If you tracked him, you’d only see who he went to visit. Or are you a watcher?
Tracked or watched?
this is exactly correct. Even if it had the chance of being wrong, getting Episkeys role info would be very important to us.
Even if he was a Town (although I dont think he is) he would understand lynching him might be the best thing for us at this point.
Suburban, if your role can see who I visited, dont out it yet please.
oh, forgot I had that first post multi-quoted.
I know my role, and have for a few days now.
I am really big on not outting info unless there is a very specific pro-town reason to do so. There hasnt been yet, so I havent.
I will probably reveal everything before EOD since there is a chance I will die.
I have spent hours going over everything and I don’t think it’s helped lol.
Scuba had to have given out a correct result and** Episkey **apparently a false result
Would that mean that** Episkey** sent the false message about** NAF **and Scuba sent the correct message about Episkey? I know this has been discussed ad nauseam but I am just trying to get things straight in my little brain.
Actually I think we will probably learn a bit more when** Episkey** dies.
Unvote Lilflower
Vote Episkey
It really does make sense that way.** Idle** and Giraffe also visited** Pizza** that night but I don’t think they were giving out information.
Tracked. I see who my targets visit.
J.D., I’d rather wait until you announce your own action, so that I know whether or not you’re being truthful. I see no compelling reason to say anything right at the moment, but I am of the opinion (and have been for a couple Days now) that full information on targets would be a good thing at this point.
Ahhhh, I see what you mean…
My “he sure was a popular guy” was meant as a commentary on the number of people who *claim *to have targeted J.D. last Night (myself, Drain Bead, NAF1138, PCM). I have no knowledge of who *actually *visited him.
As I explained, it doesn’t matter who targeted **Pizza **that Night, except for Scuba_Ben.
Ben told us that he targeted Pizza, and we know Ben gave true information. Therefore, Pizza must have received at least one piece of true information. We know that the information he received regarding **NAF **was false (per Zeriel), so that means the information he received regarding **Episkey **must have been true.
Got it 
I’ll concede that I was wrong.
Unvote: lilflower
Vote: Episkey
By my count, there are 16 living players, of whom no more than 4 are Scum.
Regarding lilflower:
If **Scuba_Ben **targeted **septimus **last Night and **Episkey **targeted Silver Jan, then lilflower is Scum
If Ben targeted Jan and Episkey targeted septimus, then lilflower is Town.
We don’t know who Ben targeted, and assuming Episkey is Scum, we don’t know who he targeted either.
Of course, unless someone else claims to have received alignment info last Night, we’ll be left to conclude that Jan and septimus were the targets, in whichever order.
Unless I’m mistaken we’re plum out of investigative roles, so I’m not sure how we make a decision on **lilflower **without lynching her.
You could lynch Episkey instead and find out what his role is. Isn’t there a role that always sends scum reads whether the person is scum or not?
Ah, I see.
Pity, I was looking forward to lynching you.
I watched NAF and had noapparent result, I did not claim to watch JD
ok so since most of what I really wanted to see is now out there anyways, and everyone wants it, here is my info.
I am a psychiatrist, i pick a person, and they get their role in a PM overnight.
i targeted:
astral rejection
special ed (rand before I subbed)
Idle Thoughts (rand I forgot)
myself
suburban plankton
Precambrianmollusc
so…
explain please?
explain?
and Suburban can obviously confirm my visit now.
I just wrote a post trying to see if I could find fault with Suburbans reasoning - more a logical test really and ended up with so many new roles and coincideces required for EPISKI not to be scum that it pretty much seamed certain the Suburbans logic is correct and EPISKi is scum. then it was eaten.
I am concerned over the apparent coincidence that both SJ and Septimus ended up with whispers on Lilflower. One could simply be lying to help scumbuddy EPISKI out by adding a bit more confusion.
FYI I trust Suburban because I have seen him track who he said he tracked, and the scum tracker I believe is dead.
JD - every night I have received a result which is consitent with a town watcher. On two nights I was also sent a role PM , with my name at the beginning. One night I was told I was the apothecary which was a town role with certain powers. then I was told I was the town efficiency expert with certain powers.
On Night 5, I got a PM stating that I was a Town Tracker – unlikely since I’ve never gotten a Tracking result.
(I assume Night-0 is omitted from this list.)
But only you and Ed report receiving these correct PMs, right?
My PM was the right Night (N5) and matches your target, but was sent to the wrong person. But the other wrong PM’s didn’t matched your target’s role. Thus, that I got a Tracker PM when you targeted the real Tracker might just be coincidence.
BTW, by this time Scum has probably identified our Doctor by elimination. Would it be best for Doctor to out herself and let Ed give her a double Doctoring power for Night 8?
Septimus who did you target N5?
Septimus, I may be confused here.
Every night except the night I targeted myself I got “no apparent result”
I targeted myself and got what I believe is my full role.
Others I targeted have confirmed they received a role PM for themselves.
I do not get any info, it goes to my target.
oh shit.
ignore everything I just said about precam.
I have reason to believe I was either a) roleblocked, or b) the poison makes it unable to execute my night action.
WTF.