I meant that sentence more as a response to Hawkeyeop’s vote analysis. I should have written ‘since we’ll have more information at dawn, we can do better analysis then’. I definitely wasn’t sure I would survive, but am glad I did do so on my first Mafia night :).
Onto the Night kills:
Thing Fish: unlikely to be the scum or a serial killer kill, since he had the most votes.
That leaves vigilante or ‘Night lynch’ as suggested. They could be the same if the vigilante can only/must kill the one with (the most?) votes.
Unvoting for now is an OK way to handle it, though if we get closer to lynch or lose it would give scum two kills (last minute vote + Night kill).
bufftabby: Either serial killer or vigilante. Not sure why pedescribe thinks she had a good reputation, she was even a bit suspicious in my book.
Pleonast: Most likely the scum kill, though might be SK. He got some votes early, but stayed cool and only had Thing fish’s vote at the end of the Night.