Mystery Mafia -- Game Thread

I just realized that this probably isn’t the way it works because you would have to know your role to know that you could submit two targets toNight, i.e., know that because you targeted two people that you now have two powers that can directed independently of each other. What probably happens is that whoever you target will get both mine and NP’s actions directed to them.

That’s an interesting thought.

I was thinking it would get randomized one or the other.

Either way, I want to know what you and NP think I should do. You both probably have better handles on your powers than I do. I don’t need to know your reasoning, but let me know a couple of people you think I should target.

Just catching up…a few questions/comments that came up as I read through this morning…

bufftabby, I can’t tell if you are referring to yourself in the 3rd-person here, or if you are quoting someone else and botched the coding. Are you saying you targeted yourself on Night 2?

My comment about gnarly’s death was a mistake, caused by inattention due to job duties :slight_smile:

You have targeted three people. One Night you were redirected from your intended target. All three people that you *actually *visited turned up dead in the morning. Therefore I am 99 44/100% certain you are a Vig/SK. If you want to test your power by having Drain Bead reflect it back onto yourself, please feel free to do so, because it will save the Town having to decide what to do with you.

It’s only a good catch if you believe that anything in particular that **Idle **has told us is true.

This is the sum total of your contribution Today. Might you have anything else to add?

If you think it’s time for a mass claim of some sort, then why don’t you start with yourself? Sort of a “show of good faith”, instead of waiting for a “Confirmed Townie” who doesn’t actually exist at this point.

I forgot a couple things, both regarding Episkey.

First, Episkey, you keep saying that you are one half of a Paranoid/Insane Cop combo, you targeted **gnarlycharlie **last Night, and since gnarly was killed the result that would have gone to gnarly reflected back onto you. This makes no sense to me, given what we know at the moment. Do you have some evidence which directly supports the idea of your ability reflecting back to you upon your target’s death?

Second, can someone please sum up the case against **Episkey **today? He was the only person to receive votes Today before **Idle’s **slip, but I’m not sure exactly why he kept picking up votes.

No it’s not. That’s only true if you are using it against Episkey. If you are looking at it as PIS about me then it is in fact a really good catch. Idle didn’t take me into consideration when writing that bit. It could go either way for Episkey, but it shows that Idle knows I am town. That isn’t what Ben meant, unfortunately, but it was still a good catch.

Since there will be no real voting record today
** vote Idle **

Damned if I do and damned if I don’t. It’s obvious he will be lynched so my vote leaves no real record. But If I don’t vote him someone will pile on me for that too. (my current voting record is atrocious I know that)

As to my powers……. (and I still find it odd that N3 my target was shot ) If I am not blocked I have an idea for toNight.

The mimic could target me and if I end up dead and I am a killer you will have that power for one more day.

If my idea doesn’t work *and * I live then the reflector probably should target me the next Night to get me out of the mele. (unless y’all decide I can distract the role blocker for a while)
I don’t like killing random Town any more than you all do.

I don’t actually have an informed opinion of this particular subtopic at the moment, because I never got the chance yesterday evening review events in light of Idle’s outing as a Wolf. I’m attempting to do that review now, so I’ll refrain from agreeing or disagreeing with you here for the moment.

we should have a second wagon with a couple votes in case there is a day angel

i prefer cracked

I don’t think that we have any roles with Day actions per the rules. Also, why would **Idle **be any more likely to be a day angel (saved by a day angel? I’m not sure what a day angel is) than anyone else we’ve lynched?

Why are you voting for **crackedquads **anyway? I don’t recall seeing any reasons, just the vote.

Day angel?

pretty sure there are no day roles

If/when a majority of players agree to the mass claim, I volunteer to go first if that’s really what we need to get Mr. Plankton on board. But I don’t want to claim unilaterally for the reason I implied earlier: the claims trickling out from Townies lately benefit Scum more than Town because Scum are in a better position to understand bits of information. The mass claim, with Scum obliged to claim also, is how to exploit the claiming process against them.

NAF, Episkey, Pwnsall, and septimus are the final scum remaining…so unless you actually believe me and lynch those people…then yes, you would obviously lose.

coughscumcough

Ok, side bet.

Who wants to guess how many actual scum are in the list?

I will bet 5 noprizes that there is exactly 1 scum on the list. Anyone else want to make a guess? It will entertain the people playing at home.

I will bet 10,000,000 prizes that there are either no scum on my list…or that they are all scum.

I’ll win.

You don’t get to bet, you already know.

Interesting reply.

That you wouldn’t say something like “So there are no scum listed there” if you knew that you weren’t scum yourself.

Because I said either none were or they all were.

I think that’s a very telling response. I’d take note of it people.

It’s the little things like that that catch scum.

day angel isn’t a day action, it’s a night action that prevents a player from being lynched the next day

i have talked about cracked a decent amount but basically he’s said things i think are wrong and he should know better about and he would never try to get away with on our boards

i also still think there are 2p2er wolves tho that’s a bit thin but combined with their deaths and my being blocked n1

his lack of contribution recently also isn’t helping

Actually, you’re the one who’s wrong. Day angel IS a Day action.

Should we all just block Idle, he’s making my head spin. If he is a Traitor (confirmed by his death) then I would take more notice of what he says. At the moment I know he has lied so I am not going to accept anything he says at the moment as truth.

I’m going to die anyway…so why would I bother trying to feed you worthless info that would just be revealed to be bunk upon my death?