I’m afraid I don’t have a huge amount to add at the moment. I need to go back over the events of the last day at lynch. I want to look at lilflower too - why would she back off creating a tie if she didn’t think BlaM was scum?
Sent from my GT-I9100 using Tapatalk
You said you didn’t like the BlaM lynch, but unvoted when you realised you had a 50/50 chance of saving him? (i.e. in a tie, correct me if I’m wrong, the lynch is chosen randomly between the two candidates) You specifically said you didn’t like the case against BlaM, but then deliberately let him be lynched?
** This is the stuff we know.**
[spoiler]
Gadarene 161 (Host)
Krayz 35 (Town, Bureaucrat) Lynch
Mahaloth 5 (Wolf, Tracker) Vigilante
GuiriEnEspaña 11 (Town, Vigilante) Murder
Silman 4 (Town, Journalist) Murder
Blaster Master 67 (Wolf, Propagandist) Lynch
Dancecat 114 (Town, Town Crier) Murder
Inner Stickler 90 (Town, Beat Cop) Vigilante
peekercpa 318 (Town, Lightning Rod) Murder[/spoiler]
This is just my personal current opinion.
[spoiler]
[ul]
[li]Blue- Strong lean townie or Town (Askthepizzaguy, Sacher/DonkX4, Septimus, NAF, Normal, Episkey[/li][li]Teal- Lean townie. (Drain Bead, Idle Thoughts, TexCat, gnarlycharlie, Silver Jan, Scuba_Ben, Weedy/Hirka, TimeLady/pwnsall, SisterCoyote/JD)[/li]
[li]Black- No bet. (crackedquads, lilflower, Suburban Plankton, Zeriel, special ed, Giraffe, bufftabby, Scathach, Mykbot, sangaman/Meeko, [/li]
[li]Maroon- Lean scummy. (Brewha, Lightfoot, Astral Rejection)[/li]
[li]Red- Strong lean scummy or Scum (Only the dead scums so far)[/li]
[/ul]
Gadarene 161 (Host)
Krayz 35 (Town, Bureaucrat) Lynch
Mahaloth 5 (Wolf, Tracker) Vigilante
GuiriEnEspaña 11 (Town, Vigilante) Murder
Silman 4 (Town, Journalist) Murder
Blaster Master 67 (Wolf, Propagandist) Lynch
Dancecat 114 (Town, Town Crier) Murder
Inner Stickler 90 (Town, Beat Cop) Vigilante
peekercpa 318 (Town, Lightning Rod) Murder[/spoiler]
Lightfoot and Normal Phase found it.
I made the case on Blaster and supported the case on Inner but voted for Blaster because it looked like no one was going to join me in my support for Inner. I thought the case presented on Inner was stronger.
Ah, thank you. 
There is a whole heck of a lot in this thread and I’m already sort of a sloppy note taker. I’m going to miss relevant things, which is one of the many reasons I need folks going behind me and picking up all the things I drop and painting over the spots I miss.
Thanks again Weedy.
I just don’t see Scuba as a top candidate at the moment unless I’m missing something.
I see I’m pretty much alone on Astral and Brewha. Okay lets hope I’m wrong.
LOL, of course I have nothing better to do than run around after you. It must be the mum in me.
MODERATOR ANNOUNCEMENT
DuckburgDK will be subbing in to replace MykBot. Say hi to Duck!
Not to mention it could potentially out Cops. This actually happened when someone came up with the idea of posting “trust lists” in one of the first Mafia games on this board. The Scum went through the lists and found the ones that were the most accurate and used their NK to take out the Cop on either the first or second night after the list idea was proposed.
Define bad. I made two cases (technically I was the first to bring up Ben on Day One, that were at least logically consistent, albeit wrong. Alas, Townies make wrong cases all the time. At least I realized it, and have soft-cleared Ben as a result. I voted Scum on Day Two. That vote was not supported by much other than a hunch, but I can’t exactly argue that the results are bad.
And toDay, I made the first case against Scathach. Three Days, and all three times I was either the first or second vote on someone. The time I was the second vote, I had been the one to begin the case the day before, and essentially cuddled a known Scum in doing so. If I’m Scum, I’m being exceptionally bold. That’s why I asked Ben what he thought of me after Day 2. I figured that he, of all people, could see that I was likely Town based on the events of that Day. I also thought (incorrectly, as it seems now) that he realized I targeted him N1 and thought I might be responsible for doubling his powers–hence why he made sure to emphasize this to me. I was trying hard to be subtle about that, but was concerned I played my hand too obviously there and might be a potential NK target. Turns out it wasn’t me, it was Ed (I will take that at face value, because lying to out the real doubler will get him lynched the second it’s found out). But I digress. An examination of my record will show nothing bad. Wrong sometimes, sure, but not bad.
Where’s charlie, anyway?
Hi Duck!
Can someone real quick, or at your own speed, tell me the following:
Who’s dead - and their alignment
The best case made itt.
and ofc - when is lynch?
Day ends on Saturday at 12 pm EDT.
Hi Duck!
Cos I’m lazy, I’ll just suggest you click the Day and Night links in Gad’s sig to get the kills.
With the schools year just starting, and being swamped with work as I’ve taken over as department chair, I’m still in skimming mode.
Scuba Ben has slid slightly from neutral to possible Town based on revealing that his action had been doubled. I’m not certain Scum would have easily given up this information in the game thread. This is not solid clad evidence, but it’s enough for me to compensate for my earlier suspicion.
Where do I set up my account, so I can see signatures?
Found it - by clicking Gad’s name and his public profile.
So I believe we’re running pretty good.
You could link me to the best case itt 