oh he is a mimic
weird
I think any role could be a wolf role at this point, we’ve had a wolf vigilante and wolf doctor for example.
No, but I do anticipate he will die soon if he’s being honest…at the hands of wolves.
And, if we do get towards EndGame with him having 4 or 5 results, his death would be quite welcome.
those are wolf roles i would assume would be in the game tho
cracked if you want to look at other ppl i’d suggest
bufftabby and precambmollusk
MODERATOR NOTE
No talking about PMing the mod, please. 
meaning if you want to reread them, because i don’t feel like they’ve been discussed at all
Unvote: Normal Phase
What I saw as inconsistency is still there. How was she doubled?
However, with lilflower corroborating the story, It’s certainly not a slip by Normal Phase.
I’m still waiting for NAF to weigh in on how he thinks his targets of Night 3 had double actions on night 4.
God only knows. That goes against everything that had happened previously. Town has all the same information about my role that I do. I haven’t held anything back.
Oh, ok. :rolleyes:
OK, thanks. At least I know you read the discussion Normal, lil and I ha about it though, and have nothing to add.
Only up through page 89, but I’ll reply to this.
I’m doing my table with CODE tags, writing it up in a text editor, and lots of preview. This time my table has the CORRECT Night 1 message.
Night Target Message they received
----- -------------- ----------------------------------
1 Scuba Ben Silver Jan is a Villager
2 Giraffe pwnsall is a Villager
2 AskThePizzaGuy Episkey is a Wolf; NAF1138 is a Wolf
(cannot tell which was mine,
but see D4 #3721 claim by known Scum investigating NAF as Town)
3 Scuba Ben Weedy (now Dead) is a Villager
4 Drain Bead special ed is a Villager
Unknown
LighterFeet (LF2)/DuckburgDK/MykBot - who knows. To much player flux to have a read
bufftabby - not enough participation for me to have a read
J.D./SisterCoyote - not enough participation for me to have a read
Precambrianmollusc - was in scum group but down to 50% confidence. Definition unknown
Scathach - I got nothing
septimus - I got nothing
Silver Jan - I got nothing
Probably town
crackedquads - “the stupid, it burns!” is a response I have to town more than to scum. Annoying but probably town.
**Normal Phase ** - Almost made the scum list because of the misrepresentation of the BlaM lynch (I am working on a theory that the players who have done that are more likely to be scum than not). But based on actual play probably town.
Special Ed - breaks my heart. Probably town
Zeriel - close to 100% confirmed after Idle’s death.
Lilflower - again, based on gut. But I was wrong about Idle based on same criteria. Boarderline, but I think town.
Giraffe - Probably town on my notes. I don’t recall why anymore.
Scuba_Ben - Probably town on my notes. Again I don’t recall why off the top of my head.
Episkey - Could not have gone so hard after me as scum. No hedging bets or anything. If scum I am *seriously *impressed.
DonkTimesFour/sachertorte - BlaM voter early, plus meta reasons from when he was sach.
Drain Bead - I think all Idle’s claimed reads were truthful.
Scum
pwnsall/TimeLady - no case yet. Just copying my notes down. Will try to build a case or move off this list.
Suburban Plankton - because he tried to misrepresent the BlaM vote. I suspect this is a scum tactic to get me lynched. Not strong 51% confidence.
Not a great list.
Vote pwnsall case to come later. Mostly process of elimination.
lol, good vote!
OK, I’ve had almost no time for this game the past couple of days, so I apologize if this is a dumb question, but how can we have two poisoners? For the first few Nights, only one person showed up poisoned each Day. For there to be two poisoners, that would have to mean both of them chose the same target twice in a row. That’s pretty unlikely. I would think it’s more likely someone stole/copied pizza’s power, right?
NAF is the one who is believed to be a mimic, right? But he hasn’t claimed to have targeted pizza. If he’s a Wolf mimic, then this would make sense: the scum would want pizza’s poisoning power to kill an extra Townie the next Night.
I need to go back and reread the argument for why one of NAF and Episkey should be scum, but if it holds up, this data point would make me lean toward NAF. Also, he’s struck me as far more Townie than Episkey, which is usually a dead giveaway.
In answer to a few question that were asked after LightFoot was killed.
I don’t know any more than any of you. LightFoot had no clue she was a Mason and with the chain of events she honestly thought she was a killer (hence her target the Night she died)
Has anyone pieced together how LightFoot was/ could have been killed?
**Drain Bead ** may have targeted her but the power they claim would not have killed.
Now we know there is another poisoner to go with said killer. Be they Village or Wolf we know not.
And Idea. If there is a role that can choose one dead player and use that power once (I’ve seen it done)
- no that won’t work because there was an extra kill and a poisoning the same Night.--------- Unless someone was doubled…………………
I’ve got to go back and see what the other me’s said with different eyes. I hope to add more.
LighterFeet
Giraffes idea about NAF makes sense
NAF did you target drain bead
I think we have some sort of ‘universal backup’. I think they assume the ability of one of the players killed the previous Night.
Night 1, Guiri, the Town Vig, was killed. Night 2, someone “found Guiri’s gun” and used it to kill Inner Stickler.
Night 3, Pizza, the town Poisoner, was killed. Night 4, somebody poisoned Drain Bead.
Which means that Night 2, someone assumed the ability of Dancecat, Inner Stickler, or peeker. That means on Night 3 we had an ‘extra’ Town Crier (discloses their true alignmant to their target), Beat Cop (learns their target’s alignment and blocks killing actions), or Lightning Rod (all actions aimed at their target are redirected to them).
If the player is allowed to choose which power they assume, I would guess they would have taken Inner Stickler’s Beat Cop role. If it’s random, then it could be any of the three. If it’s restricted to Town roles only, it could be based on the order in which the deaths are revealed in the Dan post, in which case it would be Dancecat’s Town Crier role. And of course, I could be completely wrong.
Does this sound familiar to anyone?
You probably shouldn’t be telling us these sorts of things. Technically, LightFoot Mark II should have no knowledge of what **Classic LightFoot **did.
Post 4312:
Post 4319:
Post 4332, in response to Post 4312:
Post 4356, in response to Post 4319:
Post 4369, in response to Normal:
Post 4392, in response to Normal:
Post 4401:
Post 4461:
crackedquads,
I targeted you on Night 3.
**Normal **targeted you on Night 3
**pwnsall **targeted you on Night 3
You were very popular.
What did you do on Night 3?
No. My targets are all stated already.