Our rent-a-dog needs to be a rescue

(All names changed for reasons that will become clear.)

A few weeks ago I saw a post on the neighborhood chat site from a pregnant single Mom, Mia. She was overwhelmed and needed some assistance. Her older daughter (11-ish YO) Jane had convinced her to get a dog but was not at all taking care of it. Mom was too tired and sick to do it, and wanted someone to take the dog until a couple of months after the baby came – just to give her a rest.

The homies and I all love having a dog about the place, but are not quite ready to commit to a full-time canine. So we really enjoy having rent-a-pups come through. I put a note out to all of them to see how they felt about taking on this longer than usual “lease.” We were all for it, so I went to visit them.

At my visit it was clear that Lulu was much skinnier than she should be. She was immediately friendly with me, and Mia remarked that’s unusual with strangers. It’s normal for me though, as I’ve spent a lot of years working with and training dogs. So I didn’t think a lot about it.

We talked a bit about what she was looking for. I understood that I would be taking the dog on the weekdays, so that Jane could have her dog home on the weekends. Jane gave her mother a heartbroken look and asked “Will this be like Spike?” The Mom told me that her brother had adopted Spike when the daughter failed to care for him.

I asked Jane to look me in the eye and said “Nobody is trying to take your dog, OK? I’m just here to help your Mom out until she gets settled in with the new baby.”

A week later (and about a month early) I got an emergency call that the baby was on the way. There is a ton of detail I would love to add here, but suffice it to say that picking her up showed me a lot of truth the owner never told me about. Like a minuscule crate the dog had clearly spent way too much time in, and no dog food anywhere in the house.

I finally got her home and settled in my space. She was so scared. She wouldn’t eat if I was in the room. Wouldn’t take a treat unless I was at least four feet away and wasn’t looking. Bolted in terror every time I moved. Hand shy, foot shy (OMG the rage!!) mats in her coat so bad they were pulling on her skin, and overall practically feral. As far as I could tell she had no English vocabulary at all. Not even “sit” which every dog I’ve ever worked with had down pat by eight weeks.

For the first few days I just tried to live in her periphery and let her CNS get used to being out of the cage. She wolfed down chow morning and night, but I had to walk away and sit down before she would touch it. After about 3-4 days she started leaving a few bites in every bowl. I lowered the feed amount a few times, but she kept leaving food until I realized – she’d been starved. She was leaving food in case the next feed didn’t come. Poor sweet puppy.

She would jump into my lap if I patted it, but not in a happy way. I would call it fawning behavior. Still, it allowed me to surreptitiously cut out the worst of the mats.

Twice Mia made appointments for Jane to come by and see her dog. Both times they no-showed. They have not wanted to take her on the weekends.

It has been about four weeks now. She is not afraid of anything I do. I can touch her feet and snout without fear. She’s had a second bath now, but still needs a full groom to get the smaller mats out.

She sleeps on my bed, near my feet but not touching. In the morning she army crawls up the bed for cuddles. A couple of days ago she took a treat from hand for the first time. She’s beginning to be playful.

She is still easily frightened. Something scared her in the back yard (big truck or train from the sound of it) and now she doesn’t want to go out anymore. We’re working through it again. She was doing really well for a while there, but at least she has learned to use the puppy pads indoors.

She’s learned several english words like come, sit, chow, treat, but also wait and gentle. One of the homies got her some buttons, and I’ve placed them around near her various activities. Chow, treat, outside, clean-up (for the puppy pads) requests that she makes (or used to). But I’m not trying to get her into that yet, she’s still in kindergarten – the buttons are high school. Just leaving them around as familiar objects and pushing them when I do things.

When one of the homies needs to talk to me they will ring the bell or knock and open the door to speak. She has learned to bark once (inform) and then let me handle it. She’s going to make a great watch dog.

Here’s the horror I’m living under though: we have no legal rights to hold onto this dog. The original agreement was for two months, and one is up. I’ve thought of a hundred strategies to keep them from taking her back, but none realistically works. And my promise to Jane haunts me.

