Is he admitting he and Anna had sex before they got married?
Oh good. He’s 'fessed up and asked for forgiveness. Now it’s Anna’s duty to forgive him and move on, and if she can’t do that then she’s a terrible Christian and will no doubt be shunned by her in laws, parents, friends, siblings and pretty much every acquaintance she’s ever made in her sheltered life. Meanwhile, Josh’s repentance will be lauded and he’ll be held up as an example of someone who “made mistakes” but came back to the path of righteousness and became an example to us all. All’s well that ends well.
That was the first thing I thought of when I read the list; I suspect that’ll eventually be a big deal as well… possibly a bigger deal than just the membership on the two sites.
I figure he might be able to spin those away as being similar/part of his internet porn addiction (if no actual affairs or hookups are proven), and he did it just to get better pictures/videos, but admitting to premarital sex is something altogether different to these types.
I’m thinking of sending Anna some scissors, sharp scissors.
Bingo. THAT’S what he’s addicted to. Or wants to be.
(My bolding)
Well…I’d never heard of it until a few days ago. Think I might need to get out more, or something.
Nope, it was a complete surprise. Um…I’ll bet.
Another vote of schadenfreude tempered by thoughts of his wife & kiddies. Yeesh it’s been a rough year for imploding celebs. Cosby, Josh, Jared, Josh again…I’m not gonna be able to handle it if Jimmy Carter turns out to be involved in rhino poaching or slave trading. Next thing you know there’ll be a bunch of NFL stars involved in unsavory off-field acts of violence and cruelty.
I’m here, sweetie. 
Trust me, the irony is so delicious in this that anemia has improved dramatically. I’m so sick of assholes that damage others’ lives with their beliefs, actually being worse than the “sinners” they rail against. And like everyone else, what his wife will have to endure because of all this is breaking my heart. I so feel for her and their children. Hell, for anyone that grows up in that patriarchal, oppressive lie. I wish this would be a wake-up call for folks of that ilk, but instead, I’m sure it will always be someone else’s fault for tempting the poor, unworldly Head of the Family. Ugh.
I’d never heard of Ashley Madison until I read this thread.
I just wish I was shocked. Poor Anna. She’s just utterly screwed regardless, and totally without an outlet - just has to smile and smile and forgive and keep sweet. Makes my blood burn.
I think he’s answering that one the way that gets him laid without having to be a bigamist. If he says no, then he’s stuck with being matched with just the good girls who don’t put out on the first date.
It wasn’t possible for Josh and Anna to have premarital sex. They were never alone together without a chaperone. I doubt Josh put a lot of thought into his OKCupid responses; he was just giving whatever response would get him laid faster.
Maybe he was looking for someone to carry his luggage.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_Alan_Rekers#.22Rent_boy.22_allegations
You mean other than the Dallas [del]Convicts[/del] Cowboys?
Threesoms.
Can you get credit for 'fessing up when you deny it until the proof is splashed over the Net?
Sorry if I missed it, but where is Huckabee in all this latest news?
No, that’s “Pornhub”.
Wonder if Josh has a membership there, too?
But their chaperones were his brothers and sisters. Come to think of it, I guess that would have been okay with Josh.
After his support of Josh’s pedophilia, he removed the Duggars from his site.