I’ve spent some time reviewing the Night Kills, hoping they might tell us something. I’m not sure if they have or not, but here’s what I came up with:
What we know
Night 1
Mahaloth was shot
Guiri was killed (no color)
Silman was killed (no color)
Night 2
Dancecat was shot (by “multiple people”)
Inner Stickler was shot (with Guiri’s gun)
peeker was killed (no color)
Night 3
gnarlycharlie was shot
Astral Rejection was shot
TexCat was killed (no color)
brewha was killed (no color)
How it might have happened
Night 1:
Mahaloth was probably shot by Guiri. (He was also poisoned, but we know that didn’t kill him.)
Guiri was either the Scum kill, or was brewha’s Vig kill
Silman was tareted by LightFoot
Night 2:
Dancecat was shot by “multiple people”. We’ve been assuming that was the Scum kill. I don’t think so. I think that was the Mason’s kill.
Inner Stickler was shot “with Guiri’s gun”. This suggests a backup Vig?
peeker was LightFoot’s target, after she was redirected.
Night 3:
brewha was poisoned by Askthepizzaguy, so that likely explains his death
Astral must have been the Mason’s target, unless they were blocked. There is no mention of a “group” killing Astral, so it may be that the Mason kill did not go through.
gnarlycharlie was LightFoot’s target. The first two Nights, LightFoot’s target was killed with no color, but tonight he was shot. Could that mean that someone else targeted him as well?
I think maybe so. The PMs shown in the death reveals for Tex and gnarly said “you search for your fellow mason” (singular). This implies that there were to and only two Masons, and that they were both Town. The Scum would have known that there were no Scum Masons, so best case scenario for them was that we had two Confirmed Town, and worst case was that there might be additional Masons waiting to be found. Therefore it would have been very much in the Scum’s best interest to get rid of the Masonry last Night. And I think that’s what they did. brewha targeted gnarlycharlie, and TexCat was the regular Scum kill.
What I think it all means
Night 1:
Mahaloth was shot by Guiri
Guiri was killed by Scum (Nightly kill)
Silman was killed by LightFoot
brewha was either blocked, or his target was protected
Night 2:
Dancecat was shot by the Masons
Inner Stickler was shot by brewha
peeker was killed by LightFoot
Night 3:
gnarlycharlie was shot by brewha, and was also targeted by LightFoot
TexCat was killed by Scum (Nightly kill)
Astral Rejection was killed by the Masons
brewha was poisoned by Askthepizzaguy
The biggest problem with the above is the color surrounding Inner Stickler’s death on Night 2. It is mentioned that “someone found Guiri’s gun and decided to put it to use”. That doesn’t sound like brewha, who should have had his own gun. Another issue is that Dancecat’s death was attributed to “multiple people”, whereas there is no such mention regarding Astral’s death, both of which I have assigned to the Masons. These items either are or are not a big problem depending on how significant the detail in the color is.
If I am correct, what this tells us is that the only evident killing power left in the game besides the Nightly Scum kill is LightFoot, so the body count should drop from this point on. Of course, it’s possible that there is another killer out there, and the roleblocker(s) and doctor(s) that we appear to have managed to successfully prevent at least one kill each Night. I think that’s somewhat unlikely, but I can’t be certain.
If I am incorrect, then there is at least one unknown killing role needed, to explain Inner Stickler’s death.
So there you go. I’m absolutely certain there exist not even the tiniest flaws in my logic or reasoning, so there’s no point in even thinking about trying to find them.
Unless you feel you must 
