O.K., so what's the Shaggy Dog Story?

In this recent Thread about the Aristocrats Joke, Cisco references the similar Shaggy Dog Story. In a prior Aristocrats Joke Thread the same Shaggy Dog Story reference was made by pravnik. So, what’s the Shaggy Dog Story???

Prior to reading about the Aristocrats Joke I was not familiar with it- but I was familiar with other jokes of the same tradition* so I did understand the point of and the humor of the Aristocrats joke when I read it. With this understanding I can deduce the nature of the Shaggy Dog Story, but still I’d like to know how it goes.

*The one I know is the “Fuck you, Clown!” Joke. I’ll be happy to retell it if anyone feels the need to know it.

A Shaggy Dog Story is a really really long story. It’s drawn out to the point of people groaning and walking away. However, the people that tough it out and stay until the end of the story are rewarded with…nothing!

A friend of mine has a favorite about a guy who goes to an exotic Eastern country and hears a strange noise from far off in the distance while in his hotel room. When he asks about the sound he is told that he cannot be told because he is not a monk. The guy gets so curious that he goes through rigorous training and much anguish and pain (resulting eventually in the loss of all his limbs) to become a monk. After a loooooong description of this process, he is finally told to what the sound is. The listener invariably says “Well, what was the sound?!”, to which my friend replies, “I cannot tell you, for you are not a monk.”

This particular one probably wouldn’t be considered an exact Shaggy Dog Story by the most rigorous standards, but it is in the same spirit and very similar.

The only other one I can think of right now is a very long description of a day in the life of three different men, ending with the statement that “Two out of three people prefer Corn Flakes to Cheerios.”

So, are you saying that “Shaggy Dog Story” is just the generic name for this type of story? Or is there an actual Shaggy Dog Story about a shaggy dog?

I do appreciate your explanation of what a Shaggy Dog Story is, your explanation is very well stated, but I do already understand how it all works and the point of it. What I’m asking for is the Shaggy Dog Story after which this type of story is named. Or isn’t there one?

Thanks for chiming in!

There was a prototypical Shaggy Dog Story which involved a dog which was shaggy, hence the name. (Unfortunately, I do not recall it.) But the term has become generic for a long-build-up/absurd punchline story.

Oh, I’m pretty sure there is one. I’ve never heard it or read it but I’m pretty sure I’ve read about it.

And I should clarify just a touch why I think the Aristocrats merits a comparision to Shaggy Dog Stories. Like I said: A Shaggy Dog Story tortures its listeners before giving no payoff simply by being very, very long. The Aristocrats similarly tortures its listeners before giving no payoff simply by being very, very disgusting. IMO it’s one of the greatest jokes every told for this very reason (but then again I like Shaggy Dog Stories as long as you’re a good enough storyteller to fake me out, which is hard to do since I’ve heard quite a few of them.)

By the way, what’s the “Fuck you, Clown!” joke?

Oh, boy . . . you’re going to have to give me a few minutes.

I’ll be right back.

The original shaggy dog story involved a man who saw an ad promiseing a large reward for the return of a lost shaggy dog. The man goes to great length to capture and return the dog, traveling continents in the process, only to be told “my dog wasn’t that shaggy” when he finds the owner.

I also heard a version of the shaggy dog, in which the owner of a shaggy dog takes his pet to a shaggy dog contest and keeps winning - it goes through every contest, starting with the local one, through to the Shaggiest Dog On Earth contest and the dog wins at every stage, at which point the dog goes to the Shaggiest Dog in the Universe contest, where the judge says: “that’s not a very shaggy dog.”

Yup, long and ultimately anticlimactic.

Bienville’s Own Humble Retelling of the Classic Tale:

I’ve made it longer in prior tellings, but I’m short on time right now. Sorry!

Not exactly a shaggy dog story, but I’m reminded of Mark Twain’s short story “The Story of the Old Ram”. An inebriated man starts to relate the story of his grandfather’s old ram, then gets sidetracked, then gets sidetracked from the sidetrack, sidetracked ^3, and so forth; until he passes out drunk having never gotten around to actually saying anything about his grandfather’s ram.

P.S. thanks to Johnny Ecks and Idlewild for giving good answers to the specific question in the OP! :slight_smile:

I don’t remember who but there’s a stand-up comic whose act is telling stories that get sidetracked again, again, and again. He eventually finds his way back to the original story, finishes it and all his sidetracks.