Mystery Mafia -- Game Thread

[special_ed]

@bufftabby

I also targeted buff Night Two. The only message I received was IRT the warm glow.

and you didn’t get 2 actions on night 3?

On a related note, NAF hasn’t described how his power might work getting 2 powers and yet only being able to act once toNight.

[Weedy]

I wanted to put Idle on ignore.

Sorry Idle Thoughts is a moderator/admin and you are not allowed to ignore him or her.

Can you please stop? At least with the giant text.

@Episkey

I mean, what?

1. It’s blatantly impossible Astral peeked me scum because, well, IM NOT SCUM.

2. Astral blatantly says “I find giraffe more scummy than episkey”, yet you think he peeked me wolf or something?

If he peeked you wolf (well, not him but someone else and he got the result) then it was on Night 2.

3. “For my earlier case + the message ATPG got” was the reasoning for voting me. The case itself isn’t even a case on me being scum, it’s a review of my posts (again ended by “I find giraffe more scummy than episkey” which is never, ever ,ever ,in the history of ever said if I’m a peeked wolf - which again is impossible).

This is exactly why I think he got a peek of you. The case wasn’t even strong enough to vote you Day 2, but Day 3 he votes you as soon as he gets the chance.

I don’t think he left a breadcrumb for us to decipher. I think he had a scum result, and was looking for an excuse to vote it.

The main reason I have doubts about that is that he also voted gnarly on Day 2, for Silver Jan’s message. Maybe he just wanted to work out if the messages were reliable. And because you seemed kinda townie, working stuff out and all. Though you don’t get any credit for trying to work out your own role.

You harping on the weakness of his Day 2 case is not clearing for you at all. I know it was weak. So why did he vote you for it?

Doesn’t really matter for today, since Idle is getting lynched today anyway.

@pwnsall

weedy when you said you got an investigation of texcat n1 did you also say that was your target n1

She was not my target on N1 or any night.

[Scuba_Ben]

@LightFoot

Interesting ploy by ** Idle **
My way of thinking it can’t be true. That would essentialy break the game wouldn’t it?

Yes, it’s a very interesting ploy. There is, of course, only one way to test it.

My vote stands. That aside, Idle I will accept you as a Traitor who has decided to throw his Scummy lot in with the Town.

[Idle_Thoughts]

@Weedy

I wanted to put Idle on ignore.
Can you please stop? At least with the giant text.

Hahahahaha. You obviously have never played with me before.

Cite, Cite (Important Information to remember)

[LightFoot]

@Suburban_Plankton

Actually, you’re partially right (soft of, but not really). I forgot about **brewha **being a Vig.

So last Night we should have had 6 deaths:

Mod Kill
Pizza poison kill
brewha Vig kill
LightFoot kill
Mason kill
Scum kill

The first two are accounted for.
The Masons are not responsible for Texcat or gnarlycharlie, so that leaves Astral, or they were blocked.
Lightfoot targeted gnarly, and I was informed that she was redirected on Night2, so I think I would have been informed if she was blocked Night 3. I wasn’t, therefore she is responsible for gnarly’s death.
That leaves brewha and the ‘normal’ Scum kill, and only one more dead person, that being TexCat. So I’m guessing that someone on the Scum team was blocked last Night. If not, both of their kills went through and the Mason kill was blocked.

In any case, brewha is gone, the Masons are gone, and Pizza is gone, so there should be only 2 deaths Tonight (the Scum kill, and LightFoot).
And yes, I’m assuming that LightFoot has not been the ‘designated killer’ for the Wolves the past 3 Nights.

Underlining Mine
You targeted me Night 2. You would not have had any result N3 because you can’t target the same person twice.

[Idle_Thoughts]

@Scuba_Ben

Yes, it’s a very interesting ploy. There is, of course, only one way to test it.

My vote stands. That aside, Idle I will accept you as a Traitor who has decided to throw his Scummy lot in with the Town.

Woohoo…that much closer to a with-Town victory! Assuming that it even works that way, that is (everyone saying they accept me).

[Weedy]

@LightFoot

Interesting ploy by ** Idle **
My way of thinking it can’t be true. That would essentialy break the game wouldn’t it?

