I answered this already. The salient points:
(1) Their votes lack any reasoning whatsoever, while your vote is based on demonstrably faulty reasoning which you acknowledge but haven’t changed.
(2) You’re around and they’re not.
(3) I think you’re a better Mafia player than they are; therefore, when you do things that make no sense, it pings me more than when they do.
I think we can probably rule out b) and d), as **Astral **was not the apparent lynch candidate. The triple vote was intended either to kill Mosier, to save Gadarene, or to mess with the Town.
None of which says anything about the likely alignments of either Astral or Gadarene. We would need to know quite a bit more about the source of the three votes in order to determine that.
Let’s not forget that there were also ‘extra votes’ on Mosier and Gadarene yesterDay. The most likely explanation for those is that we have ‘double-voters’; unfortunately that leaves us with 11 suspects. And no way to tell their alignment even if we knew who they were anyway. So I suppose at this point this just gets filed in the “let’s remember this for later” pile.
MHaye,
Do you plan on placing a vote Today? I know you needed to get caught up, but we’re only about 45 minutes until End of Day, and it would be ‘unfortunate’ should you finish your review 5 minutes before Dusk and throw a wrench in the works at that point.
Ah, this is an entirely new spin on “Lynch the Loud”, coupled with the warmest, cuddliest snuggling I’ve heard in weeks.
I *like *it.
You asked me a question. I responded honestly to your question. Go hug an umbrella.
Seriously, Suburban: you asked why I’m not harping as much on PetW and fubbleskag’s votes of me. I did. You, however, have continued to vote me despite your initial premise for voting me (that I was lying about my correspondent) having been invalidated. I’m calling you a scum for that.
Where the fuck do you get Lynch the Loud from, and how in the fucking world am I snuggling you?
Jesus Christ.
Working on it. Need to find a post I read earlier.
That took a while, and I still need to read from 1101 again.
My votecount has Astral at 6 votes, Gadarene, Normal Phase, and Weedy at 2, Choie, Believerer, myself, Scathach and Suburban Plankton at 1.
Weedy’s vote remains on me, in case anyone’s wondering.
I’ll remind you that there is not only a triple voter, but also two separate secret-voting players. If they all gang up, they could push Gad or I (say) - anyone with two votes - into the lynch lead.
[color=blue]Vote Astral Rejection[/c].
That’s one part self-preservation, two parts suspicion from Yesterday, one part “who did that triple vote actually save, Gad or AR?” and one part Normal’s critique of that farewell post found in [post=14961971]post 1037[/post].
bh
Too used to posting on MtG forums where the [noparse][c][/c][/noparse] tags are used to link to card information. I usually catch it. Not this time.
I never once claimed that you were lying about your correspondent. I said you were lying about knowing **fubbleskag’s **Special Third Party Win Condition.
“Lynch the Loud” came from the fact that you’re voting for me, in part, because “you’re around and they’re not”.
And how can you not see your point (3) as snuggling?
I really wish we had something else to talk about Today, but it seems most of the Town are content to listen to us squabble…at least I’m enjoying myself with it; I hope you are too.
Pretty sure I have the same stupid three votes on me that I’ve had most of the day.
Can you even read?
I’m not voting you because you’re around and they’re not. I’m complaining to you about your vote being on me because you’re around and they’re not.
Stop misrepresenting what I’m saying, please…or at least take the sentences a little slower so you don’t miss their meaning.
I’m sure it’s 2.
What I have for you.Suburban Plankton : +813
[del]Visorslash : +824 -1,194[/del]
fubbleskag : +967
[del]Visorslash : +1,200 -1,203[/del]
[del]Mhaye : +1,281 -1,284[/del]Who have I missed?
First **choie **said it, and now you’ve repeated it: that the triple vote yesterday might have been meant to save Astral. How is that?
The ‘final’ vote count (before the triple-vote and the two hidden votes) had **Gadarene **as the lynch, one vote ahead of Astral.
The only way the triple vote could have been to save Astral would have been if the triple voter a) knew that there were two hidden votes, and b) thought they were both going to be placed on Astral. That would have put Astral in the lead by a single vote, and he would have required ‘rescuing’. Of course, neither of the hidden votes was placed on Astral, so he was never actually in any last-minute danger at all.
If I’m missing something, someone *please *point it out.
PetW is voting me, as far as I know.
My apologies. I did conflate “why do you think my vote on you is so bad” (which I did ask) with “why are you voting for me” (which I did not ask).
Although, I suspect the two are pretty heavily tied together, are they not?
In fact, what have I done that makes you think I’m Scum other than ‘not move my vote off of you’?
unvote
unvote
Vote Astral Rejection
Forgot to do this before I went to bed last night. I know people will hate the last minute vote change, but I’ve been asleep for the last 7 hours.
Let’s be paranoid.
Unvote
Vote Astral Rejection.
Just in case OGGH decides not to count my vote because it’s in a quote box.
Unvote Suburban Plankton
[color]Vote Weedy[/color]
This is not your village game so far.
Well, at least we came to a consensus.