises. Can’t do without it. If I miss a workout, I get twitchy. I fantasize about running and look forward to getting home, putting on my shoes, and hitting the pavement. Then again, I use numbers as a tool in exercise, too. I’ve found that working toward a goal is a great way to keep myself excited about the next workout,. Every week, I’m increasing my speed or duration, so it’s always something new to look forward to. And, yeah, I enter it into Fitday, but a couple hundred calories are just not enough for me to get excited about. I don’t exercise to lose weight, I excercise for endurance and strength and energy and flexibility, and because I love it.

I’ve been working out at Curves since January, and doing the Curves eating plan for a month. Since January, I have lost 12 lbs (10 lbs of which was fat); since a month ago, I’ve lost 4 lbs. It doesn’t seem like much. It doesn’t seem like anything. I look in the mirror and while I don’t look pregnant anymore (which I did at my heaviest point), I still look fat to me. I bet I could lose another 10 lbs and still look fat to me.

Keep in mind, at 4’10", 12 lbs is a significant shift - and a pound a week is healthy, and more likely to stay off than weight lost more quickly. My size 8 pants are loose now; I was wearing size 10 when I started. I’ve lost a total of 20" (from bust, arm, thigh, waist, abdomen, hips). Even my workout pants (Brooks running pants) are loose now. I know these things. But I still look fat to me. Except my face. My face looks like it’s somebody else’s. And my collar bones, they’re somebody else’s, too.

I think it’s normal to freak out. I’m actually having more trouble adjusting to being nearly 40 years old than to my weight change or lack thereof. These life changes, they’re hard. Hopefully, as long as you can tell yourself “I am making myself more healthy,” you get get past the ‘but I look weird to me’ thing.

As far as the favorite pants go, can you find another pair of the same brand in the next size down? Maybe on Ebay? That’s what I’d try to do. I hate it when my favorite clothes don’t work for me anymore.