It is definitely not true. It doesn’t even make sense. Idle is getting carried away with his joking around. He is dead anyway, so there is nothing too silly or desperate for him to say right now.

If it makes anyone feel better, they can vote to ‘let Idle Thoughts be town’, as long as they also vote for him to be lynched.

Idle Thoughts

[Idle_Thoughts]

@Weedy

Can you please stop? At least with the giant text.

Here’s another for ya.

Near the end of the page:
“The ensuing debate saw Idle Thoughts resort to posting in Large Font (deliberately recalling his performance in the Pirates game),…”

So it’s sort of like “my thing” and, at this point, expected of me at least once in every game. : p Well, I’ve always had it come out at least once in every game (and even some games I wasn’t in), so I figured it needed a cameo here.

Sorry for the annoyance. You’ll probably see it once or twice in future games with me, though, if you play.

[Idle_Thoughts]

@Weedy

It is definitely not true. It doesn’t even make sense. Idle is getting carried away with his joking around. He is dead anyway, so there is nothing too silly or desperate for him to say right now.

If it makes anyone feel better, they can vote to ‘let Idle Thoughts be town’, as long as they also vote for him to be lynched.

Idle Thoughts

Who says I’ve been joking around with anything I’ve said so far?

Unvote NAF
Vote Weedy

[NAF1138]

can we have a hammer for consensus lynches?

vote idle

[Suburban_Plankton]

@LightFoot

Underlining Mine
You targeted me Night 2. You would not have had any result N3 because you can’t target the same person twice.

:smack:

That’s what I get for trying to work and play mafia at the same time. Of course I would not have been told anything about your Night 3 actions.

That being said, it’s doubtful that you were blocked, since you admit to targeting gnarly, and he turned up dead just like all of the other people you’ve touched.
I think it’s clear that you are either a compulsive Vig, or a compulsive Serial Killer. As such, it’s questionable whether the Town can let you live until end-game, though I don’t think there’s any great urgency to kill you at this point.

[Idle_Thoughts]

@NAF1138

can we have a hammer for consensus lynches?

vote idle

Vote: No Hammer

[Suburban_Plankton]

@NAF1138

can we have a hammer for consensus lynches?

vote idle

I think there’s still plenty to discuss Today apart from the lynch. I see no need for a hammer at this stage.

[LightFoot]

** SuburbanP**
Your knowledge of my redirection D2 fits nicely me being a killer.

Your comment about ** gnarlie’s ** death can’t be true because you did not target me N3 (although I could still be a killer anyway)

Does Scum want me to look like a Killer to hide some of their kills?

I’d be any easy lynch since I keep killing Town?

Is there something else afoot here?

[Idle_Thoughts]

And I bet nobody finds it suspicious NAF would try to get an early end of Day.

I’m telling ya, going to be kicking yourselves at the end when you find out I served up the rest of the scum for you, full names and all.

[Weedy]

unvote Idle Thoughts

Hammer?? I am not done with today yet even if Idle is self-admitted scum.

vote NAF1138

[Giraffe]

@Idle_Thoughts

See, here’s my real role:

Seriously now. Or may Mod strike me dead.
100 percent truth or I’ll never play another game of mafia in my life.

Don’t the game rules require a modkill if you post your real role PM? So telling the truth or lying, you’re dead either way, right?

[Idle_Thoughts]

@LightFoot

Your comment about ** gnarlie’s ** death can’t be true …

Lynch All Liars, FTW!

[LightFoot]

@Suburban_Plankton

I think there’s still plenty to discuss Today apart from the lynch. I see no need for a hammer at this stage.

Also I recall it mentioned that since most everyone is going to vote Inner We should be making other cases and maybe giving a second choice vote for the record?

[Idle_Thoughts]

@Weedy

unvote Idle Thoughts

Hammer?? I am not done with today yet even if Idle is self-admitted scum.

vote NAF1138

This is good. I can get on board with this.

Unvote Weedy
Vote NAF

@Giraffe

Don’t the game rules require a modkill if you post your real role PM? So telling the truth or lying, you’re dead either way, right?

Damn, I forgot about that.
Yep, dead either way.

So you should so vote for someone else toDay.