Okay… I think we can probably conclude there isn’t a Vigilante. However, in the event he does exist and he was blocked or something, he really should step forward now. Otherwise, I will not consider a Vigilante claim remotely credible.
Also, looking at the death toll, we only had one. Now, that means either they doubled up on Idle Thoughts (which doesn’t make much sense), or they targetted me, one of my protected targets, or Dio (whom I imagine was protected by the Witches.
Now, I’m going to have to give these results some further thought…
Sach, do you care to confirm the identity of MHaye and that Idle was honest?
Hmmm, well, perhaps I was mistaken about Idle after all. sach will have to tell us more. Nevertheless, considering who we COULD have lost, I’ll take it (at least we won’t be clogging up the thread with our arguments anymore ).
And I can’t see any reason whatsoever not to Vote CatInASuit
Okay, I didn’t see this when I posted. But based on this, this looks really good for Hockey Monkey.
Do you have any thoughts why you may not have info yet? Could this be related to a recruitment attempt? If he was self-jujuing, you’re supposed to get his role, right?
Intriguing… it looks like Idle’s tendency towards paranoia may have done him well: I’d recommend against cutting him up too much, sache. He might want that body back, tomorrow. When he does come back, unfortunately, I think he’s got an excellent chance at being the recruit.
In other news, it looks like Blaster’s scheme for protecting the rest of the town has worked out quite well: we went another day, scum didn’t get a permanent kill in, Hockey Monkey is now (relatively) confirmed, and might have another answer for us tomorrow.
For right now, however, I’m calling Cat out. This evening, at Dusk, on the main green of Cecilwich. You and I, last man standing, may the best sorcerer win. Vote: CatInASuit
I don’t think we can conclude that quite yet. Wolves could easily have opted to No Kill to avoid Hockey’s investigation, and the Vig could have killed Idle.
Why would the Vig have any good reason to kill **Idle ** over CatInASuit?
I can see how the Wolves may have gone for a no-kill option, but that still leaves a Vampire out there who is a much more likely Idle Thoughts killer. Do you not agree?
Nope, I can’t give you a logical reason. I’m not saying it’s likely, but it is possible. You’re probably right, but I prefer not to make assumptions, is all.
I think leaaping to the conclusion that Hockey needs to make excuses for herself is making a pretty big assumption, yourself. I think it’s pretty reasonable for Hockey to assume that, on a night with two kills, if she gets back a null anwser, it’s a vampire kill
If the killer is a Wolf or other than a Vampire, I get a name. Duh. Otherwise I get ____'s killer was a Vampire. I didn’t fuck up at all. Other than picking **Kat ** over **Nesta ** to investigate.
About Idle. Do we think he really was the witch doctor and is going to come back (having, presumably, enchanted himself) with the name of his killer? Or was the whole witch doctor thing a bluff? He did get his own powers very wrong at one point.
We have to make some reasoning steps, and that’s SO incredibly unlikely, and just dumb if he did that, that I’m not willing to believe it unless he gives me a good reason. I’ll be even more disbelieving if he waits until he’s cornered to tells u why he did that.
That said… I would like to take some time today to try to look at some other people. We’re going to start running out of confirmed townies soon, so it will be nice to have some information out there before they go. We can still end up with a lynch on Cat, but that doesn’t mean we should waste the Day.
I disagree. The only think Hockey told us Yesterday that we didn’t already know was that MHaye was a wolf. Which, she could have known by, you know, being a wolf. She hasn’t told us anything Today that’s verifiable, either. I’m still suspicious.
).