Nested Quotes

On a separate message board I frequent (ddrfreak.com), quoting is infinitely easier. We hit quote, and the entire message of the poster before us becomes quoted–including any quotes this poster may have had before.

Example: http://www.ddrfreak.com/phpBB2/viewtopic.php?p=7572800#7572800 (If it doesn’t link for you, scroll down to the post from “Mark,” and look at his first quote.

It’s a quote-within-a-quote. Excellent for quoting the OP and the comment at hand. Here is how I would code something similar:



[QUOTE=OP]

[QUOTE=Comment]
Here is the comment.  It's in a smaller, nexted quote box within the big quote bos.
[/quote]
Here is the very original post.  It's in the largest box available.
[/quote]


My question is, why can't we have this?

oh my god. It actually works.

Color me stupid.

Okay, new question. Why don’t the nested quotes carry over when I hit the quote button?

Probably because they sort of become redundant after they were first quoted. (in most cases) so they are not included to save space.

A little test:

fz <-- at least two characters.

The hamsters used to automatically nest internal quotes, but the feature was dropped in one of the vBulletin updates (I think it was when we came back from the Winter of Missed Content, about two years ago). It makes for much cleaner-looking threads, since a lot of folks habitually “quote” an entire post, unedited, before making their own reply. The exponential growth of those posts–as folks merely continued to quote the responses to the responses with all the old responses still intact–got to be pretty ridiculous in many instances.

ooooooohhhhh… pretty… golden… boxes…

A bit like those chain e-mail things where every single ‘original message’ text was left in?

Nitpick: Linear growth, at most, not exponential, since each post would add at most one layer of nesting. Sorry, misuse of “exponential” is a pet peeve of mine.

Very good, Squink and Lobsang. Now all you have to do is figure out the vB codes for tesselated fish, birds, and lizards.

Eh, go to liberal arts grad school, ya darn nitpickin’ math major.

:slight_smile:

Error’s slippery slope claims another victim. :wink:

If you had majored in liberal arts, you would have recognized the usage of “math major” as symbolic of the hard sciences in general. :stuck_out_tongue: