On an episode of the old “Jeopardy” program, the answer was:
“If you believe in fairies, then you believe in me.”
The question the contestant answered: “Who is Liberace?”
The home audience just heard a second of silence, after which they heard raucous laughter from the studio audience.
Art Fleming related this story on the David Letterman program in the 80s.
On an early 70s game show called “Jackpot” the question was:
“I’m the kind of dance you would expect a Playboy Bunny to perform.”
The contestant’s answer: “The hora.”
That was muted, also.
(Host Geoff Edwards related this story in a TV Guide interview.)
Another time of “The Price is Right,” a contestant was bidding on the showcase, which–at the most–would have been $25,000. She bid $100,000! Barker verified that that’s what she meant. She said “Yes.” Needless to say, it didn’t work out.
On an episode of “The Joker’s Wild,” the contestant was to fill in the next line of this song"
Oh, the weather outside is frightful,
But the fire is so delightfule,
And since we’ve no place to go. . .
(contestants’ answer)
Let it rain, let it rain, let it rain. . . SNOOOOOW!
On a “High Rollers” program, when they came back from the commercial break, host Alex Trebek said that “something had happened to the video from the previous game, and won’t be able to show you what transpired. We can just tell you that [whoever] was the winner.” At least that was the story. Don’t know what really happened, though.
I saw Pee Wee Herman as a contestant on “The Dating Game.” Not Paul Reubens–Pee Wee Herman (although I don’t remember what name he used. It was the first time I had ever seen him, and it was a couple of years later before he became better known, and then later infamous.
A show called “Rhyme and Reason” (or maybe “or”) was played by displaying a line, whereupon the contestant would pick a word that rhymed with it. If the celebrity he/she called on completed a rhyme using the same word, the person scored.
Given line: “Will sex still be great, when I’m 98?”
Nipsey Russell answers: “It might be, but I won’t participate.”
And who could forget Eve “Jan Brady” Plumb’s dumb “Smegma” answer on “The Weakest Link.”