Outlaw Feud: Lord of the Rings by 5 time champ [Game Over]

  1. Narsil
  2. Bilbo
  3. The Shire
  4. Orthanc
  5. Strider
  6. Lorien
  7. Galadriel’s Ring
  8. Eowyn
  9. On Weathertop
  10. Took

Bonus question, no points
Rate the movie:

A noble effort given the complicated and lengthy material

  1. Anduril

  2. Isildur

  3. Gondor

  4. Isengard

  5. Strider

  6. Manwe

  7. Nenya

  8. Eowyn

  9. At Weathertop

  10. Proudfoot

  11. Duh! See my username.

  12. Wanna say “Estel,” but I know that wouldn’t get as many responses.

  13. Galadriel’s ring.

  14. Proudfeet!

Extra credit: A very noble effort given the complicated and lengthy material

We still love you, DoloRebo!

  1. Anduril
  2. Sauron
  3. Gondor
  4. Orthanc
  5. Strider
  6. Manwë
  7. Narya
  8. Meriadoc
  9. Weathertop
  10. Took
  • Meh +
  1. Sting
  2. Bilbo Baggins
  3. Gondor
  4. Orthanc
  5. Strider
  6. Elbereth
  7. Nenya
  8. Eowyn
  9. The Prancing Pony in Bree
  10. Gamgee

Notes:
4: I wanted to say “Osgiliath”, that being the location of the primary stone, but I know that won’t be most popular.
6: The one name that everyone who’s read the trilogy will remember. O Elbereth, Gilthoniel! The risk is just whether they’ll know she was a Vala.

  1. Anduril, Flame of the West
  2. Gollum
  3. Rohan
  4. Orthanc tower
  5. Elessar
  6. Eru
  7. Gandalf’s fire ring
  8. Either Merry or Pippin (the one who backstabbed the Witch King)
  9. Weathertop
  10. Took

ETA : Strider. Motherfucking Strider. How could I miss that one ?

  1. Glamdring
  2. Bilbo
  3. Rivendell
  4. Isengard
  5. Strider
  6. Lorien
  7. Elrond (owner)
  8. Eowyn
  9. At Weathertop
  10. Took

Bonus question, no points
Rate the movie:
Eru, Himself, could not have done a better job

  1. Anduril
  2. Bilbo
  3. Mordor
  4. Orthanc
  5. Strider
  6. Lorien
  7. Vilya
  8. Eowyn
  9. Weathertop
  10. Took
  1. Anduril
  2. Bilbo
  3. Gondor
  4. Orthanc
  5. Strider
  6. Varda
  7. Nenya, the Ring of Adamant, held by Galadriel
  8. Eowyn
  9. On Weathertop
  10. Proudfoot

Rate the movie:
A noble effort given the complicated and lengthy material

  1. Anduril
  2. Smeagol/Gollum
  3. The Shire
  4. Orthanc
  5. Strider
  6. Melkor/Morgoth
  7. Narya
  8. Merry
  9. When he’s standing on the cliff (The Crack of Doom?) and Gollum jumps him and bites off his finger.
  10. Gamgee

ETA: My rating:
A noble effort given the complicated and lengthy material

Thanks for the breather, 5 time champ! I’ve had a lot on my plate lately. My Dad (84 yrs old and lives with us) had a TIA (mini-stroke) on Tuesday morning, and I was at the hospital for two days with him. Then I went back to work on Thursday, and had to get caught up before my engineer left for Scotland. I was off today, but I had 4 different appointments to take care of.

Sheesh!

I’ll post a brand new one Monday morning. (Dad’s doing ok.)

  1. Anduril
  2. Gollum
  3. Gondor
  4. Orthanc
  5. Strider
  6. Manwe
  7. Nenya
  8. Eowyn
  9. At Weathertop
  10. Took
  1. Anduril
  2. Gollum
  3. Gondor
  4. Orthanc
  5. Strider
  6. Mandos
  7. Nenya, the Ring of Gladriel
  8. Eowyn
  9. Weathertop
  10. Took
  1. Anduril
  2. Gollum
  3. Rohan
  4. Isengard
  5. Strider
  6. Oromë
  7. Narya
  8. Faramir
  9. Shelob’s Lair
  10. Gamgee
  1. Anduril
  2. Golem
  3. Gondor
  4. Isengard
  5. Strider
  6. Melkor
  7. Galadriel’s
  8. Eowyn
  9. Weathertop
  10. Gamgee

Bonus question, no points
Rate the movie:
[LIST]

A noble effort given the complicated and lengthy material

  1. Sting
  2. Sam Gamgee
  3. Mordor
  4. Sauron’s Dark Tower
  5. Strider
  6. Lorien
  7. Nenya, Galadriel’s ring
  8. Faramir
  9. Turns invisible at the Prancing Pony
  10. Took

Bonus question, no points

A noble effort given the complicated and lengthy material

Worm I am not familiar with the character Elendriel, it would appear you have conflated Elrond and Galadriel??

Yeah, I have. I was going to write “the Elven Queen”, but decided to show off instead (and look were that got me)

  1. Anduril
  2. Bilbo
  3. Mordor
  4. Orthanc
  5. Strider
  6. Olorin / Gandalf
  7. The one owned by Galadriel
  8. Eowyn
  9. In Mount Doom, right before Gollum bites it off
  10. Took
  1. Anduril
  2. Gollum
  3. Gondor
  4. Orthanc
  5. Strider
  6. Manwe
  7. Narya
  8. Faramir
  9. Amen Sul
  10. Took

Bonus question, no points
Rate the movie:
A noble effort given the complicated and lengthy material

Sheesh, ya’d think the LOTR geeks woulda devoured this one by now.