What all the storm und drang on this board stems from is that many of the board’s posters want this place to be an echo chamber. They absolutely cannot stand dissent and invariably seek to get people moderated and/or banned not for breaking any rules but simply for having different beliefs than they do. And since for the most part no rules are being broken by the opposition, they’ll land on the only ambiguous one allowed and attempt to portray their opponents as being “jerks.” And many of them truly believe it. They simply cannot imagine any way for anyone
What you are suggesting is just another way of achieving this. Sure, your plan still allows for dissent, but it also attempts to shuttle it aside where hardly anyone is exposed to it so everyone else can go merrily on their way promoting whatever ideas or viewpoints they want without being challenged on them.
The board’s management, to its credit, seeks to have a board where dissenting ideas and points of view can be heard. It sees value in having dissenting viewpoints on the board and consciously acts so as not to have this place turn into an echo chamber.
But because so many of the board’s posters are so absolutely convinced of the moral superiority of their views and their beliefs and the intensity with which they hold them, they are utterly incapable of tolerating disagreement and automatically jump the conclusion that anyone who opposes them is, by that very fact, assholes. So they pester the mods and screech make demands for things like topic bans, thread bans or outright banning for those they’ve been unsuccessful at driving away through pile-ons, insults and mockery.
There is only one way that only one side can be heard from, and that is through dictatorship. The country’s founders recognized that people are not free if their speech is proscribed so that only one point of view is allowed. It’s not for nothing that communist dictatorships, which I hope we can agree are liberal at their base, are notorious for suppressing free speech and also punitive toward those who express disagreement with the party line.
Everywhere in this country we see efforts by people on the left to quash ideas they disagree with and prevent the proponents of them from being heard
I’ve always admired the fact that the board’s administration and its moderators have been willing to put up with the amount of whinging they have to endure in order to keep this place from becoming the full-on left-wing echo chamber that so many of its members so strongly desire it to be.
None of the board’s conservative posters behave in any way like the majority of its liberal posters. We don’t hurl expletives and vulgar insults at our opponents at anything approaching the way the board’s liberal posters do with us. We don’t accuse them of being mean, uncaring, willfully evil or any other insults intended to portray them as being deliberate assholes to their fellow man.
In short, the posters here who constantly come in for abuse and accusations of an endless variety of assholism are not the ones who are engaging in it.
I hope the board will continue to allow those of us who disagree with the prevailing political sentiments here to continue to have a voice. I also hope that as the board attempts to grow that it will seek and welcome dissenting posters to liven the place up even more and to offer an even greater sense of perspective as to how the other side thinks.
I believe this would become a terribly boring place should it eventually become a board where liberals congregate to preach to the choir, virtue signal and slap each other on the back over what wonderful and superior people they are. This board’s liberal members live in enough of a bubble as it is, given the shock, surprise, horror and disbelief evident in their reaction to the election of Donald Trump. They are clearly out of step with a very large percentage of American citizens and it would behoove them to try to learn how the other side thinks, rather than seeking to drive them away to become even more insulated and ignorant of the outside world.
Time and time again we hear on this board about how Trump’s voters are racists, misogynists, Nazis, etc., but invariably when one of the board’s posters comment about family or personal acquaintances who support Donald Trump, those people somehow never fit the liberal image of Trump supporters. One would think that eventually it would begin to sink in that Trump’s voters are not the evil beings everyone here is so utterly convinced they are, and that to a great degree they’re just normal everyday people going about their lives the way everyone else does, taking their kids to school or soccer practice, buying groceries, mowing their lawns and trying to pay the bills. Not many of the board’s posters know this now, but should the place ever become the echo chamber so many desire they’ll never even be able to imagine it.