Thanks, it’s frustrating that I put in the time to put together the case against Scuba_Ben with links and it’s still being boiled down to flip-flopping.
The interesting point about the flip-flopping isn’t that he did it, as that means nothing, but why and the when.
The interesting point about his peeker vote isn’t that he voted him, it’s that his reason for doing so seems to be a pretty straight-forward and deliberate misrepresentation and, again, timing.
But seriously, to those who are going to dismiss the Scuba_Ben case, at least get it right or, preferably, tell me where I screwed up in my analysis.
I am just answering as I read so things are going to be out of sequence. No I did not target** Scuba Ben** but I was asked to send in the name of an alternate player in case the person I targeted was lynched. I did not get a result of the first person but I DID get a result on the second person. Still happy with your vote Zeriel? BTW it wasn’t** Zeriel** either.
It’s not your fault, but I’m having a ton of trouble keeping up with subs. When you post the next offical player list (I assume at Dusk), can you make sure to note who is subbing for who? Thanks.
Yes, that’s the bandwagon analysis I’ve been slogging through the posts working on.
So, here’s where I get confused. Say Peeker is scum and his scum buddies orchestrate a couple more bandwagons to save him. If we’re on the high side of scum - there could be 9 of those 21 votes belonging to scum - so that’s very possible.
What I don’t get is Krays’ defense of Peeker. He calls out three people as wolves when they voted** peeker** - though he said that his intention was not to call out peeker voters exclusively.
We know Krays is town. I think we can assume that he got lynched to save one of the other lead vote getters. I’m just not convinced that** Peeker** was the scum that was saved.
Of course, there’s would be no way for Krays to know Peekers alignment since we know he was town. Something just seems out of place here.
I dont’ think Texcat was the other wagon since I don’t think she had any votes at all when the band waggoning started. I’ve got to see where SilverJan fits in all this chronologically.
I know I dont’ have anything conclusive in this post, but I want to see what others think.
I am not dismissing the case. Rather my feeling is that I had a better place for my vote and tried to hint (using a tiny number of words) at why I wasn’t “feeling” the case agianst Scuba Ben.
