Jewish family holiday psychosis (longish)

Mom’s Passover psychosis seems to be starting early this year. I’m seriously wishing I’d done something intelligent for Passover this year, like I did last year, i.e. leave the country.

Mom has a very annoying habit of coming up with last-minute things that she needs me to do for family holiday gatherings, a tendency which is exacerbated by the fact that she never seems to be able to decide until the last minute when we are going to get together, or sometimes whether we’re going to get together at all. Frequently it’ll be the day before a holiday, and I still won’t know when she wants me to show up or what she wants me to bring, or how many people are coming, which is useful information to have when one is expected to plan, shop for, and cook around half of the meal. Then, when I get frustrated and upset with her, she starts her usual rant about how I’m not observant enough, and don’t I care about my Jewish heritage, and how somehow she manages to make the time to get everything done for holidays…today she called me at work to discuss it, in spite of my repeated requests not to call me at work unless it’s an emergency. Well, apparently Passover is an emergency.

This year she’s apparently decided that I should take next Wednesday off of work to prepare for Passover, so that I can drive 40 miles to the home of a family friend, whom I can’t stand, to spend Seder, deal with the family friend and her even more annoying mother for an entire evening, and then drive 40 miles home, probably arriving around midnight if I’m lucky, just in time to go to sleep and wake up at 6 a.m. to go to work the next day. Nevermind that we only hear from this “friend” when there’s an occasion that involves us buying gifts for her or her daughter; apparently now it’s time to engage in Jewish solidarity. What this really means is that Mom just realized there’s no way in Hell she will be able to get her apartment ready for Seder herself, so she managed to wangle us an invitation elsewhere.

This lack of planning is frequently aggravated when, after making multiple trips to the store, Mom changes her mind about what I’m supposed to bring, or what time I’m supposed to show up (she usually calls the day of the holiday, and decides she wants me there several hours earlier than originally planned, although we have yet to start with the actual substance of the event within two hours of her originally appointed time), or how many people are coming. Frequently I’ll set aside the entire day before the gathering to cook, but somehow I can never get the peace and quiet I need, because Mom feels the need to call me fifteen times during the day. (Her demands can verge on the insane: once, I was post-surgical and on crutches, and she still called as I was leaving the house to ask me to pick something else up at the store for her!) I love to cook, and in fact I look forward to holidays as a time when I can try out new recipes…I’m pretty good at timing kitchen operations so that I can manage to juggle everything I’ve planned to prepare and still make it to Mom’s house at the appointed time.

However, Mom, if you call me when I’m up to my elbows in half-chopped soup ingredients, cake batter, and the half-rolled components for stuffed grape leaves, all of which are dependent on very tight timing, I’m NOT going to drop everything and run out to the store for something you forgot to buy yourself. You live two blocks from the supermarket, but at least 20 minutes each way from me, so if you forgot to buy an ingredient for what you promised to cook, I’m not going to take a minimum of an hour out of my cooking day to run an ingredient over to your house. I planned ahead and shopped for my ingredients ahead of time, so no, I’m not eager to slog through the last-minute holiday crowd (she frequently pulls this stunt on Thanksgiving) to buy another bottle of wine because you’re not sure there’s enough. And no, I’m not going to drop everything and come to your house, on no notice, to do heavy cleaning because you’re the one who wanted to host Seder this year, but couldn’t find the time to clear the crap off your dining room table or organize your disastrous kitchen cabinets or wax the livingroom floor. You are an able-bodied and (usually) intelligent adult, and if you couldn’t have things ready in time, you should have realized that ahead of time and planned accordingly.

Yes, I’m very ambivalent about family holiday gatherings, especially for Jewish holidays. I am indeed proud of my heritage, but I’m not at all sure I believe in God, which makes me feel like a huge hypocrite when I recite the canned blather from the Haggadah. Mom, I hate how you always manage to get into a fight with my sister. I hate how you always manage to find something negative to say about the Middle East situation, and how in recent years it’s generally involved at least one dig about Muslim fundamentalism, which you don’t distinguish from Islam at large.

I never wanted to go to a Seder to begin with, and the more you behave this way, the more I grow to resent, and even to hate holidays, especially Jewish holidays. You’ve simply sucked all the joy out of them, and nothing I say seems to make you understand that. I’m seriously asking my boss to deny any request I might be forced to make for time off next week, if I weren’t convinced you’d sic the ACLU on her.

Eva, seriously, maybe your mum is throwing out some ‘subtle’ hints that it might be time for you and your sibs to take over the planning and hosting of the celebrations. I don’t know her age, but it IS a hefty responsibility and getting old makes it more difficult to co-ordinate all the stuff that needs to be done. Maybe she’d like to step back from some of that and hand-over the reins to her kids.

I don’t know what you can do about her rantings at the gatherings though…spike her wine with arsenic?? :smiley:

My mom is the perfect inverse: come Christmas time, she has to take care of everything. She won’t let anyone help, because they’ll do it wrong. Which would be great, except she complains about it the entire time.

Mom: God, I hate doing this holiday shit!

Me: Well, Uncle Jeff offered to do it at his place. Why don’t we just…

Mom: NO, I’ll do. First I have to put up the decorations, then I have to wrap the presents, then I have to start the dinner, then I* have to…"

Me: Geez, mom, do you want me to help out with any of that?

Mom: NO, I’ll do it. But this is the last time we do Christmas! Next year, I’m spending December in Mexico!"

Me: That’s what you said last year.

I used to feel bad about this, but now I figure she just enjoys the martydom. Perhaps not coincidentally, she’s the only practicing Christian in the entire family.

Well, Mom just turned 60, and she’s in good health and is really the only one with enough space at her place to host more than a couple of guests for an event like this. (We don’t have huge gatherings anyway, usually no more than I don’t think it’s age; she’s always behaved this way. And besides, my sister and I do more than half the cooking between the two of us anyway.

(As for the arsenic; isn’t it a cumulative poison? I don’t want to kill her, just knock her out temporarily. Maybe some Valium would do the trick.)

May I suggest the little white lie: “I’m sorry Mom, but I’ve met a nice Jewish boy and we’re doing Passover at his place.”?

Or, if you’re feeling sadistic, “I’m sorry mom, but I’ve met a muscley black Islamic sex god, and we’re spending Passover doing things they don’t teach you at Temple.”

Eva, is there some reason you have to go?

Robin

I say you beat the hell out of her! That’s what I did to my mom when she started talking about all that Christmas crap with me. Well, actually she beat the hell out of me but that’s just because she sucker punched me and kicked me in the nuts.

Damn, I just realized what a bitch my mom is.

Carry on! :wink:

Thanks for the suggestions, guys…unfortunately, I’m a lousy liar (plus, my mom knows about what’s going on with me to know I haven’t really been dating anyone in particular, and the only guy who might conceivably be believable in the “date” role is Catholic and will be out of the country next week anyway - smart guy!), and I do believe in keeping family harmony. I just wish family harmony weren’t so darn incompatible with my own sanity.

I am, however, sincerely considering declaring myself an official atheist simply in order not to have to deal with this stuff on Jewish holidays. That still eaves me with Tnanksgiving, which is a biggie, although at least it would resolve the immediate problem.

I do think I’m going to make a policy of having the receptionist put Mom’s calls in voice mail when I’m at work, though. At least I had enough sense not to divulge my direct line to her.

Change your citizenship. “Sorry, mom, I’m no longer going to any family holidays, as I am now an Swiss atheist.”

[sub]It’s fun giving useless advice.[/sub]

Hmm–you could torch your house. That’d give you a golden excuse to not go.

Or better yet, you could torch the ‘friends’ house! Of course then you’d run the risk of them arriving at your house so maybe you’d better torch it too–just to be safe. In fact, what the hell: I say torch your mom’s house and the houses of your geographically nearest relatives. It’s the only way to be sure.

Or you could beat the hell out of her. I’m still leaning towards that, actually.

Caught on preview: you want her to get Swiss citizenship Miller?! That’s crazy–everyone hates the Swiss. You might as well tell her tatoo the ‘stars-n-bars’ on her forhead and then go on an extended backpacking trip in Namibia or something. Sheesh. :wink:

Well, **Miller, **I must confess that I would have indeed enjoyed your original suggestion, if only it were true…I just have this little thing about lying.

Or maybe we could find a way to get Mom laid, and it would improve her disposition. Anyone know a nice single guy, 50-something and up, preferably a Sierra Club outdoorsy type with a beard and a strong sense of social consciousness?

Here’s one of Mom’s Passover gems from a few years back: my sister brought her boyfriend, who is black (not at all unprecedented; we usually invite guests, both friends and S.O.'s, and often they’re not Jewish). We usually pass the Haggadah around the table and take turns reading passages.

Well, that year, every time a specific passage mentioned slavery or bondage, sMom asked my sister’s boyfriend if he wanted to read it. My sister and I kept sneaking peeks at each other; we didn’t know whether to laugh or cry. Mom certainly isn’t a racist (on a conscious level, anyway), but she kept insisting afterwards, when we brought the matter to her attention, that she just asked him to read those passages because she thought they might hold special meaning for him…

Eva–

If you want, you can do Pesach at my mom’s place. She’d (I should say we’d– my sisters and I will be there too, and cooking is at least a somewhat cooperative undertaking) be happy to have you.

Yeah, but if you declare yourself atheist, you have to deal with even more guilt.

Trust me, it’s not worth it.

Robin

Shoot. Crappy editing.

I meant to say that you could spend the first two days of Pesach with us, or that you could come over for the seders.

I’d assume that you’ve got other things to do than hang out at my mom’s place for 8 days.

Damn, that sounds so familiar. If I didn’t know better, Miller, I would seriously be wondering if you were my brother.

I’m out of useless advice; I just wanted to say that “wangle” is my new favorite verb.

Miller, I hear ya. My mom was the same way. Now she will actually let her daughters-in-law help (they both are rather pushy people anyway).

Ooh! Ooh! Passover horror story!

I was seven (I remember this so vividly - part of my utter disgust for Passover as a whole). We drove down to MD, where Dad’s side of the family (which is the Jewish side) lives. Now, NinjaDad and his brother don’t get along very well. THey can usually be decent to each other at family get-togethers, though. Uncle had had a drink or two (NOT uncommon) before the seder. Getting an extra start on those 4 cups, I s’pose. Anyway - both he and my father had been under the impression that they’d be leading the Seder. THere was a screaming match between my 5’5 father and 6’7 uncle, and then a shoving match…My grandmother, the amazing woman she is, had the presence of mind to take pictures when the cops showed up to try and cool things off.

Anyway…I have absolutely no advice to give. I’m still (for the past what, four years?) trying to convince my parents that while I don’t believe in Judaism, they really haven’t done anything wrong to cause this to happen. They don’t accept it, and try to compensate by involving me as much as possible in various things, which often involves ‘forgetting’ I don’t read Hebrew… :rolleyes: I really think it’s a Jewish thing. Some sort of…creepy cultural thing, perhaps. Jewish Mommy Angst?