Regarding the votes on Macey. He could be scum certainly but I’ve played with him before and I don’t think he is. Having said that he always acts scummy to me so I’ve no problems with the votes on him and as cookies (I think) pointed out, if we end up lynching town on the first Day which is generally more likely than not, at least we’re lynching one who’s acting anti town.
Pleo/jsexton (I always want to add “blessed be he” there as that was the first game I ever read) seems to me like two good players with very different approaches to the game. Doesn’t tell me a damn thing about their allignments but I don’t see anything odd in their disagreements.
So anyway my vote’s pretty worthless I know but I’m not particularly suspicious of any of the current candidates with votes on them currently so meh.