Question all, is it better to lynch lilflower?
If she turns up wolf, we know Episkey is insane detective and might get another result out of him?
Yes, my mistake. I meant Insane instead of paranoid
Do you recall anyone else felling warn and cosy on day 6 (Pwnsall was killed N5 right, after our first lynch attempt on crackedquads?)
When she turns up wolf they eat me and we dont waste a mislynch too.
lilflower
Off to watch the Cowboys/Jets game. Back later
I do and it was all “no apparent result”
Which made me think I might be the mason my former self could not find…* I will be more active but RL is a tad more important now *
No, I don’t. Even though I’m not able to be terribly active, I am trying to read/respond to anything relevant to me. If someone besides pwnsall did feel warm and glowy, it might be helpful if they would say so now.
Yep, it is true 
and I think you are right. You targeted me on N1 cos you thought I was scum and you targeted me last Night cos you thought I was Town lol anyway I do believe you could be the insane cop that always gives wrong results. If Septimus got the message from Scuba then it makes sense that Lilflower is scum
Unvote Episkey
Vote Lilflower
If Episkey is telling the truth about his target, then lilflower would seem to be Scum.
However, we’re still left with the quandary from two Days ago:
On Night 2, Askthepizzaguy was targeted by Scuba Ben (who always generates truthful reports) and by Episkey (who seems to always generate false reports) and pizza reported Wolf whispers on both Episkey and NAF1138.
Thus, if Episkey is indeed Town, then NAF1138 is a Wolf.
I phrased this poorly. What I meant was:
Agreeing that NAF1138 is Town, we conclude Episkey is a Wolf.
But is there any reason why Pizza couldn’t have received a “wrong” result for both** NAF** and Episkey? We might just be jumping to conclusions here.
NETA, ok I misread your post and now I don’t know what to do anymore. I still think that if Episkey always generates wrong reports that** Lilflower** is scum
I’ve changed my mind.
It’s too bad we’re not 100% sure who Scuba Ben targeted last Night. (More generally, such targeting info might lead to easy Town victory at this point, making me increasingly suspicious of players, e.g. lilflower, who don’t reveal.) But, since Scuba Ben knew his power, targeting a likely Townie would be appropriate … so targeting the very Townish septimus would be logical! 
And that would be consistent if Episkey’s Night-6 target was stated honestly. Thus
Unvote: Episkey
Vote: lilflower
All of the alignment whispers seem to be perfectly consistent with my earlier summary, if there was exactly one lie about a report. There seem to be five distinct possibilities:
[ul][li] 1. Pizza received an “Episkey is Town” whisper, but lied about it for reasons of his own.[/li][li] 2. Episkey, Insane-whispering Wolf, received an “Episkey is Town” whisper, and reversed it to be consistent with his claim to be Insane Town.[/li][li] 3. Episkey, Paranoid-whispering Wolf, is lying about Night 6.[/li][li] 4. Zeriel’s read on NAF was somehow incorrect.[/li][li] 5. Other??[/li][/ul]
A scheming Pizza (1) might be almost as likely as a Wolf Episkey (2,3) who’s been so cooperative. (4) seems unlikely. Is there any other explanation (5)?
At this point I am VERY suspicious of anyone who is trying to keep Episkey alive. It is anti-Town to keep rehashing this discussion every Day. We can lynch Lil Tomorrow, once we are sure we’re operating with truthful info.
Why is it suspicious that I haven’t been blurting out every little thing I’ve doing in this game? Don’t you think it’s in town’s best interests to keep a few things unknown to the scum? If someone had claimed something that I could corroborate or dispute, I would certainly speak up.
So we have Jan saying she got a message that I am town and septimus saying he got a message that I am scum.
It’s very likely that Jan was Scuba’s target and septimus was Episkey’s target and Episkey does give out bad information (and that Episkey is town). Now that makes the message about NAF untrue and with Zeriel confirming he is town, I’m not sure how that could happen.
If Episkey is lying about his target and he really targeted Jan, that means he gives out both good and bad information (if that’s a plausible role).
The bottom line is that I am town. I’m fine with you all lynching me if you must. Frankly, I’m tired of talking about Episkey and if lynching me helps figure all of this out, then so be it.
Episkey said that he targeted me on N1 and N6 and both times I received information. On N1 I was told that Gnarly was scum which was incorrect and on N6 I was told that you were Town.
Understood but you don’t know if Episkey really targeted you. We also don’t know what his role is so who knows what he is or is not capable of.
All I’m saying is that I’m town.
I don’t not envy you all trying to figure this out toMorrow.
What d you make of the Nights Episkey said he targeted someone else and that person did NOT recieve the information?
I don’t understand the people unvoting Episkey to vote for lilflower.
Askthepizzaguy, a confirmed Townie received 2 messages on Night 2, saying **NAF1138 **and Episkey were both Scum. We know that Scuba_Ben, a confirmed Town Gossip, targeted Pizza. Therefore at least one of the messages Pizza received must be true.
Zeriel, a confirmed Town Cop, reported that NAF is Town. Therefore the message “NAF is Scum” that Pizza received is false. That means the message “Episkey is Scum” must be true.
We don’t even need to take into consideration what Episkey did or didn’t do that Night (or any other Night, for that matter). This information comes to us directly from two confirmed Town Investigators.
Unless Pizza, Zeriel, or Scuba_Ben lied to us or were given false information (which is admittedly possible, though *thoroughly unexplainable *at this point), Episkey must be Scum.
I just don’t see any logical way that it can’t be so.
vote Episkey
I forgot to mention, I tracked J.D. last Night. He sure was a popular guy 