I was actually suggesting that RS was my “backup”. Or complement would be a better word since his investigation results would have complemented my own.
I already gave my opinion. I wanted to test the barn post because I didn’t know where it came from. There were a few possibilities I threw around. A second cop was one of them. Many o the games I’ve been in on Idle have had multiple cops that could search different things. I get alignment. That’s all I can tell you. My PM is right there for you. You weren’t on my radar at all Tex but this is really pinging me.
And also Red never confirmed he wrote the barn post. From my investigations I never would have been able to tell you whether Stan was an alpha wolf or not. The barn post wasn’t a typical cop report.
Just some Wine for you to think about regarding my play in this game:
I went after Diggit for wanting to out the masons
I was the first to go after Stan because of the barn post and other suspicions
I was the first to go after Cookies for her inconsistencies.
I have and keep bringing up that we need to be careful because we are close to MYLO.
If I’m scum I really suck as a teammate. Cookies wasn’t even on the radar that day before I brought her up. Everything I have done was to try and advance the town win.
And FTR I don’t necessarily believe Wombat’s Vig claim, which is why I didn’t add it to my scenario above. If she was the SK wouldn’t claiming Vig be an easy way out of her pickle today? She can explain where she’s been, without much question?
I’d be happy to address any concerns…what exactly are you concerned about?
My power is to “may investigate any player (by Night) to determine whether they have had any truck with a Demon. This power is infallible.” I can’t detect a Demon directly, which makes me think that the Demon is not a particular player who can be detected/killed/etc; I think the Demon is a mechanic in the game.
I don’t recall seeing anywhere that the Scum can’t kill the Demon; where are you getting this information? We have been told (via the Barn) that the Scum can’t kill the Serial Killer, but I don’t think there’s anything to suggest Serial Killer == Demon.
**wombat’s **PM is very clear if you actually read it.
“Once the Serial Killer is dead by any means and you have yourself killed at least one non-Town player of any stripe, your Nightly kills go from compulsory to optional.”
That says that **wombat **goes from a Compulsory Vig to an Optional Vig when **two **criteria are met:
The Serial Killer is dead
wombat killls a non-Town player.
**wombat **claims to have killed Cookies, fulfilling criterion #2, but the Serial Killer is still alive, so criterion #1 has not been met, therefore he’s still a Compulsory Vig.