In an odd inversion, if there are two evil left, I would dismiss any possibility of MHaye being Evil. While I give him no credit for the Turn 3 vote (because I think there are 4 Evil in the Game), if there were 5 Evil, then MHaye could easily have won the game by voting for me. So I accept that MHaye could be Evil in the 4 Evil case, but reject that MHaye could be evil in the 5 Evil case.
All right, let me run this alternative Nuclear Option by you all:
We vote to lynch sinjin, MHaye and Boozahol. (At least one of them must be Good and will need to go along with the plan). sach, Zsofia and I mirror one of them each, like we did with Chucara and Darth, so there can be no last minute voting shenanigans. Any items they have go to the Hoard.
I die from the Curse, so any items I might have (I don’t have any) go to the Hoard.
sach drops his item(s) into the Hoard. As a backup, Zsofia bashes him.
End result should be sach and Zsofia alive. Zsofia wins as Chaotic Good, Lawful Good wins.
Of course, this plan assumes that sach is Good and Zsofia plays along. It’s not foolproof, but it’s close, and does not rely on Evil to participate. What do you think?
I’d be OK with your plan, if it didn’t run the risk of losing to an Evil Sach - something I have not actually ruled out. (It’s as unlikely as all get-out, but trust the game to it? Are you that confident?
I’d be prepared to leave Zsofia alive, but not Zsofia and Sach.
Eh. I don’t hate it. And I see what you are trying to set up.
Possible problems: I have someone dropping in this afternoon. I can not guarantee my presence at 3PM today.
Also, are you sure you want me to drop instead of cure?
It’s your life so I’ll do what you say. I’m sure Pleonast will love my changing my action again. 
I’m fine with any plan that involves sinjin dying. Hell, I’d support a sinjin/sachertorte dual lynch at this point.
On Items.
I have two, one of which is the now-discharged Orb of Healing. As you might guess, it’s the other item that has caused me hesitation over agreeing to put them in the Hoard.
I started the game with Bracers of Defence.
By my reckoning, they’ve faced two or three attacks already. One was when I sprung Boozy’s traps to use the Orb on him. The other was DarkCookies’ summoning of the Great Wind. I don’t know whether the Wind made one attack on me, or one for each item. Whichever it is, there’s a significant chance that the item will no longer protect me. I have no way of finding out, either
Consequently, I am willing to put them into the Hoard, to reassure Lawful types that I am no threat to them (even though I am, myself, Lawful. I mean, why believe me?)
We have an hour and a half to get our shit together. Less, since MHaye is going out, like right now.
I know, and this is partially my fault for not getting my act together sooner. I’m sorry about that, but I didn’t have time to do the kind of analysis needed to get my head straight until recently.
I don’t think we’re going to be able to do my plan or** sach’s** nuclear option at this point. Not enough time to coordinate. So what’s the fallback? I don’t know. I’m not convinced that sinjin is Evil.
Unvote Sinjin
I clear my vote so that if you decide on the nuclear option, you won’t have to distort actions to deal with my vote.
Whatever befalls, I consider Sinjin the most likely to be Evil, then Boozy, then Sach. ShadowFacts is very unlikely to be Evil, and Zsofia not at all.
See you either next turn, or in the aftermath.
The nuclear option is off the table.
Vote for who you want dead.
unvote ShadowFacts
unvote Squid
unvote MHaye
fuckin’ A, I cannot figure out the best plan right now.
For now:
vote MHaye
Shadowfacts, you should check out whichever of MHaye or sinjin ends up living. If you happen to live, then knowing if one of them has the Helm or not will be useful information.
Of course, if you live, I will probably want to kill you. But if you are Good, you know that finding out the information is critical.
I don’t think we have enough time to ensure everybody can do it.
Sorry, I didn’t see that we already kind of decided that. I am torn of a muchness on who to vote for, so I guess I’ll go with my uncertain gut.
vote sinjin
For the record, since we’ve bounced back and forth.
My Turn Action for Turn Five is to drop all items (Sword of Dancing) into the Hoard.
Already done.
And you should drop your item - don’t try to cure me.
Heh. 
Wait, I thought I was bashing you?
I think ShadowFacts wants us to do both.
Personally, I think you should do something else. If I fail to drop my item, I think you all would be justified in killing me (if the game doesn’t end this Turn). But if you can’t think of anything else to do, then forcing me or MHaye (if he lives, which it looks like he will) to drop is as good an action as any, I guess.
Whatever. It’s up to you Zsofia. Not that you even care if I’m Lawful or Chaotic. Or MHaye for that matter.
Never mind. I changed my action.
OK, well, after Zsofia’s vote, it looks like there is no way that sinjin is not going to die. Fine - I think we have a lynch to burn. The question I am asking myself is: is it better to lynch just sinjin or sinjin and MHaye both?
Situation now:
ShadowFacts (Cursed)
sachertorte
sinjin
Zsofia
MHaye
Boozahol
If we lynch just sinjin and the game is not over:
sachertorte
Zsofia (presumably Cursed - that’s what I’d do)
MHaye
Boozahol
In this scenario, whether sinjin comes up Good or Evil, there is one Evil left or the game would be over. I strongly think that sach and Zsofia are Town, so they will have to decide between MHaye and Boozahol.
If we lynch both sinjin and MHaye the game is not over:
sachertorte
Zsofia (presumably Cursed - that’s what I’d do)
Boozahol
In this scenario, at least one of MHaye or sinjin will come up Good, but however that shakes out, there is one Evil left or the game would be over. The Evil player is obviously Boozahol - game over.
So, assuming that sach and Zsofia are Town - and I strongly believe that - it is better to lynch both MHaye and sinjin. I am in a bit of a hurry here, but I think I got it right. Any critique?