Ahoy! I am dead and request spoilage.
All right, you old timers. Which of you veterans of the famous Batman game is behind this?
I’m dead and want spoils please 
Sent from my XT1526 using Tapatalk
Coming up. But you have to post in the spoiler discussion thread. No drive by spoiling. :dubious:
I’m tired of people getting spoiled and not sticking around to talk.
Are they spoiling your fun?
I am again looking for a sub for my game on Giraffe boards. If anyone is interested please pm me here or there.
What the heck. I’ll get spoiled too.
All caught up on this thread…please send me the spoiler info too.
I wonder why (it appears that) the Mafia have started using their daykills on Lutha. Could it be that they know something the rest of us don’t? Can’t really imagine how that might have come to pass, though…
My vote analysis system is sending up loud sirens and flashing red lights about the Day 2 Brewha voters. It expected to find 4 or 5 Scum among those 16 voters, but 13 of them have now flipped, and only two were Scum. The other three are bufftabby, Lakai, and Johnny Bravo,. Almost as suspicious are the D6 Inner Stickler voters; it expects to find 2 scum among those 7, 3 of whom are now dead Town, so predicts 2 Scum among TexCat, Johnny Bravo, raventhief and Lakai. I have slacked off a bit, but will catch up and post updated scum predictions after the Nightkill(s).
Still unspoiled here…but I definitely expect Johnny B to turn up Mafia.
I suspect the Mafia is afraid LUTHA is win stealing and is playing to eliminate that threat rather than increase the lead on the Werewolves.
What is the program you’re referring to?
Mafia wants to kill anyone who isn’t them, because any non-Mafia death brings them one step closer to victory. So in that sense, any kill is as good as any other.
In particular, they want to kill people who aren’t likely to die in some other way, like the lynch or the Wolves, because if a non-Mafioso can die from some other source instead of from them, that’s a bonus from their point of view. Neither the Wolves nor the Town has yet killed any Cultist, so that makes the Cultists reasonable targets.
There’s another reason, too, and it’s relatively straightforward and based on publicly-known information, but it’s maybe not quite as obvious as those two, and I’m spoiled, so I’ll refrain from pointing it out.
Actually, come to think of it, two other reasons, but I’m pretty sure the other one is a spoiler.
Reaction to your flip on the Wolf board:
There is speculation among the furry folk that your last minute unvote of Cookies was a gambit to draw attention to yourself and get NKed as a VT. Comment?
ToeRoosh and I should be getting royalties!
Exactly. Once the third-party are accepted as not a threat to Town, they are simply another brand of Masons from the Scum point of view. It shows why it’s best for Town that Third Parties claim early–and that means Towns should not eliminate players for being Third Parties, because it discourages early claims.
It was a consideration. It wasn’t the original intention of the plan, but since nobody else was going along with the unvoting, I didn’t see any harm in the unvote and thought it could be interpreted as a power townie protecting himself.
Captain Klutz makes a great point about about claiming and the relative position of the wolves and mafia. Claiming forces wolves and mafia to go after one another. It would be better to claim at night to give wolves a slight advantage. By making a small pool of claimed vanilla, wolves know where to hunt for mafia because that has to be their #1 priority. Since wolves make up part of that fakey-fake vanilla pool, it’s easier hunting for them. Town can pull out a win if they force mafia and wolves to aim for cross kills.
My current scum list:
Guiri and Johnny Bravo on the same team (probably mafia)
Biotop and SNFaulkner on the same team
Texcat
Thing Fish, I think your candidates of raventhief and bufftabby are viable as well.
The rotten thing is that I have almost no case on any of them other than gut feeling.
I agree that Biotop is probably Scum. Beyond that, I have no clue.
If Johnny Bravo flips mafia, the only case I will ever make is “Bob is scum for reasons. Vote Bob.”
So people are talking about how maybe the Patsy should claim vanilla, and they’re acting like the reasons for that would be obvious, but I’m not seeing it. Surely it can’t be because the Patsy is a miller, because e isn’t. Not any more, at least, with all of the Detectives dead. Or are people really just not thinking it through that far?
Agreed. Patsy is a one-person masonry. It’s a horrible plan for them to claim vanilla and Lightfoot’s couple posts there come off as scummy as heck.
But I appear to be wrong about SNF.