Old School Mafia Reunion (newer players welcome too)

Thread Games
361

I was just kidding. We are looking at this also.

My personal opinion, this is not exactly cathedra just NAF the player talking, is that if you are mod killed you have been erased. Removed as though you never played. You can neither win or lose, because you aren’t in the game. If we need to we will work backwards through time to make things even up.

I have always felt that the spirit rather than the letter of the law was more important. This is why my games tend to have weird crap happen in them. So, again, not speaking as a mod in this post. We will have an official position late. But it may be helpful to know how at least one of us thinks about this sort of thing.

362

This, I think, we have covered. But there is information you can’t know.

Edit: it’s also possible we will tweak things before the official game thread.

363

I think I will also add a rule indicating that modkills are at the discretion of the moderators at all times; if we think you’re trying to game the rules, we’ll make things so that you can’t.

364

A clarification on the multi-lynching: If, by some chance (successful Doctor or Blocker, or Scum choosing not to kill, or whatever) no Townies die during a Night, will there still be a lynch the next Day?

365

The town deaths only relate to extra lynches. The standard Lynch is always available.

366

So if there’s exactly one Townie death overNight, then there’s still only one lynch total?

367

Yes

368

No, and we will make clear the required number of votes for each additional lynch. The top vote getter will always be lynched.

369

I hope you all don’t mind, but we thought a Google Form would be a way to get a final count of who is signed up. Please sign up at the form below. I did not choose to have it collect emails/data from you, but let me know if it does and I will try to turn that off.

You have until 12/30 to sign up officially.

All you have to do is type your username and press submit. That’s it.

Here is the form.

And here is the spreadsheet that displays our official sign-up list is right here. Check for your name!

370

And hey, only sign up if you are already on the list. This is a confirmation process to make sure that now that you know what all is involved you still want in.

371

Ah yes, the ole’ double secret signup.

372

Ah, yes, thanks.

373

Everyone who hasn’t signed up on the new sheet yet is clearly lurking. It’s already been three hours.

374

Yes. And even if there are 2 or 3 Town deaths at Night, the additional lynches are never required. People can always avoid reaching those vote-total-thresholds in order to keep it at one lynch.

And 3 lynches is the maximum per Day.

375

Thank you…now we’ll have a brand new topic to debate endlessly on Day 1. :smiley:

376

Now you are getting the idea. :cool:

377

So, if there are 55 players, and 27 vote for Abigail, 22 vote for No Lynch, and the remaining 6 vote Bernard and three townies died the previous night, who gets lynched? Just Abigail, or Abigail and Bernard?

378

Abigail dies, because she had the most votes.
No Lynch does not go through, because it only works if it’s the most.
Bernard doesn’t die, because he didn’t get 34% for the second lynch, and even though he got the 10% threshold for a third lynch, the third lynch only goes through if the second one does.

If, instead, the no-lynch voters had voted for Charlie, then all three would die.

379

Only Abigail. I guess we should have clarified that “no lynch” can’t be one of the second or third lynches since it contradicts the first lynch.

And no, the third person would not be lynched since no one reached the second lynch threshhold.

380

I’ve just signed up, although I’m just an alternate.