Hurry up normal you probably won’t spew yourself wolf here.
Gad, thanks for the player list. i think i need to start a spreadhseet for what days are which, it seems so damn random to me.
Looks like I have all weekend at least 
DAY FIVE VOTE COUNT
Through #4381.
NAF1138 (4): Episkey [4261], crackedquads [4324], Scuba_Ben [4334], lilflower [4349], [del]special ed [4354][/del]
Episkey (2): [del]Scuba_Ben [4247][/del], Silver Jan [4252], Drain Bead [4303]
crackedquads (1): septimus [4331]
Normal Phase (1): special ed [4359]
Please PM me with any corrections.
Also, I updated my signature to include Days Three and Four.
:dubious::dubious:OMG, this forum has a skeptical face.
I’m back and much less irritated than yesterday. Time to find wolves:
If we assume that one of me/naf has to be scum - and I believe we’re at the point where that’s true - then I have a theory on something wolves will probably do today, but want to let it play out first. Prior to eod I will explain my theory and how it could apply to today in full, but I’m going to let some votes fall before I do.
When is eod so I don’t miss it again?
CQ is taking a lot of stock into what we can or cannot determine is a level yet. CQ, I agree with you entirely that Idle’s statements after outed are going to be very readable for spew, but I believe we have to wait until this NAF/me thing is resolved first.
Side note:
@CQ: “Town Village” is pretty damn clever considering the good guys are a “village” on pog while a “town” here. So “town village” covers both.
I’m a bit uh, concerned would be the word, that you don’t know that?
No we don’t, the rest of idle’s spew is not dependent at all on whether or not NAF is a wolf, rather idle’s spew may make NAF a wolf and others non-wolf. There’s a correlation of course but not causation.
The only thing to be concerned with is that apparently I’m not reading role reveals that closely. Town Village sounds like stupid wording. It’s just poor language use and should read Town/Village instead. There’s no such thing as a town village.
He wouldn’t be at the top of my list absent the 50-50 thing. If you held a gun to my head right now and made me choose between him and Episkey I’m not sure which way I would go. NAF’s current behavior makes me want to vote him, but he has the better vote record, having started the BlasterMaster wagon while Episkey only joined it later. Backing off to go after Inner for a while doesn’t entirely erase that.
And yes, more likely to mention villagers. You didn’t answer my question.
What?
Also in Idle big analysis post before he spews himself wolf, he distinctly uses the term Town Village describing NAF but does not use that term when describing the other player (I forget who). Why would that be? I just snap assumed it was because “Town Village” was an editing fail on his part, but maybe the fail was wrt the other player he was talking about.
I went through the posts (the moderately hard way) and pulled the list of the Dead.
The necronomilist:
Day 1 Krayz Town/Bureaucrat
Night 1 Mahaloth WOLF/Tracker
GuiriEnEspaña Town/Vigilante
Silman Town/Journalist
Day 2 Blaster Master WOLF/Propagandist
Night 2 Dancecat Town/Town Crier
Inner Stickler Town/Beat Cop
peekercpa Town/Lightning Rod
Day 3 Sangaman WOLF/Doctor
Night 3 AskThePizzaGuy Town/Poisoner (modkill)
TexCat Town/Mason
gnarlycharlie Town/Mason
Astral Rejection Town/Mystic
brewha WOLF/Vigilante (poisoned Night 2)
Day 4 Idle Thoughts WOLF/Detective
Night 4 LightFoot v1 Town/Mason
Weedy Town/Mystic
Total of five Wolves down.
I took Gad’s list of Living players and tagged it with my estimates on sides. I have 9 out of 20 listed as “no feel”, so I have much to consider this coming weekend.
I believe resolving Pizza’s messages by lynching either Episkey or NAF is important Today, as long as we don’t lose sight of finding all remaining Wolves. However, my list does not include anybody tagged as “strongly leaning Wolf.”
I won’t give you information when you’re at best 50/50 to be a wolf, so I’m not sharing.
Ok. I just hate trying to decipher all that nonsense. So far you believe it shows you as a villager though if I’m correct?
The four were me, naf, pwnsall, you right?
Pwnsall is lock villa, naf is lock scum (though you dont know that of course. To you it’s me/naf are 1/1 lock), and then you. Considering NAF is outed pretty much (again, or me) I’m gonna try to chew on if he’d actually list a second wolf there.
Haha alright. I liked it 
Not really relevant though in the grand scheme of things
Not quite, this is what I said in likelihood of villageriness
Drain Bead
Special Ed
Septimus
Pwnsall
Episkey
^
^
^
Crackedquads
^
^
^
^
^
lilflower*
JD*
Drain Bead, Special Ed, Septimus, Pwnsall and you were all spewed villagers, in that order. I also was spewed villa but the circumstances are less concrete than the above 5. Lilflower and JD were also mentioned but not expanded on by idle despite all of his time to spew so I’m not quite sure what to make of that.
It’s a village by the name of Town ldo
At best 50/50, really, so high? What are you trying to hide, crackedquads? You say you’ve been roleblocked or ineffective every single night so far. Which is it? Not knowing your role yet’s no crime, but you don’t say “no apparent effect”, you specifically say you may have been roleblocked. Yet you’ve never said anything about it before now, and you won’t say on which nights. And you’re making arguments about what Idle would or would not do as scum that seek to excuse your own self-conscious response to his comment about you.
vote: Cracked quads
@ Episkey – Idle also mentioned Drain Bead, Ed and Septimus, at least; there may have been more I’ve forgotten. I have questions for you a couple pages back, too.
I’m also still considerably suspicious of Zeriel. I went and looked to see if what he’d done since my case on him and there was essentially nothing but the obligatory vote on Idle Thoughts: he says he’s been sick.
This is what I’m talking about. I figured the first one about NAF was an edited fail, but maybe he just went to greater care in crafting his fakepeek about naf because they’re w/w. NAF’s win condition wording is correct while Drain Bead’s is not.
@normal which post number? I must have missed them sry.
Poor case is poor. You don’t even want to lynch NAF which is so lol, but I like all the “maybe he is” “i guess he could be” qualifiers. You’re trying to give yourself outs for why you’re not lynching the lolobvious wolf. You’re going to be lynched right after NAF flips wolf. If NAF dies and is a villager, then feel free to lynch me. This is the easiest bet in the world.
Original case on Zeriel:
http://boards.straightdope.com/sdmb/showthread.php?p=14183260&highlight=zeriel#post14183260
I don’t think it’s ever been responded to.