Last season was the first one to have the judges’ vote-off, and Spicer was in it. I mentioned in that thread, post #7, that his cause was ultimately doomed because he needed to be no lower than third from the bottom to stay alive (which was the case, although he did last longer than I expected). As for Bobby Bones, the big beef with him winning (some truly epic outrage here) which, given his fanbase, the judges would be most likely powerless to prevent.
My problem with Tyra Banks is that she’s annoying. All the stupid questions, all the egging on, all the pretense, and she has to use all these pseudo-Valley Girl accents that just grate. I’m not going to pretend that that’s what’s going to give her the boot, though.