But how can I possibly return her to a situation where she has clearly been hit, kicked, and starved? Mia put another note out on the neighborhood site with a photo of an English Bulldog. Her BF apparently is moving in with them (thank goodness – for the baby’s sake) and they need someone to take the BD until her lease is up (six months.) After that they plan to get a house with a fenced yard.

So I’m thinking we probably actually have five months. What do we do then though? Returning her would be too awful; it doesn’t bear thinking about. I do give Mia credit for reaching out for help. And I know there are a lot of people in the world who think crating and hitting dogs magically teaches them how to act. But nobody thinks they are teaching a dog when they kick one. And she was clearly foot shy.

I promise pics as soon as I can get her fully groomed. Don’t want to embarrass her! <3

If the dog is neglected, I have a funny feeling Mia might not be too disappointed if it doesn’t come back. Maybe when she’s ready, ask if she’d like you to hang on to the dog (or continue whatever your arrangement is) for a bit longer. It wouldn’t surprise me if, based on nothing at all other than your post so I could be wrong, Mia is hoping Jane loses interest in the dog at some point. I’m guessing that’s exactly what happened with Spike.

Do they live nearby? Maybe talk to Mia and see if she’d prefer you keeping the dog full time and letting Jane stop over to play with it for a few hours on the weekends and then transitioning that into it being your dog.

Whatever you end up doing, if it’s going to involve the dog being at their house less (or not at all), I’d start moving towards that sooner rather than later. Jane is going to be starting her summer break in less than two months. It’s going to be harder if she loses her dog right before summer.

And, I wouldn’t suggest doing this, or at least I probably wouldn’t do it, but if the brother is older and moved out, you could reach out to him and see what’s going on. You might feel better about this if he says something like ‘yes, please, keep the dog, they shouldn’t have one, they don’t take care of it, that’s why took Spike’.

Also, I’m pretty sure your concern is about returning the dog to that house, not losing a dog that you like having around. I only say that because if it’s the latter, I know some rescues have ‘regular’ people hold on to dogs before they’re adopted. My aunt used to run one and while I never took her up on the offer, was always asking if I wanted one of the rescue dogs for a few months, all expenses (including food) paid by the rescue.

Oh, this is awful. Please don’t return that poor animal to a miserable existence. It sounds like maybe the family needs money? Can you offer Mia or Jane $100 or so, explaining that you really love the dog and want to buy her and that is would be best to give her a good home with you? You could draw up a handwritten bill of sale to prove the dog really belongs to you now. Maybe give Jane visitation rights. (I imagine she will stop visiting after a while, if she comes at all)

The hitting and kicking is blatant abuse. The over crating and not providing foods, grooming or vet visits(I’ll bet) is abuse as well.

Do not take that dog back there. If they kick up a fuss call the animal rescue people in your area. The dog police. The humane society. A vet you know. Some one in charge of animal protection.

Kicking a helpless starving dog is criminal.

I did wonder if it was some sort of scam. To get our sympathy and make us spend money to keep the dog.

To be clear, it was supposed to be shared custody. They reneged on their only two visits, and have not contacted us since. I’m sure all their time, energy, and attention is taken up with the new baby.

I know. But you have to be able to prove it. Like a twit I didn’t take any photos or make any reports at the time. How do you call the police on a mother in labor?! (Don’t call me Ned. IYKYK.)

It would be my word against theirs. We will take her to the vet, and I’m debating whether to go ahead and microchip her under our name if she hasn’t been already.

To give you an idea of the symptoms I am working off of: When she first got here, she would just pee where she lay. It took a couple of weeks for her to even stand up and squat to do it. That is a sure sign of a dog who has lived in a cage all their life. I’ve only ever seen it in a bitch rescued from an Amish whelping farm. That one had never touched grass before.

Ok. Check on the bulldog if you can. If it’s underweight he’ll look like grampa in a very baggy suit.

I’m worried about him.

Ask the new Mom whether she uses a particular vet because you want to do her a favor and update her shots.
If she doesn’t have one she won’t have an answer.
That’s neglect if she’s never been vetted. Spayed, shots, flea and tick meds or even a microchip.
I believe urine scald stays a long time on a dogs tummy. If it gets bacterial.

