This is a church-league team, from Crossroads Church, in Corona, California. Any funny or clever names would be appreciated. It’s a Protestant church.
Go.
Being Catholic, I have to wonder what the hell a Cardinal is doing playing softball with a bunch of Protestants 
That said, how about calling your team the Crossroads Blues, after the old Robert Johnson song? You could get a little of that “deal with the devil for instant success” mojo going for you.
How about calling your team the “Oops”?
‘Gospel Truth’
‘Holy Rollers’
‘John 11:35’
‘Wise Virgins’
‘Chosen Ones’