This nine-year old Dutch girl taught herself how to sing opera by watching Youtube vids. She hasn’t had singing lessons. The way she sings is unbelievable. Like, literally unbelievable. You’d think it was fake, but it isn’t.
She was on the Dutch edition of <country>'s got talent, just a week ago.
It was annoying to have to hear the audience clap every time she hit a high note.
She is good but, she doesn’t understand what the song is about. Listen to this version and hear it performed by an adult who is expressing the emotional content.
Yeah, I had to go pick up my own fallen jaw as well. It may turn out that she has had singing lessons, but that they made up the Youtube story because it is a better story. Still, even with singing lessons, she’s freaking nine years old.
Yeah, that bothered me a little too. Especially changing the ending: she’s begging her father for pity, ending in that way doesn’t make sense at all. She also muddled the words. It’s perfectly excusable for a 9 y/o, of course. But it seems a shame, since her voice is lovely. It also makes it more plausible that she has little training, if any. She looked quite untrained to me, with my only very barely trained eye. Although that means she is talented, singing in this way with no training could also damage her voice and she could be teaching herself damaging techniques. Still, very impressive for a little girl!
I love singing this piece myself, however cliched it might be.
I had a classmate in German lessons who was working on learning half a dozen languages exactly so she’d be able to read the librettos herself, rather than having to ask people what each song was about constantly. She was already a professional opera singer. That girl simply needs someone to help her with that.
Don’t girls’ voices change when they go through puberty? I know they don’t change nearly as much as boys’, but still, that could come as a harsh shock to this kid: When you’re that good, almost any change at all is going to be for the worse.