On the Krazy Waggon we had
Drainbead
Sanagamn
Malahoth (S)
IdleThoughts
LightFoot
ScubaBen
PrecambrianMollusc
So Scuaben, Lightfoot and Gnarlycharlie started the roll against Innerstickler
Both Scubaben and Lightfoot were on the Krazy list adding numbers at the upper end of the vote count.
gnarlyCharlie was accused of scum by SilverJan. Obviosuly GC is backed up by texcat with the mason claim.
SilverJan was pushing the vote on IS up to 6 when the count on BM was 8 votes. Which doenst look good, however SilverJan was attacked and voted for by Blastermaster, who was scum.
I am pointing a big finger of suspicon at lightfoot and Scba for voting pattern reasons.
GnarlyCharlie for voting position and being accused of being a wolf.
texcat is still suspicious to me for fishing for roles and asking who alse investigated GnarlyCharlie as SilverJan said it wasn’t her result.
On the Krazy Waggon we had
Drainbead
Sanagamn
Malahoth (S)
IdleThoughts
LightFoot
ScubaBen
PrecambrianMollusc
So Scuaben, Lightfoot and Gnarlycharlie started the roll against Innerstickler
Both Scubaben and Lightfoot were on the Krazy list adding numbers at the upper end of the vote count.
gnarlyCharlie was accused of scum by SilverJan. Obviosuly GC is backed up by texcat with the mason claim.
SilverJan was pushing the vote on IS up to 6 when the count on BM was 8 votes. Which doenst look good, however SilverJan was attacked and voted for by Blastermaster, who was scum.
I am pointing a big finger of suspicon at lightfoot and Scba for voting pattern reasons.
GnarlyCharlie for voting position and being accused of being a wolf.
texcat is still suspicious to me for fishing for roles and asking who alse investigated GnarlyCharlie as SilverJan said it wasn’t her result.
When I voted Inner, I was only the second vote on em (NAF having already moved onto Blaster). The wagon on Inner really got rolling with either LightFoot at 2403 or gnarlycharlie at 2446. Note that there are 7 votes on Inner (one withdrawn) in the range of less than 90 posts. Also note that both of our claimed masons had their final votes on Inner.
The late votes on Blaster were pwnsall and peeker, pushing Blaster over the top after the Inner wagon worked up steam. But we know peeker to be Town. So the possible Scum playing for Townie cred would be pwnsall.
The votes in a short range were Dancecat, Normal, Episkey, Drain Bead, Idle, and NAF (posts 2258 through 2347, also just under 90 posts). I consider that the bulk of the wagon. There seems to me a good chance of Scum playing for Townie cred in that group too. But we know Dancecat to be Town.
So it seems to me that the Scum hiding in the lynch would be in the group: pwnsall, Normal, Episkey, Drain Bead, Idle, and NAF. And there may be room for suspicion in the bandwagon on Inner. But that is confused by Blaster’s defensive vote. Still, there could be Scum in the group: LightFoot, Scathach, Jan, brewha, lilflower. (I omit gnarly as claimed mason.)
Thoughts on this, Astral and all?
AOP @ PCM: I contest your claim that I started the bandwagon on Inner. The wagon got going well after (post-wise) I had voted for em.
But I do agree with your claim about LightFoot’s voting pattern. vote LightFoot
Also good point about Blaster attacking Jan. This is a point in Jan’s favor.
You gotta look back further there, Idle. Blaster went from 1 or 2 votes to 8 in the course of a couple of hours. That action is the one that I thought was there to save someone else. I wasn’t the only one to notice it either.
Honestly? Because I wasn’t completely convinced that IS was scum. But, PCM’s post there really illustrates the BlaM wagon. He had two votes, and the IS gets one, then BlaM gets 6 over the course of the next 100 posts.
That made it pretty obvious to me that BlaM was not scum. I believed that IS could plausibly be scum and putting my vote anywhere else would make absolutely no difference. Voting IS didn’t almost save BlaM, but thankfully, there’s smarter players than me and they kept that from happening.
@Scuba_Ben, I thought we had this sorted out some time OK. You can PM mod, but I am pretty sure that you have to submit two targets, if you send in your night action before nightfall. The second is just a precaution in case your first target dies. Any message you receive should have been on the first target.
I’m not very happy with the results this morning, but am happy to still be here! I was the first to vote for Inner, not to save Blaster, but because I thought Inner was scummy. NAF was the second voter and he went back and forth and ended on Blaster. I need to go look at the tail end of the voting yesterday.
No, that was Jan. She sent in her N1 target before Dusk, and was asked for a backup target. On the other hand, I was explicitly asked for two targets for my N2 action – no discussion of backup targets. I have not been asked for this for my action on N3, nor was I asked for it for N1.
I also think I can help someone confirm that someone else is town.
Last night I was told I had a role (x) and an alignment (town).
However that role as described is not consistent with the results I received the night before. In addition I also recieved a result last nigh that was consistent with the prior nights result. So it appears I was told someone elses role and alignment, but it had my name at the begining.
That’s what I know. the rest below is supposition.
My theory is
There is a role out there that tells the target their alignment and power.(person I)
There is a person out there who has role X and is town (Person T)
It also appears that there is a redirector who can direct effects targeted at one player toanother (Person R)
And there is me (person P)
Person I targeted T, the redirector ® targeted T and me §. so I recieve Ts role and alignment courtesy of Is role and Rs redirection
So to whoever the redirector is who targeted me and someone else, that someonelse is Town.
I am not worried that the redirector is a scum redirector because the above doesn’t tell them anything they didnt know, they already knew that T was town. With the exception that they may not have known if T was town or a 3rd party , if we have any of those.
I also think it unlikely that scum would be targeting me overnight, I may be paranoid but I suspect a couple of people and scum will be trying for an easy lynch of me today.
they are independent events, meaning after hammering the wolf over villager we are probably each like 90/10 w/v, and now that he died I’m still 90/10 w/v
obviously i know i’m 100% villager, and thinking that casting the deciding vote on a wolf is anything but villagery is bizarre
Welp, looks like peeker was Town. Sorry for trying to kill you, buddy. Still not sure what got in your bonnet about me, but rest in peace.
Interesting about Blaster Master’s role: send someone false alignment information. Not sure why he chose me, but I guess it doesn’t matter. I’d argue that it gives me some Town cred, since it would be an odd scum-scum play for Night one: I had gotten more votes and attention than him at that point, so if I’m lynched and flip scum, people will look askance at the guy I cleared. This argument relies heavily on “scum wouldn’t do that” though, which some people automatically reject so take it for what it’s worth.
Another interesting bit of info: I was sent another message last Night, this time letting me know that pwnsall is Town. Again, this message was unrelated to the results of my Night action. No idea if it’s true, of course.