Well, I’ve officially dumped Auctioneer in favor of Auctionator. I just finally had enough of Auctioneer locking up the game while it did its scanning on each and every auction I tried to post. I looked at the things SFG mentioned about it erroneously scanning everything in my bags, but this didn’t seem to be the situation in my case. At least not as far as looking at the numbers on the progress bars — the only number I ever saw there was “1”. Yet it continued to freeze the game for 1-3 minutes every time. I think the problem (for me, anyway) is that Auctioneer is just too feature-laden for my purposes. Each item I wanted to sell or buy was scanned and analyzed in every possible way, most of which I was never going to use.
Main things I like better about Auctionator:
Selling:
• Quickly identifies the current lowest-priced auction and automatically undercuts by a reasonable amount
and
• Generates a Starting Bid price based on the Buyout price it generated (as opposed to Auctioneer’s method of undercutting the Buyout and Starting Bid prices separately, which far too often resulted in it looking at two different auctions, so that I could get a reasonable Buyout undercut based on the current lowest Buyout, but then the Starting Bid would be ridiculously low because it was based on a completely different auction, usually posted by some noob/halfwit posting a single item with a 2c Starting Bid and no Buyout - too many stacks of my mats coming up with, say, a 50g Buyout and a 19s Starting Bid, which I’d have to manually change, or cancel my auction, run to the mailbox, and start over again because I clicked the “Create Auction” button too quickly).
• Posting one stack at a time and bulk posting multiple stacks use the same interface (vs. Auctioneer which had two different interfaces using completely different methods for calculating prices; I had to use the Appraiser tab to bulk post, and 99% of the time that interface returned the message, “Cannot match lowest price”, no matter how much fiddling I did with the settings).
Buying:
• Consolidates multiple auctions from the same seller and lets me buy as much as I want from that seller, one click per stack, with no separate confirmation click after each purchase
• Shopping Lists! It remembers mats I’ve purchased in the past and keeps them in a list on the side, so all I need to do is go to the “Buy” tab and click on an item in the list, and it automatically searches for that item