I’m no fan of Dave Matthews, but I’m even less of a fan of rock critics. God knows it’s easy enough to get a good idea of new releases for free on the internet. If you like the music you should buy it, regardless of what some pseudo-intellectual poseur thinks.
I found it pretty consistant with every other Dave Matthews Band album. You’ll like it if you like Dave Matthews. If you don’t like his music, well, you won’t be surprised.