I have the same reaction to that song, and those lines. I can remember first hearing it as a hormone-addled teenager, in love with the very idea of a wild, rapturous love like that, and practically had tears in my eyes.
Annie Lennox sings “Into the West” with extraordinary emotive power, I think: - YouTube
Mary J. Blige helps U2 knock “One” out of the park here: Mary J. Blige, U2 - One (Official Music Video) - YouTube
And Patty Griffin gives it her all - and it’s a lot - in this rendition of “Heavenly Day”: - YouTube
“Hey, how you feelin’?
Are you still the same, don’t you realize the things we did
We did were all for real, not a dream
I just can’t believe they’ve all faded out
Of view, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, ooh”
I love “Nights in White Satin” too, and have ever since I was a kid.
I have a lot of other songs that give me “tingle moments,” but probably the biggest one is Peter Gabriel’s “Signal to Noise.” Near the end of the song (past the 5:00 mark) there’s an instrumental bit that slowly builds to a crescendo, ending with the repetition of the line “Receive and transmit” over a pounding drumbeat (at 5:43 in this video).
I’ve mentioned this several times before in similar threads here, but that segment does something to me every time I hear it, no matter how many times I hear it. I have to turn it up. It’s beautiful (and live, it was absolutely amazing).
Not just “Nights in White Satin” but the whole damned album Days of Future Passed really does it for me.
A close second is Al Stewart’s Year of the Cat, especially “Sand in Your Shoes”:
On Remembrance Day the bands all played,
The bells pealed through the park
And you lay there by the “Do Not” signs,
And shamed them with your spark
Now winter moans in old men’s bones
As the day falls into dark
And it’s goodbye to my lady of the islands.
The one that really tugs at my heart is Enya’s “Flora’s Secret,” since it reminds me of the most intense love affair of my life in the summer of 1975:
*Lying in the long grass
In the sunlight
They believe it’s true love
And from all around them
Flora’s secret
Telling them of love
And the way it breathes, and
Looking up from eyes of
Amaranthine …
They can see the sky is blue
Knowing that their love is true
Dreams they never knew
And the sky above is blue. *