I bet a Doctor can still see signs of maltreatment and starvation.
I think you have a case.

IMHO

Even if it is a scam (although I doubt it, probably just ignorance and being overwhelmed), I’d certainly offer something to get him out of their orbit. I wouldn’t even want Jane coming around for a visit. Are you in a position where you want to keep her? Maybe tell the mom that you have a “friend” who just fell in love with the dog and wants to buy her. Get a bill of sale, just in case.

StG

So the BD is supposedly the boyfriend’s dog. He looked underexercised and overfed from the photos. The only way to check on him is to text Mia, and I’m really just trying to let her forget I exist. This probably sounds evil to you, but I can’t take on the BD too. I need to focus on saving Lulu, and I do think that inertia might be her best chance.

My Dad raised champion EBDs so I have a very high idea of what they are supposed to look like. This guy looked like an overstuffed sausage on twigs.

Maybe you can’t take the dog. But if you see signs of abuse. Overfeeding an obesity breed is just as dangerous as underfeeding

That is when you call animal protection services to pay them a visit.

ETA. Are the children well cared for?

This. Ignore them. They’ll probably never contact you again. If they do, tell them they owe you $x,xxx for vet & food bills which they can pay before you bring back the dog.

Wait, wait, wait. They offloaded one dog they couldn’t take care of, and now they’re getting another dog they need to offload? OK, it’s the boyfriend’s dog, and comes with the boyfriend… but presumably he was already taking care of the dog before he moved in, and is still able to take care of it now? It sounds like they’re somehow in the business of getting dogs and then immediately getting rid of them, except that I have no idea how that “business” would work.

Regardless, something is seriously wrong here, in ways that we don’t even entirely understand (and the parts we do understand are already bad enough).

I’m guessing she couldn’t exactly tell her daughter she’s giving her dog away, then say “Oh, but my honey is moving in and bringing his dog.”

Agree 100%. She was really confused when nobody on the neighborhood site wanted to take care of the EBD for six months and then give it back. ??? I took Lulu because I am serious about helping new mothers. But yeah, I would help with the EBD if I could.

As to Beck’s very important question, I do think that Jane is well cared for, in a manner of speaking. She was obviously fed, and she had an afternoon carer who picked her up at school and stayed with her until Grandma got home from work each day. I suspect a father providing help specific to her? A lot of guesswork here. Her room had nice furniture and plenty of clothes. Her Grandmother and Aunt were taking the braids out of her hair when I arrived. But I’ll never forget the sound of her voice when she was asking whether this dog was gonna be like Spike. IOW, was she going to get her dog back. It’s going to haunt me forever. $^%@*#(!

If you get legal ownership of the dog, you can invite Jane over whenever. And do you know why she was a no show? Maybe her mom didn’t let her go. Maybe she was so upset about Spike she doesn’t want to be attached to this one.

I adopted an abused cat. It’s not obvious any more, but boy was it obvious when we got him. And he’s still afraid if you lean down and reach over to pet him. I sometimes do it by mistake, because that’s how i greet my other cats, who happily bump up against my hand.

Write up a description. Document the abused behaviors she still has. Just in case. But i don’t think the mom wants to keep the dog. I bet she’ll let you buy it for a modest price.

Also,

That’s not your fault. That’s something her mom did to her.

You should check to see if she’s already chipped. If so, then the other family has a claim on her, and they would need to sign her over to you via the chip software (we had to do this with our dog that rehomed to us). That could involve some drama in this situation.

If not chipped, then this is a stray dog you found and want to keep. A friend of mine had a neighbor that kept a dog tied-up and alone in the front yard - the dog was friendly yet lonely. He’d go over there and pet and play with it, the owner never did. Finally, my friend just went over there and took the dog home, told the neighbor why. No resistance from the neighbor. He was finally loved and cared-for, and was a great hiking/trail dog!

If the dog is unchipped, just take it, keep it, chip it, and love it. As others are saying, don’t send her back there.

I wanted to elaborate on this. You made a promise you can’t keep because the mother lied to you. That sucks, but it’s on her, not on you.

Thank you. I needed to hear that more than I realized.